Re: Pam or any other Japanese tool expert
ThomD
>I'm not in favour of multiple hollows myself, so it's hard to make the case. I think the idea would be if you are cutting down on the end of a piece of wood, like a shoulder, and your chisel is a little large, but the next smaller one is a little small. The wider chisel would have a better index if it was bearing on the webs between the hollows. But in practice I don't realy find this necesary. I do think there is already too much material on the backs relative to the bevels, so I think the better sharpening dynamics would be a better thing to go for.
As far as I am concerned the only purpose to the hollow is to make it possible to get the same effect on either side of the blade when sharpening, to have some chance of an equal degree of polish. It's hard to believe today, but back in the 70s when I started almost all the sharpening instructions suggested one should only sharpen the bevel, not the face. One polished up the face when putting the chisel into service but one didn't touch the back, except to remove the burr. The japanese approach is closer to equal strokes on either side, and you need a similar amount of metal to get the same polish.
It has been suggested that hollows make it easier to flatten chisels, but this is flat out untrue as far as the total amount of metal that needs removing over the life of the chisel. It is true as far as initial putting into service is concerned, but the factory can easily grind the backs flat so it doesn't really make much sense if that was the main reason. It could have been historically true.
I don't see any advantage to multiple hollows under any circumstance with a plane. It would make the edge stiffer, but the problem there is that might have adverse effects when it comes to bending out the edge, not sure no opportunity to try it. The plane doesn't index off the center of the blade, which is within the plane, and outside the abutments.
Getting the three bevels forged or ground nicely on the back of the chisel looks like it would be more work. It also looks cool. The kind of thing one would put on the top of the line chisel, which has other features, like better steel and iron. So the cost is likely justified at some level. Not in performance as far as I can see.
The whole Japanese tools thing basically comes down to:
1) a better design within the tools themselves, better geometry.
2) Better edge retention.
3) Better sharpening.
Arguably only 1 is still valid if a person was open to more mechanisation. The technology exists to sharpen the full width backs if a person wants to employ it.