Re: Shaarpness-Geometry or honing?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>Bob
While a sharp edge is usually defined as the single point where two sides meet, this is simplistic in regard to woodworking needs. My response here is also rather simplistic, but I consider the follow few points to be central.
Firstly, one should talk of "penetration" to refer to the ability of the blade to cut. A blade honed at 20 degrees (like a paring chisel) will have greater penetration than a blade honed to the same degree but at 30 degrees (such as a chisel designed for chopping). Press down on a razor blade <:>)> then press down on a something nice and thick. Of course the bevel angle is chosen also for edge durability, but that is not relevant here, just a compromise factor.
Secondly, we might also talk of "smoothness" (although I recall Lyn called it something else the last time I decribed this point). The smoother the edge (an 8000 waterstone will produce a smoother edge than a 4000 waterstone), the less resistance in penetrating the wood. Of course, this smoother edge will also create a smoother cut since fewer serrations are transfered to the wood surface. Incidentally, this is the reason I hone my scrub blades to 8000 (where some might only go as far as 1200) since I need all the help I can get to penetrate the hard Aussie woods I use. Here it is not about surface finish, it is instead about making the task easier.
My perception (and limited experience in this regard) says high angle plane blades, such as those used in bevel up configurations (e.g. honed at 48 degrees to produce a 60 degree cutting angle, assuming a 12 degree bed), have a smaller window than lower angled plane blades such as those used in a bevel down cofiguration (e.g. such as those with a 25 or 30 degree bevel but a 60 degree bed). Not that the former are any less "sharp", but the higher bevel angle has less penetration and subsequent wear affects it more quickly. Just my perception, mind you.
Regards from Perth
Derek