Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Why there are fiberboard planes *LINK*

Posts

Why there are fiberboard planes *LINK*

#1

Why there are fiberboard planes *LINK*

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>One of the Stanley plane types that this forum periodically likes to bash (though less often than the poor benighted No. 75) is the fiberboard planes, No. 193 and following. For those not familiar with them, the link below is to Patrick Leach's thoughtful and unbiased analysis.

Last summer, we stayed at a cabin in a motor hotel (cabin group? not sure what the right name would be) near Crater Lake, Oregon, that date from the 1930's, and aren't much changed from their original state. The cabins were built by a pair of brothers primarily from wood milled on the property, but either they ran out of wood, or they wanted to zip up the places a bit and show that they were with the times, because the paneling above the wainscoting is fiberboard, grooved randomly to simulate wide-board paneling. For those not familiar with fiberboard, it's kind of like particleboard, but softer - somewhat of the same relationship to particleboard that cooked rice has to uncooked.

I took some pictures, of which the below is an example, to share with this group, to explain why the fiberboard planes made sense. While my reaction to it on entering the cabin wasn't exactly positive (other than being archaelogically intrigued), I came to understand what was going on. It was becoming clear even at the turn of the last century that the wood resources wouldn't last forever, and fiberboard was an experiment - though this is the positive spin. An equally valid assertion would probably be that the lumbermills were looking for a way to pull some money out of waste material.

The other place I've seen fiberboard used is also in Southwestern Oregon, in the lodge at the Oregon Caves National Monument, where it lines the walls in the upper floors where the lodging rooms are. There, the panels are put up utterly unadorned, like sections of drywall with no tape between the joints, but fuzzier. I have to say that the brothers at the cabin made a more attractive use of the material.

The grooves in the brothers' fiberboard are remarkably clean and precise after 70 years, and it's clear that the tool used to cut them was well-designed for the application; so, let's give fiberboard planes a moment's respect. We may not, at this remove, have much respect for the material, but it appears that Stanley accomplished what they set out to do.


img

Patrick Leach on fiberboard planes

Re: Why there are fiberboard planes *LINK*

#2

Re: Why there are fiberboard planes

dale Stansbery

>Someone respects them as the last one I saw go at auction with fences(well some kind of parts anyway) and box went for a couple hundred $'s.

Re: Why there are fiberboard planes *LINK*

#3

Re: Particle products...

paul womack

>An equally valid assertion would probably be that the lumbermills were looking for a way to pull some money out of waste material.

Ah. Where responsible use of resources meets capitalism.

Sometimes the system works!

BugBear

Re: Why there are fiberboard planes *LINK*

#4

I've seen something similar

Mike Fitterling

>In some of the houses here in Lake Wales, like the ones put up quickly in the twenties for the workers on the tower at Bok Tower Gardens, I've seen something they call "beaver board" that they put up instead of plaster. Must be the same thing. Tends to sag when used on ceilings.

Re: Why there are fiberboard planes *LINK*

#5

Re: Why there are fiberboard planes

Dave Thompson - on the Embara river

>Thanks for sharing the photo Bill, and including the humorous Leach description. I've been curious to see the product of one of these planes. It kind of gives some indication of economics of the time (depression era?), and relative cost of labor versus materials.

For a while I've been thinking masonite as a brand name for fiberboard, but actually that would be like dried up and pressed cooked rice, wouldn't it? ;-)

I suppose MDF would really be the common modern name. DIY shows seem to love the stuff, and I know it's the ideal material for loud speaker enclosures. While I haven't frequented the area for years, I seem to recall the common name on rec.woodworking for this use to be termite vomit.

Re: Why there are fiberboard planes *LINK*

#6

Hardboard

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>is, I believe, the generic name for Masonite, which is a trademarked name - another example of the leading trademark name becoming the generic name (kleenex, formica, etc.).

Actually, MDF is not quite the same as masonite (hardboard) or fiberboard. hardboard has a different binder than MDF, thus the darker appearance (and tempered hardboard is cooked somehow too), while fiberboard is fluffier.

Re: Why there are fiberboard planes *LINK*

#7

Re: Hardboard

Dave Thompson

>Ah yes, sorry for the confusion. Re-reading my note, I see it certainly doesn't say what I intended ;-) I agree masonite (hardboard) is different than MDF.

I've always thought of hardboard and MDF (medium density fiberboard) as both fiberboards. The question I have though is, what substance are the fiberboard planes designed for? I presume MDF...

Re: Why there are fiberboard planes *LINK*

#8

Re: Why there are fiberboard planes

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>Very curious post, Bill. I've been in both of those buildings, but never stopped to study the fiberboard. (My mother used to live in Cave Junction.) As Mike knows, she is now living even closer to Bok Tower than she was to the Oregon Caves.

If you want to go way beyond fiberboard, there is this stuff they've been making right here in NJ for many years, called Homasote. My green #75 has met its match.