Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Hartville Indian 5C Plane

Posts

Hartville Indian 5C Plane

#1

Paul Kramer

Hartville Indian 5C Plane

Paul Kramer

>I recently read a post from someone (sorry I don�t remember who) about the Hartville Tool plane offerings from India that appear to be Bailey copies. They had the 5C on clearance for $34.99. I thought, �How bad could it be?� Well, the following few posts (I can�t post multiple pictures in one post) is what I found. I spent about three hours tuning it up but decided � based on the discussion in the previous post � that I wouldn�t add any �aftermarket� parts. No good money after bad.

The plane arrived encased in plastic with all metal surfaces covered in grease. The box was a little rumpled but the plane seemed to have survived it�s trip without any obvious damage.


img

Re: Hartville Indian 5C Plane

#2

Paul Kramer

First the good things

Paul Kramer

>The sole appears to be perfectly flat. The picture shows the plane balanced atop a straight edge with sunlight from behind. Not even a sliver of light.


img

Re: Hartville Indian 5C Plane

#3

Paul Kramer

the �funny� thing

Paul Kramer

>At the top of the chipbreaker is a �funny� little impression. There are no other markings on the blade, etc. The plane sports a �5� but that�s it.


img

Re: Hartville Indian 5C Plane

#4

Paul Kramer

Issues

Paul Kramer

>There were several issues. First, and most troublesome, is that the frog adjusting screw is all off kilter. The entire screw is at an angle. The flange is angled in relation to the shaft of the screw. The flange isn�t of a consistent thickness. All this makes adjusting the frog nearly impossible. Additionally, the hole is not deep enough so as to allow the screw to go as far forward as it should be able to.

The picture also may show that the machined surfaces for the frog aren�t as smooth as those in a LN or LV plane.


img

Re: Hartville Indian 5C Plane

#5

Paul Kramer

Issues 2

Paul Kramer

>There were other machining issues. The blade-adjusting knob was roughly machined leaving sharp edges that were uncomfortable in use. The screw that secures the front knob is about 1/8� above the knob around it. It is uncomfortable as well. The machined surfaces on the frog are also rough � again unlike the LN or LV. The blade arrived with a knick, though shallow. The chipbreaker edge needed some serious honing to allow it to contact the blade fully at the very front edge of the chipbreaker. The blade also required some serious work to put a camber on it. Thank goodness for the Veritas Mk II and Norton water stones (220, 1000, 4000).


img

Re: Hartville Indian 5C Plane

#6

Paul Kramer

To Sum up

Paul Kramer

>The plane works � not extraordinarily well but it works. As you can see from the photograph below this is as tight that the mouth can be closed. You may also be able to make out the problem with the blade-adjusting knob and the front knob screw�s prominence. I was able to make shavings. I didn�t try to use the plane in concert with a scrub plane to flatten a board though that may point up the plane�s utility.


img

Re: Hartville Indian 5C Plane

#7

Looks like a recent Record chip breaker

James Watriss

>

Re: Hartville Indian 5C Plane

#8

Hartville 7

ydb1md

>I had about the same experience with a no 7 that I purchased from Hartville. The sole is flat (good) but the overall machining leaves a lot to be desired. The tote and knob are too small -- not much to hang onto. I need to spend time on the frog and chipbreaker. I'm going to put a camber on the blade and use it for truing panels. Once I spend about 3-4 hours on it, it'll be an ok plane. It's funny how we 'know' we're getting a cheap plane but the ad text makes it so appealing.

Re: Hartville Indian 5C Plane

#9

WOW...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>I think I'd be sending it back. Looks like you get what you pay for.

I agree about the chip breaker look like one from a Record plane.

Re: Hartville Indian 5C Plane

#10

Paul Kramer

But, It's the best 5C I own

Paul Kramer

>

Re: Hartville Indian 5C Plane

#11

Well if it's being used...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>As a 5 (i.e. between a scrub and a smoother). It should work well. I don't like the fact that you can't close up the mouth more.

Good luck with it!