Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

crooked mouth question

Posts

crooked mouth question

#1

crooked mouth question

Adam Cherubini

>I've got a wooden (fitting) plane with a crooked mouth. Yeah its a skewed mouth but forget about that. The mouth opening is wider at one side than the other. I suspect this plane takes a coarser shaving on the wide side. Any chance that's true?

Okay, okay, to the real point. I'm looking to buy a new plane and I want some justification/validation that my old plane isn't good enough. But I'd appreciate an answer to the first question.

Adam

Re: crooked mouth question

#2

Re: crooked mouth question

Michael Recchione

>Adam, it's a testament to your extraordinary skill as a woodworker that you can even get a shaving out of that old piece of junk. Obviously, you need a new plane. There, is that better? :-)

Seriously, doesn't the coarseness of the shaving depend on the depth of the iron, not on the size of the mouth opening? Mouth opening bears on tear-out, but (within limits) not on the coarseness of the shaving. Of course, if the iron is set so that it tries to take a shaving that is thicker than will fit through the mouth, then the plane will just clog. Any finer than that and the coarseness will be determined by the set of the iron.

The thing that could be causing your shavings to be coarser on the wider open side is that the iron isn't angled properly (which is a pain to get right on skewed planes). This is where that lateral adjuster would come in handy :-).

But I suspect you know all that, so let's go with the first argument. Think "miracle the piece of junk works at all!" and "The only thing standing between me and Chippendale is a new plane!". Note: I said "Chippendale", not "The Chippendales" - I don't know you well enough to comment on the latter ;-).

Re: crooked mouth question

#3

Re: crooked mouth question

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>Adam

I'm afraid it's a goner. Not only is the mouth lopsided, it's skew. I can see it from here - the sole is scratched, the sides are worn, and you are having to resort to a piece of wood through the centre to hold the blade in place. What happened to the adjuster? What's this? Dents at the rear - looks hammered.

An ex-plane, mate. Give it a good send-off. Share a couple of beers?

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: crooked mouth question

#4

An ex-plane?

Alice Frampton, UK

>Don't you mean " an ex-chunk of wood with a blade stuck in it"? :~)

Frankly, Adam, I think I can see exactly where you're going wrong. It's either the wrong hat or the wrong breeches. I suggest in-depth testing comparing various hat/breech combinations until you get optimum performance from your plane.

Cheers, Alf

Re: crooked mouth question

#5

Huh?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Yes, of course there's a chance. Is this a ruse to get people here to start using your terminology? Hope it works. :)

Pam

Re: crooked mouth question

#6

Steve Kubien

Adam and the Chippendales

Steve Kubien

>I dunno Mike. Have you seen the April '06 PW? Page's 31 and 32 have Adam leaping through the forest in his (not quite) tighty whitey's. Could be a future for him with a certain 'dance' troupe...but I may not be the right guy to ask.

Sorry Adam. I couldn't resist.

Steve Kubien

runnin' and duckin'

Re: crooked mouth question

#7

Re: crooked mouth question

Andrew F in Australia

>Hi Adam,

Try putting your tongue in the other side of your cheek, the shaving that your plane produces might become even.

It's worth a try.

Perhaps you need to fettle the plane to get an even sole - don't forget to take more off the side where the mouth is closed the most - it should even things up and have your plane working as good as new. But make sure that the sole also remains square so you can shoot with it - you may need to remove timber from the side of the plane as well.

Stanley No5's are on sale at the moment - perhaps you'd be better advised to pick up one of these.

CHeers,

Andrew

Re: crooked mouth question

#8

Steve Kubien

Ok, I'll bite...

Steve Kubien

>My thinking, suspect as it is, would be that the wider mouth on one side won't necessarily make a difference in the thickness of the shaving. Assuming I am seeing things correctly, as long as the edge of the iron protrudes from the sole equally on both sides, it's going to take a uniform shaving. Have I got that right?

Ok Adam, is this a real scenario or are you trying to get some of us thinking again? Man, that hurts! Could ya at least give a guy some warning?!?! If it's a real situation, send me the plane and I'll make it work...someday. Until then, just buy a new plane. Heck, buy a new late 20th or 21st century plane. Who knows, ya might like it. I am tempted to suggest a Bosch 1617 EVS router and hundreds of $$$ worth of bits but then I remember where I am and that you are against the random slaughter of electrons.

