Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Veritas - Innovation in Tools

Pam or any other Japanese tool expert

Posts

Pam or any other Japanese tool expert

#1

Pam or any other Japanese tool expert

HC Sakman

>What's the deal with the hollows in Japanese chisels exactly? (besides the obvious reasons...) Multiple hollows better than one? (logically single hollow should be preferable since one has to remove less metal) Why multiple hollow chisels are more expensive?Also, why there are no plane blades with multiple hollows?

Thanks in advance.

Chico...

Re: Pam or any other Japanese tool expert

#2

Re: Pam or any other Japanese tool expert

ThomD

>I'm not in favour of multiple hollows myself, so it's hard to make the case. I think the idea would be if you are cutting down on the end of a piece of wood, like a shoulder, and your chisel is a little large, but the next smaller one is a little small. The wider chisel would have a better index if it was bearing on the webs between the hollows. But in practice I don't realy find this necesary. I do think there is already too much material on the backs relative to the bevels, so I think the better sharpening dynamics would be a better thing to go for.

As far as I am concerned the only purpose to the hollow is to make it possible to get the same effect on either side of the blade when sharpening, to have some chance of an equal degree of polish. It's hard to believe today, but back in the 70s when I started almost all the sharpening instructions suggested one should only sharpen the bevel, not the face. One polished up the face when putting the chisel into service but one didn't touch the back, except to remove the burr. The japanese approach is closer to equal strokes on either side, and you need a similar amount of metal to get the same polish.

It has been suggested that hollows make it easier to flatten chisels, but this is flat out untrue as far as the total amount of metal that needs removing over the life of the chisel. It is true as far as initial putting into service is concerned, but the factory can easily grind the backs flat so it doesn't really make much sense if that was the main reason. It could have been historically true.

I don't see any advantage to multiple hollows under any circumstance with a plane. It would make the edge stiffer, but the problem there is that might have adverse effects when it comes to bending out the edge, not sure no opportunity to try it. The plane doesn't index off the center of the blade, which is within the plane, and outside the abutments.

Getting the three bevels forged or ground nicely on the back of the chisel looks like it would be more work. It also looks cool. The kind of thing one would put on the top of the line chisel, which has other features, like better steel and iron. So the cost is likely justified at some level. Not in performance as far as I can see.

The whole Japanese tools thing basically comes down to:

1) a better design within the tools themselves, better geometry.

2) Better edge retention.

3) Better sharpening.

Arguably only 1 is still valid if a person was open to more mechanisation. The technology exists to sharpen the full width backs if a person wants to employ it.

Re: Pam or any other Japanese tool expert

#3

Re: Pam or any other Japanese tool expert

tonyr

>the pupose of multiple hollows is to make a chisel more rigid. theoretically this is necessary in situations where the chisel is getting "too thin" relative to its width. obviously, we've all seen multiple hollows used on chisels of "normal" thickness under an inch in width, and in these cases the multiple hollows have no functional value whatsover but are evidently offered for sale for aesthetic reasons. in fact, its harder to flatten a chisel with multiple hollows not bc there is marginally more steele but rather bc there is one (or more) additional surface to bring to the exact same plane as the outer edges of the back. multiple hollows cost more bc there is more work required on the part of the blacksmith to craft them, though the incremental price is typically rather small. plane blades are fully supported by the dai and therefore there is no need for multiple hollows to add additional rigidity.

Re: Pam or any other Japanese tool expert

#4

Re: Pam or any other Japanese tool expert

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Chico, I don't know and none of the tool sellers have gone out of their way to try to explain this. Therefore, I've put it down to eye candy, just like mokume, for which they can charge more but no enhanced function follows. I could be wrong; but Harrelson told me mokume provides nothing beyond aesthetics, with one exception. That would be in the case of very thin/small shafts who's strength is increased by the folding. So it could be the same with multiple hollows, they could help with very large chisels.

Still, it's a pretty cool look.

Pam

Re: Pam or any other Japanese tool expert

#5

Re: Pam or any other Japanese tool expert

ThomD

>Lot's of interesting answwers.

Of course on isn't going to maintain much additional strength if one is forced to chase imperfections on a single surface down below the others. Why not just leave them. In fairness the low point could just as easily be on the perimeter.

I did chase up an Iyoroi Sr. quote from the Mid-80s in some of Robert Major's stuff where he says Iyoroi claimed the multiple hollows created greated control. No mention as to how this was the case. I'm sticking to my exposition. Majors mentioned that they created greater control in dovetailing which is a little hard to see. That appears to be his personal view.

Probably all this stuff has some truth to it.

Re: Pam or any other Japanese tool expert

#6

Re: Pam or any other Japanese tool expert

Marc in Luxembourg

>T. Odate writes - now if I remember well - that one hollow was always common and multiple ones are modern. For the reasons I don't know, and that's my interpr�tation, except that maybe on paring one can have a slighty better support, if the right or left edge isn't supported, say the chisel's broader than the board.

Marc

Re: Pam or any other Japanese tool expert

#7

Thanks Everybody....

HC Sakman

>...it seems like 1x1=1 ! ;-)

Chico...

Re: Pam or any other Japanese tool expert

#8

Hollaback chisel

Dave Burnard

>"It has been suggested that hollows make it easier to flatten chisels, but this is flat out untrue as far as the total amount of metal that needs removing over the life of the chisel."

Uh, do you mean that when a chisel ends its life the whole blade has been sharpened away? That's certainly an unavoidable truth - but may miss the point.

