Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Reach the woodworkers who ACTUALLY BUY

preferred construction material for shooting board

Posts

preferred construction material for shooting board

#1

preferred construction material for shooting board

bill tindall

>I am regretting not knowing about shooting boards years ago. I made a small one, presuming that the first attempt would not be optimum. It stays on the bench ready to use, and now I want a full sized model.

This may seem a dumb question, but I have no experience with MDF. I may be too quick to associate it with the dreadful stuff that was used for underlayment for floors many years ago.

1. Which is best for the task- baltic birch plywood or MDF?

2. How thick should the top layer be-the edge the plane rides against? Seems like thicker than 1/4" (width of metal beside plane iron)is wasted unless there is a less obvious requirement? I thought I would use 1/4" baltic birch with a strip of maple for this wear edge. ?.

Re: preferred construction material for shooting board

#2

Re: preferred construction material for shooting b

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>Bill, I put a layer of laminate over the ramp to act as a wear strip and provide a slippery surface for the plane. That goes over MDF on mine, but I don't think MDF vs. ply would matter a great deal. MDF does seem a bit heavier, perhaps a small advantage for wear if you don't apply a laminate strip.

Downside of the white laminate I had lying around is that it leaves ugly white smudge marks on the plane.

Best, Ted

Re: preferred construction material for shooting board

#3

Re: preferred construction material for shooting b

Norman (Ottawa, Ont.)

>Bill, good questions...

I echo what Ted said about MDF, it should be fine.

It has the most important quality... flat.

About the thickness of the baseboard..

You can probably get away with a thinner 1/4 in. board but

I would imagine the reasoning for a thicker board is to have a more stable, flat platform for the registration of the piece being "shot"..

In my opinion, anything less that 3/8 in. is more likely to cup and warp unless very well fastened or even glued down to the bottom platform.. Then of course the thinner the edge, the more likelihood of rocking the plane.. And, if you need to glue the baseboard down to keep it flat, it makes it difficult to replace later on if necessary.

Having said that, I've never actually tried a thinner baseboard.. I usually work with baltic birch scraps I have around, nominally 3/4 in. stuff..

Norman

Re: preferred construction material for shooting board

#4

Re: preferred construction material for shooting b

Frank D. in Montreal

>I use leftover stair risers (I used to do some carpentry and I still have a big pile of them), which are "3/4" MDF veneered with maple. I have the advantages of MDF (stable, flat) as well as a nice wooden surface to work on. I think 1/4" MDF would be fine for the bottom board, IIRC Charlesworht recommends a 1/4" bottom board. All it really does is keep the plane off the bench. If you store it correctly, 1" total thickness should be plenty thick.

2� from someone who still has a lot to learn.

Re: preferred construction material for shooting board

#5

Plans for David Charlesworth's shooting board *LINK*

Ian in Sydney

>Bill

Plans for David Charlesworth's shooting board are mounted on the Lie Nielsen Australia web site, this link should work


Plans for David Charlesworth's shooting board

Re: preferred construction material for shooting board

#6

Re: wear

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>Bill -

On my shooting boards the plane rides on a thin layer of jelly wax. I see no wear anywhere after years of enthusiastic use. Material is scrap 3/4" plywood.

Ed

Re: preferred construction material for shooting board

#7

Re: Plans for David Charlesworth's shooting board

tonyr

>Any thoughts on how the fixtures (miter/bird's house) are supposed to be fixed to the shooting board -- the plans don't seem to indicate this. thanks, tony.

Re: preferred construction material for shooting board

#8

Jelly Wax?

bill tindall

>At first envisioned this this miracal lubricant that enabled the plane to float effortlessly on a bed of gelatinous material like a skate on ice and wondered where it could be obtained. Then I realized you were talking about parafin wax. We do freezer jam so I haven't seen that stuff in a while.

Re: preferred construction material for shooting board

#9

snooze alert

bill tindall

>there is a saying here in E. TN "he's so slow ya gotta drive a stake in the ground to see him move". I ran the shooting board video at 8X and it moved along just about right. I fell asleep 4 times in the sharpening tape. Counting strokes on the stone is even better than counting sheep.

Re: preferred construction material for shooting board

#10

Yup, aka paraffin wax :)

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>

Re: preferred construction material for shooting board

#11

Re: preferred construction material for shooting b

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>My big one is made from two sheets of 3/4" baltic birch plywood. I find it to be uncomfortably heavy, but there's an advantage to that when used on sawhorses or the top of a toolbox, instead of the bench. I'm pretty sure you would find 2 sheets of 3/4" MDF way too heavy for convenience. I suspect you'd try to make do with the little one, even when insufficient for the task, and the big one would gather dust against the wall. Also, if you suffer from messy bench syndrome, like I do, just putting away enough tools to make room on the bench for the big one would also be inhibiting.

Re: preferred construction material for shooting board

#12

Fixing the mitre board to the shooting board

Ian in Sydney

>I think that david just holds the mitre board or bird's mouth against the rear rail of the shooting board.

His technique is to get the mitre angle (on the board) fairly close and then adjust the piece being shot to a precise fit using shims.

If you want a permanent attachment you couild always sscrew from the underside.

Re: preferred construction material for shooting board

#13

Re: Plans for David Charlesworth's shooting board

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>So David uses the bench as the base for the plane? I suspect this isn't all that great of an idea, even for a new bench, since then the plane would tilt with every bump and could tilt with some holes.

Pam

Re: preferred construction material for shooting board

#14

Re: Plans for David Charlesworth's shooting board

paul womack

>since then the plane would tilt with every bump and could tilt with some holes.

I suspect DC's bench has a lot in common with Ian Kirby's.

Further, there's a teensy omission in the DVD. DC normally uses a thin sheet of MDF to proect the bench, but during the DVD shoot there was no MDF at Lie-Nielsen!! Evidently TLN is a solid wood fan...

BugBear

Re: preferred construction material for shooting board

#15

Re: Plans for David Charlesworth's shooting board

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I have no idea what Ian Kirby's bench is like, but I suppose you mean it's perfectly level, all in order, and the like. I was cautioning those who might follow David's example without such a paragon of a bench.

I didn't see the dvd. Were these photos screen shots?

Pam

Re: preferred construction material for shooting board

#16

Re: Plans for David Charlesworth's shooting board

Alice Frampton, UK

>The first two aren't, I'm pretty sure. It's a shame the importance of a flat bench and/or mdf beneath still seems to be getting overlooked. David and I had, erm, a small misunderstanding about that after I reviewed the shooting DVD, but I stand by my view that it's an important omission. I agree with you, Pam, it needs to be pointed out for the benefit of those who won't otherwise know.

Cheers, Alf

Re: preferred construction material for shooting board

#17

Re: Plans for David Charlesworth's shooting board

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Thanks for the confirmation, Alice. Hard to imagine (that was for you, Paul) that there are no big orange boxes near enough to LN so they could have run out for mdf or similar.

Pam

Re: preferred construction material for shooting board

#18

Re: Plans for David Charlesworth's shooting board

paul womack

>I have no idea what Ian Kirby's bench is like, but I suppose you mean it's perfectly level, all in order, and the like.

Kirby once claimed (put it down to rhetoric) that a "proper" workbench should be flat to a thou... !

This claim is a running gag in some neander circles.

I guess ya' had to be there :-)

BugBear

Re: preferred construction material for shooting board

#19

Re: Plans for David Charlesworth's shooting board

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>That's a great goal; but I'd rather not have to mic the bench and reflatten the top every time I turn around. :)

Pam