Cheers,

Steve Kubien - who despite his preference for hand tools, loves his Bosch 1617

Re: crooked mouth question

#9

Re: crooked mouth question

Paul Kierstead

>Well, in theory one might suggest that the larger mouth on one side could allow the wood to split further ahead, affecting the thickness of the shaving and causing a poorer finish.

I think if you put a micrometer on it, you will find that there is a very significant difference, percentage wise, and you should run, not walk, out to get a new plane before somebody gets hurt.

Do it for the children.

Re: crooked mouth question

#10

Re: crooked mouth question

Rob Lee

>Adam -

I suspect it's a fever...

The period appropriate tool for that is - a fleam!

Don't forget to catch the phlebotic output for making milkpaint....

Cheers -

Rob

(it's a joke!!)

Re: crooked mouth question

#11

Not a joke

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>This is the problem with being a wise guy.

The plane is a universal fillister. There's nothing square left on this plane. With each passing shaving the fillester becomes less flat. I've tried holding it different ways, holding the fence, holding the body to the fillet. just fight every rabbet or fillester I make with this thing. I think its the mouth.

I was wondering if any of you came across this. Maybe somebody would like to try an experiment for me. Skew your frog, then make sure your straight blade is parallel to the sole and then mic the shaving. I think its going to come out fat on the wide mouthed side.

I thought you guys would know this one off the tops of your head. Yeah, I'm kinda looking for an excuse to buy a new tool, but I do want to know the answer.

I think I tried to square the sole to the side. I couldn't go the other way because of the depth stop. And this opened the fence side of the mouth. So when the depth stop touches, the fillester is 3/8" deep at the fillet and 1/2" at the edge. No good.

Adam

Re: crooked mouth question

#12

Fix that Filletster (Fillister)!!!

Paul in NJ

>Adam,

Why not add a new bottom. I'll even bring a chunk of Dogwood next time I see you and you can call it boxing. If it is not worth the work, the Patina and Crafts auctions are coming up soon.

Paul Dzioba

Re: crooked mouth question

#13

Re: Not a joke

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>Adam

The serious response is ...

The size of the mouth is mainly an issue when planing difficult grain (which you know), plus it makes it harder to judge just how finely set the blade projection is. An evenly tight mouth is more likely to produce a predictable, controlled shaving.

Anyway, I am not convinced it is just the mouth. I suspect that the body and/or sole may be skewed or twisted as well. Check these out with a straight edge and a square.

The next is whether the blade is seated firmly on the bed. Has the bed twisted, and/or is the back of the blade still flat?

Planing the sides of the body, and adding a veneer to make a new sole to close up the mouth, are relatively straight forward. My recent dovetail plane was a real mess, with all the faults one could imagine. It is now square and tight, and cuts predictable, even shavings.

Let us know what you have there.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: crooked mouth question

#15

Re: Not a joke - filletster magic bullets...

John, in NJ as well...

>Adam,

Unless its a really rare filletster plane, why not simply let it be and get another one? This one simply didn't survive well over the years. Like Paul said, CRAFTS is coming up so be on the lookout for another, more not-needed-to-be-trued-so-much plane. Should be able to find one for around $40 max.

And, like Paul said, you could add some boxwood/dogwood filler patches to make the throat closer. Alternatively, couldn't you simply grind the blade so it is less (more ?) skewed so that it projects out of the mouth uniformly? That would make the plane easier to handle and give you an even thickness shaving.

*** And anyway, how fine a shaving do you really want to take with this tool? I sort of think that filletster planes should take pretty rank shavings. If you want a nicer finish, go over the cut afterwards with a shoulder plane to clean it up. I always thought filletsters should cut fast, just like plough planes.***

Speaking of plough planes, I have a nice boxwood Greenfield plough plane that had the fence so badly warped and worn that it was nearly unusable. I finally broke down and glued a strip of cherry to the full width of the fence, planed it to be parallel to the skate and wondered afterward why, for so little time doing this simple repair, had I not done this earlier. The plough worked SO MUCH better than when the fence angle was screwed up with respect to the skate.

