Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

anyone watch this dvd about japanese smoothers?

Posts

anyone watch this dvd about japanese smoothers?

#1

anyone watch this dvd about japanese smoothers?

ray k

>I was browsing japanesetools.com's webpage and ran across their video entitled, 'Kanna: The Japanese Hand Plane'. It seems like it'd be an interest dvd, but $60 is pretty steep. Before I even think about plopping that kind of money, I'm wondering if anyone has seen and whether he/she thinks it was worth the $. Thanks.

Re: anyone watch this dvd about japanese smoothers?

#2

Re: anyone watch this dvd about japanese smoothers

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I've seen a preliminary-to-release copy, it's excellent, especially if you've picked up a Japanese plane for the first time and have no one to show you how to tune/manage it in person.

Pam

Re: anyone watch this dvd about japanese smoothers?

#3

Re: anyone watch this dvd about japanese smoothers

ray k

>Thanks Pam. I should have addressed the question to you first since you seem to be the resident japanese plane guru. Thanks for the info. I definitely fit in the brand new to japanese planes camp and have no one to show me how they work. I happened to drop by the japanwoodworker store this weekend and bought a japanese plane (the most inexpensive one--about $50). I always wanted to try to them out and I figure $50 is a small initial investment. The fellow helping me out was very knowledgeable and actually really cautioned me that japanese handplanes will either 1) make me want to leave them alone or 2) be obsessed with them. I definitely get the impression that I need someone to guide me through them several times. I get by ok with my current set of western style planes and homemade krenov style planes. But alas, I love learning new things and this japanese hand planes definitely have piqued my interest.

Thanks again Pam and I welcome any thoughts you might have on japanese planes, chisels, tools, etc.

ray

Re: anyone watch this dvd about japanese smoothers?

#4

Re: anyone watch this dvd about japanese smoothers

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Glad to have helped. There are a few others probably more guru than I, Wiley for example. The route I took, after buying a plane from Misugi Design and not knowing what to do even with Odate's book on Japanese tools, was to attend Inamoto-san's seminar on dai making at Hiraide. What with all the travel and class expenses, it's quite a bit cheaper to buy Harrelson's dvd. Also, you don't have to wait.

However, I do highly recommend spending some time with Inamoto-san making dai, an invaluable experience.

Pam

Re: anyone watch this dvd about japanese smoothers?

#5

Classes on the left coast

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>BTW, since you're in the SF area, you're in luck, there are Japanese tool using classes, like Jay van Arsdale's classes at a community college.

Pam

Re: anyone watch this dvd about japanese smoothers?

#6

Re: Classes on the left coast

Brent Smith

>Just to add my thoughts. I bought the pre-release version also. I knew absolutely nothing about Japanese planes at the time. The video walks you through all the steps from buying, settting-up to using a Japanese plane. I don't think you could spend a better $60 if you're interested in the subject. Also his video on sharpening is very interesting.

Brent

Re: anyone watch this dvd about japanese smoothers?

#7

Re: Classes on the left coast

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>Hi Brent,

Can I ask where you purchased your copy?

Thanks.

take care,

Jim

Re: anyone watch this dvd about japanese smoothers?

#8

Re: Classes on the left coast

ThomD

>Japanesetools.com

I didn't get the tape. I was at the same seminar Pam went to.

I learned a lot at the seminar, but about the only thing that I would say made much difference was to learn how hard they set the blade. I was babying it. Too tight to pull it out by hand but no tighter than necesarry to stop it backing out. Really setting it hard makes all the difference because it makes fititng the blade a lot easier.

Other than that plane prep is pretty similar to western planes as far as getting good vs "correct" result is concerned. Inletting is just standard techniques, and the sole wave form has been well described lots of places.

Oh one other thing that was interesting was to learn that the Japanese race plane guys use jigs for sharpening. I will jig a Japanes blade if I get it way off, but normally I sharpen by hand. Good to learn that when it comes to hyper performance they use jigs. Though maybe even that nugget was on the Hida tool site...

Re: anyone watch this dvd about japanese smoothers?

