WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Stanley/Record H/R`s

Posts

Stanley/Record H/R`s

#1

Stanley/Record H/R`s

John Edwards

>GG`s,

I have a complete set of never used H/R`s for the Record 405 (Records` version of the Stanley 45 combination plane, Jeff). These cutters will fit both the Stanley 45 and Record 405. Is one plane perhaps better suited then another ?

Can anybody shed light on how well these types of cutters work compared to a dedicated set of wooden H/R`s ?

Any links or comments on how to use `em ? Or even a link on using the wooden ones ?

Maybe someone who has a good set of wooden H/R`s might want to trade ?

Thanks

John Edwards

Where we are about to have some of the coldest weather this winter.

Re: Stanley/Record H/R`s

#2

Well John...

Scott Burr in rainy Ben Lomond,CA

>Do you have the bases to match the cutters? If not, you got jack and you should just send them to me. They will do you no good anyhow. If you do, well... YOU SUCK!

H&R's for Stanley�s/Records are good for straight grained wood for the most part. Hardwood/jungle varities require a skewed blade set at 50 deg. or so angle.

You have something very special IMHO John.

Just listen to me...you don't want them, they will cause you nothing but trouble. Email me, and send you my adress and you can get rid of those foul devices.

Re: Stanley/Record H/R`s

#3

Re: Well John...

John Edwards

>Well Scott, I do have the complete set. blades and castings. since you think they are bad for me I guess I have no choice but to sell them. Check in the Classified section for details.

Re: Stanley/Record H/R`s

#4

Man o Man...

Scott Burr in rainy Ben Lomond,CA

>I was just kidding John. I wish I the cash so I could get them.

Re: Stanley/Record H/R`s

#5

cheap price John.

Dave Thompson

>John, that seems a bit cheap. I don't think it was more than two months ago, I posted an e-bay link here selling the exact same thing you have. I can't find the post at the moment to confirm, but my fuzzy memory says it went for more than $700...

I suppose I should buy it from you and sell it on e-bay huh? ;-)

Why don't you give them a try before you sell them. At least you'll have the answer to half of your question, and you can answer that question next time it comes up.

enjoy,

Dave

Re: Stanley/Record H/R`s

#6

Re: wooden H & R's

Barryvabeach

>John if you want a complete half set ( not the first or last confusing term when dealing with these planes - complete half sets are typically 18 planes )of wooden HR's one great source is Tony Murland. I read somewhere that there are basically three levels - from highest to lowest in price - (1) all 18 planes are by the same maker and have the same owners mark so they were originally purchased as a set (2) all 18 planes by the same maker but different owners marks - so they were not sold together as a set - and may vary greatly in age ( like buying a stanley 1950 number 3 and a 1980 number 4) and harlequin set - each pair is generally by the same maker but have different makers in the set. While there is some debate, some suggest that you want the same maker for any pair because the numbering is not consistent across manufacturers so a #12 hollow by one manufacturer may not be the mirror image of a #12 by a different manufacturer. Others argue that you don't need the hollow to match the round anyway and that you can save a lot of money by buying them individually ( or by pairs ) and most users won't need a complete half set and they won't use all 18. Tony's site lists a harlequin set for $425 in the wooden plane section http://www.antiquetools.co.uk/tools.htm

and he lists one set of H & R all by the same maker and owner for $795 ( #1463) and another set all by the same maker - but different owners for $795 (#1464 ) in his recent additions page. Of course he contradicts one of the rules I heard listed above in that he is selling the set with one owners stamp plus two planes not normally included in a half set for the same price as the mixed set from one owner. One hting most would agree on is that the wooden h & r should do a better job that the Stanley once they are set up right - good luck with your sale.

Re: Stanley/Record H/R`s

#7

Call Larry Williams or Don McConnell

Wiley Horne--Glendora, CA

>

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.