Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

Posts

Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

#1

Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

chichi

>Is the sharpness of a tool more related to the blade geometry ie. bevel angle or the honing of the surface. Can a 30 deg. bevel honed well be as sharp as a 25 deg. bevel.honed well? I know that taking this to the extreme would result in a very sharp but weak edge, but couldnt a few degrees make up for a lot of honong?

Just curious by one who is not very good at sharpening.

Bob

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

#2

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

ThomD

>Depends how one defines sharpness. Personally I consider sharpness to be the edge polish and independant of the many other factors that determine performance. So sharpness is like finish sanding a project, all about getting an even complete job, down through the grits. Of course one can sharpen without abrasives, for instnace filing, chemicals...

I prefer the concept of cutting power, drawn from the knife field to describe the overall cutting capability of an edge. This would include the other stuff like the way in which the edge was refined, angle of scratches, bevel angles, shape away from the edge, profile shape, etc...

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

#3

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>An edge is formed at the conjunction of two planes, so sharpness is independent of the angle. Either the edge formed by the two planes' meeting is sharp or it's not.

Pam

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

#4

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

ThomD

>Not on a gouge it isn't. Go to bed! I take it back, it's probably later here.

Good point though in a theoretical sense it's sharp if the edge is reduced in thickness to the extent possible, whatever the means of "polishing" it, if any. Like making scrapers out of cut glass,

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

#5

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I'm just taking a break from baby sitting a few hospitals' servers.

It is the same for gouges. You just have to look at any given point however infintesimal.

Pam

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

#6

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>I am not a physicist, and don't even play one on tv. But will tell you what I have figured out. Pam is right, any edge coming to a point is sharp. Sharpness is not a function of geometry, it is simple science; you polish two edges until the two edges meet; the size of the scratches left by whatever is used to hone the edges will determine how sharp the edge is.

However, the smaller the angle the two edges meet at, the easier it will be for them to penetrate wood. The wood has to go somewhere as the edge of the blade is forced into the wood; less metal on the edge means less wood that has to be moved. But also keep in mind that a thinner edge will break down more quickly, thus comes the compromise; a smaller bevel angle means the iron penetrates better but will need to be sharpened more often. I have not experimented a bunch with different bevel angles because I am not building the space shuttle, I am simply planing wood. I read that a 30� angle works good, tried it, and it works for me. Some of my paring chisels are sharpened at 25�.

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

#7

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Bob

While a sharp edge is usually defined as the single point where two sides meet, this is simplistic in regard to woodworking needs. My response here is also rather simplistic, but I consider the follow few points to be central.

Firstly, one should talk of "penetration" to refer to the ability of the blade to cut. A blade honed at 20 degrees (like a paring chisel) will have greater penetration than a blade honed to the same degree but at 30 degrees (such as a chisel designed for chopping). Press down on a razor blade <:>)> then press down on a something nice and thick. Of course the bevel angle is chosen also for edge durability, but that is not relevant here, just a compromise factor.

Secondly, we might also talk of "smoothness" (although I recall Lyn called it something else the last time I decribed this point). The smoother the edge (an 8000 waterstone will produce a smoother edge than a 4000 waterstone), the less resistance in penetrating the wood. Of course, this smoother edge will also create a smoother cut since fewer serrations are transfered to the wood surface. Incidentally, this is the reason I hone my scrub blades to 8000 (where some might only go as far as 1200) since I need all the help I can get to penetrate the hard Aussie woods I use. Here it is not about surface finish, it is instead about making the task easier.

My perception (and limited experience in this regard) says high angle plane blades, such as those used in bevel up configurations (e.g. honed at 48 degrees to produce a 60 degree cutting angle, assuming a 12 degree bed), have a smaller window than lower angled plane blades such as those used in a bevel down cofiguration (e.g. such as those with a 25 or 30 degree bevel but a 60 degree bed). Not that the former are any less "sharp", but the higher bevel angle has less penetration and subsequent wear affects it more quickly. Just my perception, mind you.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

#8

I agree

Adam Cherubini

>This makes sense to me. I think penetration,i.e. producing a shaving etc has to do with geometry. Taking that initial cut has to do with honing.

Adam

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

#9

My guess

woodburnbob

>Chichi, if I read your post correctly, you are asking the question: given that I can't get a 30 angle very sharp (I think, because I'm not very good at honing and polishing the edge), if I change the angle to 25 degrees, will I get my blades sharp without having to try to hone and polish the edge?

My opinion is: probably not.

Why don't you tell us more about your whole technique of sharpening an edge from forming the initial grind to finishing up. My guess is that somewhere in there you are degrading your edge in the process you use.

I for one spent a lot of my life unable to get a tool very sharp. Five years ago this changed completely. Let us hear more. Bob

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

#10

Effect of Bevel Angles on Sharpness

Steve Elliott

>I've done some experiments that test sharpness at different bevel angles, and have compared how those bevel angles affect edge wear. Here's what I've found:



  • A well-sharpened edge at a smaller bevel angle "seems" sharper by all the usual tests, such as shaving arm hair and slicing into the edge of newsprint. My standard test involves cutting thread, but the perception of greater sharpness at more acute angles is independent of the testing method.