#9

Re: Classes on the left coast

ThomD

>Oops, I don't mean to suggest the seminar was limited to a few points. Just saying what I thought helped me beyond reading books as far as plane set-up is concerned. I learned a great deal from the seminar overall.

Re: anyone watch this dvd about japanese smoothers?

#10

Inamoto-san seminar

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Yes, that tight blade set was a real surprise, and it's also what enables you to use the blade without a sub-blade. The other thing I learned is that the blade(s) comprise the majority of the cost for Japanese planes, so dai making is not necessarily monetarily valuable; however, I'm making a set of dai for each blade set, each dai with a different bedding angle. Now that's valuable! Everybody says don't do that, because a dai without a blade can move around quite a bit and you tailor a dai for the blade(s); but what I'm doing is making a blade form replicator from desert ironwood to insert when the blade's in another dai. Not 100% sure this will work, but seems feasible.

Unlike you, I had had almost no experience with Japanese planes at the time of the seminar, so it was all enlightening to me. Also got to use the Shaptons for the first time. Went home with a lot less cash and a lot more tools. :)

That jig was developed by Inamoto-san and a friend of his and was adjustable in 3 dimensions. It worked great, but it also cost $130, which was a bit much for me.

Pam

Re: anyone watch this dvd about japanese smoothers?

#11

Re: Inamoto-san seminar

ThomD

>The more I think about it the more it was a rich experience. The best part is working with other people who all know something I don't know and was graterful to learn. Up here I have never met another woodworker who uses Japanese tools. Obviously there are others, and there is a big japanese comunity, but so far they haven't fallen across my path.

I used single blade planes with loose fit and they worked fine but they don't handle as well as the ones I now make.

I think your method may well work just fine. I have dais kicking around fromt the late 70s that I pulled a blade out of to use in something else. Putting the blade back in they work fine. Of course if you left a particular blade in a dai for 20 years it might need tuning also, so whether it will be any worse without the blade remains to be seen. I only have one dai that is unuseable it was for a jointer and it bent like a banana. Just something about that piece of wood, one I bought too.

I'm just getting worked up to make my 4" beam plane. It is going to be a pretty rough prototype until I feel it is worth formalizing.

I am also on the trail of some exceptional iron I hope to be able to forge into some laminated blades. It will all take years to sort out, but it is gradually moving in the right direction.

Are you still using the dai supplier in Cali? I still have a few blades to fit.

Re: anyone watch this dvd about japanese smoothers?

#12

Re: Inamoto-san seminar

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Yes it was rich, recommended for anyone getting into Japanese tools seriously.

Good to hear about the lack of wood movement, I don't have all that much ironwood and my supplier died last year.

Where'd you find a dai for that 4 incher? For that matter, where did you get the 4" blade.

I bought a pile of dai from the CA source, which were all cupped a small amount, so they are ageing/drying right now, should be ready in another year or so. I also bought a couple of dai from Hida in October, one long enough for a jointer.

Pam

Re: anyone watch this dvd about japanese smoothers?

#13

Re: Inamoto-san seminar

ThomD

>I'm going to make the blade myself, O1 quality, I hope better by the time I do some experimenting with the heat treating. And the dai will probably be beech. I'm working up to 6inches. So far i haven't experienced any warping during heat treating except one blade that cracked really badly, and even it was pretty flat. If I can get the same results with 4" material, then I will eventually move up to 6". This goal has been around since I saw the blade Harrelson has over 20 years ago, when Robert Majors owned it.

Originally I thought it would be so cool to be able to finish plane posts with a single pass. That was before I realized that one could curve the edge of finishing planes and otherwise eliminate the tracks!

Re: anyone watch this dvd about japanese smoothers?

#14

Re: Inamoto-san seminar

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Well, that's a fine thing to do, please keep me informed on this project.

Pam

Re: anyone watch this dvd about japanese smoothers?

#15

Re: Inamoto-san seminar

ThomD

>That should read "Plain posts".

I will keep you informed.

Re: anyone watch this dvd about japanese smoothers?

#16

Re: Inamoto-san seminar

paul womack

>That jig was developed by Inamoto-san

Interesting. When many people talk about Japanese wood craft technique, there's a lot of emphasis on body/hand skills.

