Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Domestic, Figured & Live Edge Hardwoods in Stock. Best Prices for Serious Woodworkers.

Well it's no $2000.00 Stanley 212 but... *LINK*

Posts

Well it's no $2000.00 Stanley 212 but... *LINK*

#1

Well it's no $2000.00 Stanley 212 but... *LINK*

Scott Burr, Freezing rain in Ben Lomond,CA?

>I think somebody did awfull good here.

Todd, I do I see a vacation with Ms. Jazz...


Hmmmmm

Re: Well it's no $2000.00 Stanley 212 but... *LINK*

#2

Re: 8K knife

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I had marked that thing to watch it too; must be I am not the only one that has Todd's 'bay window marked. I thought maybe it would bring $800 or at most $1000 when I first saw it and it was at $353 or something like that. That is unbelievable; guess I will be keeping my eyes peeled for knives in the wild now ;) I think Todd should buy everyone a round.

Re: Well it's no $2000.00 Stanley 212 but... *LINK*

#3

I doubt it

HC Sakman

>I doubt that auction/sale will complete. What's so spacial about this knife that somebody's willing to pay that much money?

Chico...

Re: Well it's no $2000.00 Stanley 212 but... *LINK*

#4

So, educate me. *LINK*

cooper suter

>Todd,

Got time to give us a little tutorial on what made this Marbles so special;

Age? Model? Condition? Material? Size? Original sheath? Good photos and text? The Mrs. Deadhorse reputation? Two idiots colliding? Market timing? Etc?

How was is it so appreciably different than the couple I sold?

Mine went for the low end of what I though they might.

No complaints, they were cheap.

Knives have always been tough for me to get a handle on, I get alot of them, and can reasonably guess which are better than average, but can't say I'm comfortable predicting value w/any accuracy.

Coop


$64.00 Marbles

Re: Well it's no $2000.00 Stanley 212 but... *LINK*

#5

Other non $8000 knife  *LINK*

cooper suter

>


$68 Marbles

Re: Well it's no $2000.00 Stanley 212 but... *LINK*

#6

Re: I doubt it

cooper suter

>Looks like four people were in over $4000.

I'd say it's a pretty good knife.

Good odds Todd'll have the scratch to buy that round.

Re: Well it's no $2000.00 Stanley 212 but... *LINK*

#7

By the way... I hope it does complete.

HC Sakman

>By all means, it's a great sale and I hope it does complete for Todd.

I can hear Todd saying: "Yeah I found it in the bottom of a barrel full of rusty screwdrivers, chisels and human bones. I picked the entire barrel for $5 from an old lady. (I am giggling so hard I can hardly type!) LOL....

I really would like to know why this knife is worth that much though.

Chico...

Re: Well it's no $2000.00 Stanley 212 but... *LINK*

#8

Re: So, educate me.  *LINK*

mikew

>


Todd's response on WoodNet

Re: Well it's no $2000.00 Stanley 212 but... *LINK*

#9

Thanks Mike

HC Sakman

>I read the explanation. I still have a hard time accepting the fact that a hunting knife can be worth $8k. I guess it happens. As long as the buyer and seller, both are happy I'll be just left with my wondering thoughts.

Chico...

Re: Well it's no $2000.00 Stanley 212 but... *LINK*

#10

Re: Thanks Mike

Frank D. in Montreal

>New hunting knives by reputable makers can sell for 2 or $3000, even more. If there are collectors, there's a market. Anything goes after that.

Re: Well it's no $2000.00 Stanley 212 but... *LINK*

#11

Re:Two reasons it went that high

Dale Stansbery

>First, simply more than one person wanted it badly enough to bid it that high. Secondly, having bid on a couple of Todd's auctions and lost, and watched others, it's obvious to me that he has a following of buyers that have the utmost confidence in his honest and accurate descriptions as well as his integrity, and are unafraid to pay a premium for his stuff.

Re: Well it's no $2000.00 Stanley 212 but... *LINK*

#12

Marbles

todd hughes

>All Marbles knives and axes are pretty collectable esp. in good condition but the one I sold on ebay was quite special..obviously, The marbles co. started out making an unusual little axe that had a folding guard which they called a saftey axe. These can be pretty pricey when you find them today and i have a couple including a near mint first type which has a 2 hole eye and still with it's original belt holter. In 1901 they started to make knives with the first model being the Ideal model. The one I sold was an Ideal made in around 1903 and had the early peened washer that attached the pommel. These early knives were also marked M.S.A co. for Marbles Saftey Axe co. and are worth much more then the later knives just marked Marbles.Also most Marbles Ideals had 5 or 6 in. blades and stacked leather handles with aluminum pommels. Some had Stag pommels which is much more desirable and a few had stag handles and pommels which is even more desirable and a very few had the long 8 in. blade which is much, much, more desirable.The early tube sheaths are very hard to find in any kind of condition and adds to the price.

