Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Finishing Questions:

Posts

Finishing Questions:

#1

Finishing Questions:

Patrick Wheatley

>So, this past weekend I finished up my very own version of the Roubo bench. It may not be exactly as Chris details in WW magazine but it is darn close and I love my new tool. The final step is finishing the top. I have planed it flat with my #7 and am ready for the final sanding before applying the finish. I have decided to go with Danish oil and paste wax, the top is Spruce (construction lumber from Home Despot). Here are my questions.

I think 3 coats of oil will do the trick. When I apply the oil should I just wipe it on, or should I sand it in, at least for the first coat and then wipe on the other two.

If I am to sand it in, what grit should I use? I am thinking of using a 120 garnet (or what ever I can find at home Despot) and then using steel wool between the coats to remove the slurry produced by the sand paper.

Paste Wax: can I use any type of paste wax? Does it really matter?

As you can see finishing techniques mystify me, this experience will go a long way in helping me learn something new that I can apply to other projects I have planned.

Thanks for all your help!

Pat

Re: Finishing Questions:

#2

Re: Finishing Questions:

I'm Dave Too

>Buy Bob Flexner's book on finishing.

Re: Finishing Questions:

#3

Re: Finishing Questions:

paul womack

>I think 3 coats of oil will do the trick. When I apply the oil should I just wipe it on, or should I sand it in,

The Workbench Book (shush, Adam!) has some guys pointing out that a pretty, shiny, super smooth benchtop invites the possibility of workpieces scooting around a little too easily for comfort.

BugBear

Re: Finishing Questions:

#4

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Finishing Questions:

Jack Guzman from Maine

>You gotta remember,that fine piece of furniture you just built is a work surface.It's gonna get beat up.No need to make it pretty,just a little oil to repel glue and keep coffee stains from soaking in.Some don't bother using any finish.I used tung oil.---Jack

Re: Finishing Questions:

#5

Re: Finishing Questions:

Dean J in MN

>I'd skip sanding, maybe put some BLO on it and go to work.

Why skip sanding? You are going to embed grit into the top, which is going to kill your plane next time you flatten your top. Granted, next time you flatten the top it is going to be dirty any probably be hard on your blade, so maybe that isn't a big issue. But, I don't think you need to treat a benchtop like a table top, I can still see a few plane tracks from flattening, they don't effect the use of the bench.

FWIW, my top has a few coats of BLO, and now and then I clean it off with paste wax. As for wax causing issues with a Roubo style setup, where the wood is not captured between a tail vise/dog -- I found that bench height turned out to be more important than using/not using wax, I recently lowered my bench 2 inches and the biggest effect was the ease of keeping the wood in place, I'm using battens less and less for simple linear planing.

-Dean

Re: Finishing Questions:

#6

And they're exactly right.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: Finishing Questions:

#7

Re: Finishing Questions:

Michael Recchione

>I'm with the few coats of BLO, skip the sanding crowd on this one. The main idea is that, if you use the bench for assembly as well as other stuff, a few coats of BLO will allow you to just pop the glue blobs off when they harden. Other than that, a bench doesn't need any finish at all. If you really want to use a paste wax, Johnson's would be a good choice because it's not slippery. But it's really not necessary.

As an aside, I remember in the chapter on Luthiery workbenches in the The Workbench Book, Landis talked about one guy (was his name Schneider? - I don't have the book with me here at work...) who, as the first thing he did after building his bench, gouged it with a chisel to remind himself that it was a workbench and not a piece of furniture. I don't know about anyone else, but there was certainly a lesson in that for me.

Re: Finishing Questions:

#8

Steve Kubien

Re: Finishing Questions:

Steve Kubien

>Hi Patrick,

I thinned some BLO with turpentine (2:1 or 1:1. Not really critical) and applied that to my bench. I didn't want to build up any finish, just get it to soak in a bit. Wipe off the oil after about 10-15 minutes and let cure 24 hours. Repeat this once or twice more and go ahead and wax it if you want, but I wouldn't bother. The wax helps to repel (WATCH OUT!...technical term coming here) glue-blobs but is not necessary.

A book on finishing is a worthwhile investment.

Regards,

Steve Kubien

Re: Finishing Questions:

#9

Re: Finishing Questions:

Pete Ducklow

>The way I oil wood is to flood the surface with oil and keep it flooded for 30 minutes. Look at it from different angles and with the light raking across the surface. If you see a spot where the wood is drying out and the oil soaking in too much, add more oil. You want to keep it totally saturated for 30 minutes. After 30 minutes, wipe as much off as you can and let it dry for 24 hours. You want to wipe off the oil or it will become sticky. Repeat this procedure for as many coats as you want. You'll see that after 2-3 coats, not very much oil is soaking in anymore.

Re: Finishing Questions:

#10

Re: Finishing Questions:

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>Why would you have gotten a recommendation for sanding with the oil? That's a rhetorical question, of course. There are reasons for sanding with the oil finish, but as the others have noted, they are not applicable to a softwood benchtop. The idea behind sanding the oil in is to fill the pores of an open grain hardwood, e.g., oak, walnut, mahogany, etc., instead of taking the additional step of rubbing in and rubbing out a pore filler. This is technique is not useful for either a fir (softwood) bench top, or for that matter, for a closed pore hardwood, e.g., maple, beech, cherry, purpleheart, etc., that might be chosen for a workbench surface.

Re: Finishing Questions:

#11

Re: Finishing Questions:

Patrick Wheatley

>As I mentioned I am not very experienced with the whole finishing process. My only experience was with my Ash bookcase which has a fairly open grain, hence the sanding idea.

So, thank you all for the input. I will indeed look for the recommended book on finishing and perform some trial and error when the weather gets better. I will also use two coats of Danish oil as it seems to be the easiest to apply for me right now. It will not be polished to a high luster but will be a durable work top that I am looking forward to using for many years.

Pat

Re: Finishing Questions:

#12

Re: Finishing Questions:

Greg Betit, Vergennes, VT.

>When Norm Vandal made his Shaker workbench (featured in the Workbench book) he was really pussy-footing around with it. I was working on a table in his shop a couple months after he made it, and put a pretty nasty ding right on the top. He was initially upset (as was I), but later confided to me that this was what transitioned his attitude towards it from being furniture to a tool.

Right after that he found my present work bench and told me about it. I think he went out searching for a bench for me in self defense. :)

Greg