And yet IIRC at the plane-off many of the Japanese masters were sharpening with honing guides, and now you tell me of a plane-master designing and using a jig.

Perhaps the real story is more mixed than is usually presented.

BugBear

Re: anyone watch this dvd about japanese smoothers?

#17

Re: Inamoto-san seminar

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Sure, always is. However, this jig actually worked for all Japanese plane blades but the biggest, like bigger than 3-1/2". And remember, Inamoto-san is a dai maker who only needs to get the plane to some approximation of sharp (his jig does better) for shipping. So far as I know, he's not a user.

Pam

Re: anyone watch this dvd about japanese smoothers?

#18

Re: Inamoto-san seminar

ThomD

>One thing about the Japanese myth we hear over here is how they have this tight family apprentice scheme, and don't answer questions or write things down. So I'm not surprised to get the feeling that there isn't one Japanese way of doing things, though there would be a lot of ideas exchanged at larger jobsites. But so far about every person I have met who did learn over there seemes to have learned something different.

Also, their woodworking appears to be more high tech than ours. There are many admirable things about out mechanized woodworking, but it isn't the most advanced globaly as far as I can tell, at least if one leaves CAD CAM out. Many of the advanced tools we have, come from abroad like the biscuit joiner, and the hollow chisel mortiser (not sure who invented it but it fed into our market from UK). Most of our basic machines like table saws and jointers and planers are directly from designs that are maybe 70 years old, certainly post WWII at best. We added accessories to them while in euro they have been completely redesigned with better materials and guards.

The Japanese have super surfacers, and dozens of portable tools we never see. While we are discusing archana about blade forging techniques they have machines that automatically plane beams full width, and machines that automaticaly sharpen the blades on the planing machines. So a jig is a pretty low tech thing in the overall picture.

I haven't been to Japan so my whole picture may be seriously out of wack.

Re: anyone watch this dvd about japanese smoothers?

#19

Steve Kubien

Re: Inamoto-san seminar and tongue-wagging on jobs

Steve Kubien

>Thom wrote:

"One thing about the Japanese myth we hear over here is how they have this tight family apprentice scheme, and don't answer questions or write things down. So I'm not surprised to get the feeling that there isn't one Japanese way of doing things, though there would be a lot of ideas exchanged at larger jobsites. But so far about every person I have met who did learn over there seemes to have learned something different."

It is very similar in the Japanese martial arts. An art developed and a few people mastered it. They 'tweaked' the art into their own style, based on their own experiences and encounters. Often, their version was considered superior to others. This new master would be hired by a family (or often worked on their own) to teach the samurai of the household. Some of these students would eventually teach what they have learned...but did they all teach exactly what they learned? Did they have different interpretations? Yup, they did. Now, consider that this has been happening in some arts for 400 years (some much longer). Lots of different ways of doing things. In the past, 'secrets' would be protected by blood oaths and would be well guarded. Sword makers developed in a similar ways. I would be very surprised if, as Thom suggests, that ideas would be exchanged at larger jobsites. Possible, but I doubt it. Remember that I am talking about a period in time before 1867.

Rspectfully,

Steve Kubien - who is really enjoying this thread.

Re: anyone watch this dvd about japanese smoothers?

#20

Re: Inamoto-san seminar

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Yes, I think perhaps the Japanese apprenticeship system leads to both insularity and very deep knowledge.

As to our mechanized woodworking, CAD/CAM is certainly advanced; but I'm not at all sure about biscuit joiners nor hollow chisel mortisers. More about the mortisers from our "ancient" past in a few months once I get the Barnes machine up and running. The European machines seem more refined than the North American versions. Maybe by turning over manufacturing to the east, eventually some of the Asian refinements will make it here.

Meanwhile, there are the Hitachi and Makita groove cutters I want, but can't afford, not even sold in the US. I'd love to see the machines that automatically sharpen and have long wondered why jointers and planars here don't do that.

Pam

Re: anyone watch this dvd about japanese smoothers?

#21

Very interesting insights, Steve.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>