....So what I had was an early 100 year plus old MSA marked knife, with the very desirable stag handle and in the ultra desirable 8 in. lentgh with it's original tube sheath and everything in excellent condition.Really a knife that had everything. I think also the fact that it was never monkeyed with unlike most others on the market that have been worked on didn't hurt it either.

....When I bought it at auction I knew it was a good knife , I paid $275 and would have gone much higher, but didn't know it was that good. I was thinking about $1,000. Was on for about an hour when a guy offered me $500 to stop the auction.By next morning I had offers of $1,000 and $2,500. Guy called me and told me not to stop the auction because it is a vaualble knife and worth between 7-10G. Went to $2,900 pretty quick and sat there till the last day. During this time I had 2 offers from 2 different guys of $5,000 to stop the auction. I never stop an auction though have to admit was tempting but you have to understand the only reason someone would ask you to do so is because they think they will get it cheaper that way. Over the years I have refused many many offeres and not once did it sell for less then was offered and most times much much more. This case it sat at around $5,500 last few hours till the last 12 seconds and then jumped $3,000 so of course I was smart not to take the offers though I guess these tactics work with some slow head bidders.

...I just got off the phone with the high bidder and I have no doubt he will be paying me, pretty good feedback with only one neg. for not paying. The back up bidder has called me twice on the phone and I know if I have any problims with the high bidder , which i don't expect, he will buy it.

...I have another 8 in. ideal though with the leather handle but it is in my personal collection so I don't think i will be selling it. Sure it is nice to make $8G but to me it is the "Sport" that is more of a kick...I like to buy something I know about and that I hunted down out smarting others to get it and then do well with selling it.....That doing this allows me to do what I want when I want to ain't to bad either, eh? .....Todd

Re: Well it's no $2000.00 Stanley 212 but... *LINK*

#13

Re:Two reasons it went that high

HC Sakman

>I was referring to the item ONLY. I know Todd, I didn't come here yesterday.

You didn't really have to be a character witness ;-)

Chico...

Re: Well it's no $2000.00 Stanley 212 but... *LINK*

#14

WOW

HC Sakman

>Good one Todd, congrats to you.

Also thanks for the info.

Every field of collectibles have some really high prized items.....I guess.

Duesenbergs are going for 3+ million dollars

Chico...

Re: Well it's no $2000.00 Stanley 212 but... *LINK*

#15

Congrats Todd! & thanks for the story

Dave Thompson

>

Re: Well it's no $2000.00 Stanley 212 but... *LINK*

#16

Great story Todd...and...

Christopher Fitch@Memphis

>Congrats on your profit!

:)

About the only thing I have of any real value is the item pictured below (I can't count any of my hand tools...they pale in comparison to this).

It's a spy glass (telescope) that my grandfather gave to me when I was about 11 or 12. It's been passed down a few generations...(I think 5 or maybe 6 now counting me). One of my ancestors was a captain of a clipper ship and this was his spyglass (1850's or maybe 1860's..I'm not sure on the date). I showed it once to one of my college professors who is a serious antique collector and he was shocked. He'd seen some similar Civil War era spyglasses used by soldiers but nothing like this. We talked about it and he pointed out that it must have been considered high quality since it was repaired more than one time, and with silver welding. You can see the welds in the pictures. He said the military glasses were much shorter than this one.

It still works, but it's a bit dim and, unfortunately, the main lens has picked up some scratches over time. The last lunar eclipse we had, I sat out in my backyard and watched it in this.

On a side note, this professor's most prized antique is a 400+ year old table that is wrapped in leather with designs in the leather. He uses it as a coffee table (very carefully).

P.S. I have another item I'll show one day...it's not like this, but it does have a slightly interesting story and Lee Valley now sells one which is a bit surprising. Oh yeah and my grandfather also gave me a knife, I'll have to find that too.


img

Re: Well it's no $2000.00 Stanley 212 but... *LINK*

#17

One more....

Christopher Fitch@Memphis

>picture of the glass fully extended.

Notice the length and the welds.


img

Re: Well it's no $2000.00 Stanley 212 but... *LINK*

#18

Re: 8K knife

ernie miller

>What I don't understand is why Todd would owe any one for his hard work and knowlage. Some one does good and all the sudden they owe every one for nothing? I would be willing to bet Todd has a skunk out in the barn and I don't see any one mailing him a check to make it easier on him. I todd dosent have a skunk it is because he has worked to learn what not to buy nad get burned or has learned that some time it is better to sell somthing and get what you can to lose a little lesss than you would holding it for ever.

Re: Well it's no $2000.00 Stanley 212 but... *LINK*

#19

Re: hey Ernie

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>Sounds like you could use a round ;) only kidding. I'm just jealous is all. Thinking of all the tools I could buy if I happened to be the one selling that knife.

Re: Well it's no $2000.00 Stanley 212 but... *LINK*

#20

Re: hey Ernie

ernie miller

>Sorry I just get hit with that at work all the time I work up a deal and every one thinks they should get a chunk for nothing. Nothing personal. Fresh cool well watter for me on a hot summer day would be fine.