My experience is that in chisels that are struck (and to a lesser extent those that are pushed) it's fairly common to introduce some small deformations into the edge of the chisel that affect the flatness of the back. This is very common in larger chisels (timberframing) or but I see it when cutting mortices in difficult woods with small chisels as well. While I could sharpen away a mm or so of the chisel to get past that deformation, it's often much simpler to take a few passes on the back of this chisel with a 1000 grit stone and repolish the back. Or to "tap out" the chisel to correct the deflections and increase the area between the hollow and the edge. In either case it's still faster to fix the back because of the hollow, and way faster than removing so much material from the bevel side. So I spend less time sharpening and the chisel has a longer life.

When starting out with marginal hand sharpening skills, or if you end up preferring to use motorized water cooled sharpening machines, then hollow back japanese chisels probably aren't the best match.

Re: Pam or any other Japanese tool expert

#9

Re: Hollaback chisel

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>So you are effectively ignoring the chip/deformation of the bevel side for a while by flattening the back and getting on with it? Until the chisel needs sharpening again?

Pam

Re: Pam or any other Japanese tool expert

#10

Re: Hollaback chisel

ThomD

>A lot of the early talk about hollow backs was about them making initial set-up easier. This was not a logical argument since the factory/shop can provide flat chisels if that was the main issue, and that over the life a of a chisel the fact of a hollow means you have to grind enormously more material away than if you had a flat back and either flatened it yourself or the factory made it right in the first place, as for the most part better planes today actually come with flat bottoms.

The Japanese themselves make excellent HSS chisels. The cheap set I got from Majors 25 years ago is really excellent even compared to a lot of the more expensive chisels I have since used. These can be dry ground and buffed with impunity, though I treat them as I would any other Japanese chisel. Point being if initial flatening wher the bid deal these can certianly be groud flat at the factory with no harm done to the chisels. The same is true with the more fragile ones, but it would be a little more costly. Blue steel has some HSS components, though I don't know if they are sufficient to improve resistance to over-heating.

The argument these days has shifted to the idea of the hollow back making hand sharping more effective. Which I agree with. Whether overall effectiveness is improved by spending money on expensive chisels designed to be easier to sharpen vs spending money of more efficient means of sharpening cheaper chisels is open to question. I am working on this, and don't know what the personal answer is.

Re: Pam or any other Japanese tool expert

#11

Re: Hollaback chisel

ThomD

>Are you asking me, Pam? I don't understand the question. I sharpen all edges on both sides if that helps?

Re: Pam or any other Japanese tool expert

#12

No, Thom, I was asking Dave.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: Pam or any other Japanese tool expert

#13

Re: No, Thom, I was asking Dave.

ThomD

>Oh well, can't blame me for getting excited. I was TIG welding parts for my spinning wheel, so wood talk is a nice diversion.

Re: Pam or any other Japanese tool expert

#14

Re: Hollaback chisel

Dave Burnard

>Hey Pam,

Sorry I guess that was unclear. I always sharpen the bevel side.

You can usually see the back side distortions if there are any, or they'll show themselves when you take off the wire edge. On a chisel I've worked hard I'll often just check the back on my middle stone to look for edge issues, since I know I'll pretty much always be using the middle stone on the back side in the course of regular sharpening anyway. If there are distortions worth tapping out then I'll deal with them first before working on the bevel.

I guess a guideline would be if the distortion goes a lot further than the worst problem on the edge I'll tap it out a bit first. I've seen this from chopping into a knot. If the distortion is only a bit bigger than the worst edge problem I'll take a few passes on the 1000/1200 on the back to get it back to the same size as the edge problem. Then back to the regular sharpening regimen, 1000/1200 on the bevel, middle stone on the back, middle stone on the bevel, polishing stone on the back and then the bevel, etc.

Clearer than sharpening stone mud? ;)

Re: Pam or any other Japanese tool expert

#15

Re: Hollaback chisel

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Thanks, Dave, much clearer. Of course, I'd thought it was pretty cool to only take out the protuberences and keep on going. :)

Pam

Re: Pam or any other Japanese tool expert

#16

Re: Hollaback chisel

Dave Burnard

>ThomD

I'll certainly agree that hollow backs aren't for initial setup. I don't remember hearing/reading about that one. When you say it was "early talk", do you mean Robert Majors era? That's early all right. There is/was a lot of misinformation about japanese chisels (or everything else for that matter ;) ) in the woodworking mags where someone offers to review something never having used really them all that much before. I always cringe at how their chisels look after initial setup - where they've removed more steel off the back than I do in 10 years.

I have some japanese HSS chisels (a later version, yours sound like they work better than mine). I like to say that they will take a lousy edge (can't pare with them) but can hold that edge forever. So they're fine for big mortice chopping but lousy for anything else I'd use a japanese chisel for. Mine are atsu-nomi size and even when I try to use them for morticing I quickly switch back to my regular white steel chisels.

FYI - Blue steel is not at all like HSS, it's still water quenched and every bit as susceptible to overheating (at the grinder) as white steel (or other plain carbon steels). Blue steel has some tungsten and chrome in it which can help make for a longer lasting cutting edge.

I don't think there's an argument over why the hollow exists is there? It makes them easier to sharpen! Initial setup is small compared to sharpening time over the life of a chisel. Most chisels sold to professionals in Japan are as dull as screwdrivers because the user will want to sharpen them himself and match the bevel to his style of work.

I think your idea to try "spending more money on the means of sharpening, rather than on the chisel itself" is interesting. It's easy these days spend a lot of money on sharpening equipment too, but can you get cheap chisels that are "worth" sharpening? That work as well as the opposite case - what you could get by spending all your money on a chisel set and then using the pretty inexpensive King 1000, 6000 stones? I've seen a Japanese carpenter win a KazorouKai planing contest using just those two stones. I suppose when some neander-galoot wins something like a KezurouKai with a Tormek, a Stanley #4 and a Hock A2 blade we'll all stand up and cheer. I'd sure be impressed!

We may not decide anything, but it's an interesting conversation. Whee!