Alisam Sharpening Sled
Mark Kozlowski
>Has anyone tried one of these? Can you set angles between the preset detents? Do you like it?
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
Alisam Sharpening Sled
Mark Kozlowski
>Has anyone tried one of these? Can you set angles between the preset detents? Do you like it?
Re: Alisam Sharpening Sled
Steve Kubien
>Hi Mark,
I haven't tried it because I was waiting for the Veritas Mark II to come out. Having no idea about the Alisam, I am still VERY happy I waited for the Veritas. It is extremely easy to use and does a marvelous job. In looking for a new sharpening jig, I think you should at least consider the Veritas.
My 2 cents
steve Kubien
Re: Alisam Sharpening Sled
James Watriss
>I picked one up, and haven't used it. I'm still getting around to sending it back. My reasons:
-Only one model offers a 5 degree bevel option, which is what I wanted, for back-beveling. I wasn't too clear on this when I ordered. They've offered to replace mine with the model that offers a 5 degree setting, but since each model is set for different heights, this may or may not be helpful. AND...
-Four points of contact are all fine and good if you can keep them co-planar. They did a nifty trick making the front two bearing wheels depressable, so that pressure could be applied to the blade. But since one side of the widget has machined detents (nope, no fine-tuning in between angles, sorry) and the other is completely smooth, it's hard to keep everything co-planar when it's being tightened down. The angle-setting side is fine, but the other side is a smooth surface, with nothing between that support and the rubber handle surface. So that last tightening of the handle moves the support just a hair of a degree off, so the whole thing is tipsy. I can't say for positive if that's one of those things that will ruin the whole sharpening process or not, but it's not very encouraging.
Re: Alisam Sharpening Sled
paul womack
>They did a nifty trick making the front two bearing wheels depressable, so that pressure could be applied to the blade.
In that case, what is the purpose of the font bearings?
The whole thing seems odd, and expensive.
I'm not seeing any functional advantage w.r.t. General #809 the only other run-on-the-bench guide I know.
And run-on-the-bench guides all require your stones to be parallel and of the same thickness, which can be difficult to arrange (although great for scary sharp)
BugBear
Re: Alisam Sharpening Sled
James Watriss
>Well, on a unicycle jig, you can apply pressure easily to the blade. In this case, since hte whole thing is riding on 4 roller bearings, you need to be able to actually tilt the front down very slightly, so that as the blade is ground away, you're still making good contact with the stone.
There are some advantages to this rig, one of which being that it's easy to square the blade to the rig itself with a sliding ring. The various angle settings are another advantage, since on the adjusting side, they do lock in place pretty well.
Lastly, if you're using some longer stones, you cna use the full length of the stone, and not just the part that comes before ht ejig hits the stone. And for those of use who use things like diamond paste, if you're using a really long piece of substrate, that really comes in handy.
Other than that, I dunno. It's well machined and put together, there were just a few minor glitches that I found when I opened it up.
Re: Alisam Sharpening Sled
paul womack
>Well, on a unicycle jig, you can apply pressure easily to the blade. In this case, since hte whole thing is riding on 4 roller bearings, you need to be able to actually tilt the front down very slightly, so that as the blade is ground away, you're still making good contact with the stone.
Yes. I understand all that. My question is: what are the front bearings *for*? What purpose do they (and their fancy retraction) serve?
The advantage off "full length of the stones" I agree with; it's common to all run-on-the-bench guides.
BugBear
Re: Alisam Sharpening Sled
James Watriss
>What are they for? Well, the whole thing slides on 4 bearings. It's part of the design, looks kinda like a mini aluminum sawhorse. I s'pose they're supposed to help it slide more easily than plastic skids or something, but given the design, your is a hard question to answer... it's like asking what the front feet are for on your dog. They're just there. But they do allow enough downward movement to allow the blade to be ground.
Re: Alisam Sharpening Sled
paul womack
> I s'pose they're supposed to help it slide more easily than plastic skids or something,
But they don't need to be there. If all the force is on either the blade being worked or the rear bearings, what is the purpose of the front bearings?
BugBear
Re: Alisam Sharpening Sled
Ben
>The front bearing hold the front of the jig up so the angle setting is correct. once the blade is slid in and locked down, you are right you no longer need the front bearings, that's where the spring in them comes in.