  • For any blade (A2 at Rc62, high carbon at Rc64, etc.) and a given wood species, there is a limit to how acute the bevel can be made without having the edge degrade quickly due to chipping or rolling. For good edge durability, it is important to keep the angle of the cutting edge at or above this lower limit. (For planing hardwoods, this limit is somewhere between 30 and 35 degrees, higher than I had expected.)


  • More acute bevel angles that are above this lower limit last longer than larger bevel angles.




Your idea of using a more acute angle to make up for less-than-optimal honing would work if the original bevel angle was larger than it needed to be. If decreasing the bevel angle put it below the lower limit, the edge would degrade too quickly.


Details of my experiment with bevel angles can be found here.

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

#11

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

ThomD

>Then it's not a plane.

That sounds noble. I can't claim anything like that myself.

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

#12

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I never knew there were size requirements to define a plane, regardless of how noble it sounds. :)

Pam

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

#13

Re: Dull edges often seem sharp

ThomD

>Case in point are all those Ginsu knives, and Miracle Blades with serated edges. I have some of those that cut like crazy yet you could land a plane on the dull edges. This is why sharp and cutting power are two different things. you can concentrate a lot of power on the dull edge of a seration so it still cuts.

I have a plane like that, Used it away from my stone for 6 months, it cut everything in sight from mahogany to fiberglass, it was so dull you could run your finger along the edge without getting cut. But it had great geometry. It was a japanese roughing plane and it would hook onto and peel back anything, as long as the blade projected enough to have a positive angle of attack. Not pretty but it worked fine.

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

#14

Serrated Edges

Steve Elliott

>I've never used a Ginsu knife or Miracle Blade, but have heard of so-called self-sharpening blades which degrade by chipping. The chips themselves have sharp edges, so the blades can still effectively make slicing cuts.

My tests on an M2 blade made by Academy Saws have suggested that the M2 forms very tiny sharp points as the edge wears. These sharp points make the edge test sharper on my thread-cutting test than is actually justified by the blade's performance in planing wood. The blade is a real champ in edge retention, like your Japanese roughing plane blade. "Not pretty but works fine" is a good kind of blade for a lot of tools, but maybe not smoothing planes.

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

#15

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

ThomD

>There isn't a size requirement, but it does require something other than two lines connected at an angle. As well as I remember it anyway. So far the kids are still too young for that part of the curriculum to have kicked in yet.

Your hospital work sounds noble.

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

#16

Japanese roughing plane

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Thom, I'd like to hear/see more about this one. Is the blade heavily cambered? Wide mouth? What's the bedding angle?

Thanks,

Pam

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

#17

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>A line has width. Oh, well, angels on the head of a pin time.

The work isn't noble, even though they are neonatal intensive care units, just the vestige of a career. And, btw, the system has only been down about a day in total over the last three years. The contract should end this month or next.

Pam

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

#18

Re: Serrated Edges

ThomD

>Agreed, I've heard that too. The Miracle blades are dull after a while but still cut pretty well. I bought some just to compare to the "respectable" knives in the kitchen. Certainly a well designed blade concept. No knives are perfect, but these ones are certainly worth 30 bucks a set. It's like a bullet, nose is not that sharp but with enough energy behind it cuts like nobody's business.

My plane started out sharp, sharp enough to finish plane though the opening was too large for best results. It's the reverse of ginsu knife, most of the surface on the boat are 1.5" wide or norrower, and useualy not harder than sitka, or pretty narrow. so it's a wide blade on a narrow surface. once it's hooked it, it can't let go cause th Japanese plane has anchor geometry, and self sets. Usualy the surface was fairly shinny. Eventually it did get too dull to use, but the boat was built. In performance a bit like using a scrub plane. I wish LV still sold those blades.

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

#19

Re: Japanese roughing plane

ThomD

>It was a straight edge, at the time I wasn't into camber. Really wide mouth, and it was either 40 or 35 degrees, I'll check. LV $10.50 65mm blade. White Oak dai.

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

#20

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>I thought two points define a line...3 points define a plane. Been wrong before,probably wrong again:-)JR

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

#21

Re: Serrated Edges

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>This is an amazing coincidence. I got distracted while reading this message, checked on email, received my first ever spam from Miracle Blade offering me a $300 value for only $31, as seen on tv, blah, blah. :)

Pam

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

#22

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I don't know that Euclidean geometry is sufficient these days, Joe, what will all we know about atoms and their contents, to say nothing of nanotechnology; but I'll grant you 3 points for defining a plane, however infintesimal those points are.

Pam

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

#23

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>True. I'm still having trouble with electron theory vs. conventional theory with regard to automobile electronics :-)JR

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

#24

Re: Serrated Edges

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>It's an omen...You must buy them. Or not :-)JR

Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?

#25

Re: Serrated Edges

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Have to use up those Ginsu ones first, the two sets I bought for $5 each set to serve as throwaways to be used between the time we sold our house in Falmouth and when we bought a house in Austin. Meanwhile, 5-1/2 years later, they're still cutting strong, crummy handles as ever...

Pam