Over and out,

John

Re: crooked mouth question

#16

Re: Not a joke *LINK*

HC Sakman @ Victoria, BC

>Hi Adam,

I went over couple of these obnoxious planes, which are so due to their age. All 3 of them were well used. I got rid of them all and settled for #45 while I was aiming for a 55. Since I use these tools occasionally and for work, I don't have the time to figure out what exactly is wrong and fix them. There are so many variables in these type of planes and wooden ones in particular are finicky to tune. IMO, once they are out of shape they become real history/mantle piece despite their "intact" appearance.

Get something new (or old-new) is my serious answer to your question. Click the link for something decent.

Chico...


New Fillisters

Re: crooked mouth question

#17

Try this cutie! *LINK*

HC Sakman @ Victoria, BC

>It's absolutely adorable!

Chico...


Ebony Fillister

Re: crooked mouth question

#18

Re: Not a joke

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Adam

As others have suggested, the mouth opening has little to do with the depth of cut. The blade is either too skewed or not enough skewed in the way it is shaped. While a precise angle for the skew of the blade could be calculated from the bedding angle and the amount of skew in the bed, in your case it is obvious which side of the blade is projecting too much and so the angle should be adjusted accordingly. In other words use the performance feedback to adjust the iron angle. You may also be able to see the uneveness by sighting along the sole from the end of the plane.

Re: crooked mouth question

#19

Re: crooked mouth question

ThomD

>The phlebotic output can make good glue. All I use with my LV blind nailer.

Re: crooked mouth question

#20

Re: crooked mouth question

paul womack

> I suspect this plane takes a coarser shaving on the wide side. Any chance that's true?

A careful examination (some people might use a micrometer) of a candidate shaving should answer your question.

As I understand planes, shaving thickness is controlled by blade projection, not mouth width.

BugBear

Re: crooked mouth question

#21

Re: Not a joke

paul womack

>The plane is a universal fillister.

In woodies, Salaman mentions standing, moving and sash as fillister (or rabbet, or rebate) variations.

What (do you claim) is a "universal fillister"?

I suppose a #78 (or similar) could qualify, since they can work in sash and standing modes, but you say you're talking of a wooden plane.

BugBear

Re: crooked mouth question

#22

Re: Not a joke

paul womack

> With each passing shaving the fillester becomes less flat.

Which just shows (by analogy) how effective squaring an edge with a cambered blade is...

BugBear (G, D&R)

Re: crooked mouth question

#23

Re: Not a joke

Rob Lee

>Adam -

If the blade is projecting evenly - It should cut evenly. The mouth geometry will not have an effect on chip thickness.

If the blade bed is tilted, then the iron must be skewed to compensate. (you know the blade bed is tilted if you have even blade projection, the front edge of the mouth is square to the plane side, and the mouth opening appears to be narrower on one side...). Uneven projection is common with a tilted bed if one sets the blade so that the mouth is even, without confirming projection....

Cheers -

Rob

Re: crooked mouth question

#24

Re: Not a joke

Michael Recchione

>I (and others) have already that the size of the mouth opening doesn't determing the thickness of the shaving. But let's think about why the mouth opening would be wider on one side than on the other. If we assume that the plane didn't start out that way, then the only way for one side of the mouth opening to be wider than the other would be for more wood to have been removed from it than the other side as a result of either wear (unlikely) or "maintenance and tuning".

You say you squared the sole to the side. Did you make the corresponding adjustment to the skew angle of the iron? If not, it's projecting unevenly, with more of it sticking out on the "wide mouth" side.

Projection aside, the fact that squaring the sole to one side resulted in an uneven mouth opening leads me to believe that you squared the sole with respect to the wrong side (or that the plane body is twisted or cupped in some way). If the sole is square to the side that bears on the shoulder of the rabbet (the opposite side to the fence), then making sure the projection of the iron is parallel to the sole should fix you up. Alternatively, adjusting the skew angle to project less on the deeper cutting side could be a quick fix.

It might be fun to monkey with this plane, but maybe it's time to get a new one anyway. However, you can learn a lot about what makes a difference by playing with this one. Maybe it would be good to do both.

Re: crooked mouth question

#25

Re: Try this cutie!

Adam Cherubini

>Did you mean "Try this cutie!" Or "Try this, cutie!"?

Adam