Why I buying chisels on eBay
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>Hi Steve
Many of my vintage chisels have come from eBay, some have been purchased from dedicated oldtool websites in the UK, and a few through fellow members of the Porch. Living in Oz, it is extremely rare to find vintage tools (of the variety/make I seek) at swap meets or garage sales. This is the real Old Tool Hell. With regards the price/value of vintage chisels, most of you guys (and gals, sorry Alf and Pam) will feel differently about this than I simply because of the greater availability you have in the States and the UK (my perception at any rate), and the law of Supply-and-Demand rules in this regard. Just the mail cost of each chisel to Perth is roughly $10!
I divide my vintage chisels into two categories: (1) those that are in near original condition (i.e. good handles and full length, unpitted steel) which are usable with just the usual cleaning/tuning (lapping backs, perhaps refinishing the handles if needed). (2) and those that will require a fair amount of time to make usable (i.e. only a decent blade, which will require a need handle to be made in addition to the usual cleaning/tuning). In group #1 the competition will be strong (because everyone wants these chisels), while those in group #2 may be picked up quite cheaply.
These days I tend to go for group #2 since I am comfortable making my own handles (in fact prefer this).
What brands do I concentrate on: For bench chisels I only buy Witherby (very tough steel and hold an edge almost as well as my Japanese chisels); for paring and dovetail chisels I like Berg (very slender shoulders that will get into acute angles well); Mortising chisels have been a mixed bunch to date, but over the past several months I have been concentrating on the Oval Bolstered variety, and this means Ward, Sorby and a few others (most of these require new handles, which I am enjoying making in different woods).
At the end of the day the monetary cost of importing vintage steel can get quite close to the cost of new steel bought locally. I do have a "collection" of Japanese chisels as well, mostly new, some vintage. Then there is the so-called cost of refurbishment. The time is takes to make an old chisel usable is not viable if one places an hourly labor cost on it all. However, this is not the way I look at it. I do not factor in my time as if I were at work (the current recommended rate for a clinical psychologist in private practice in Australia is $181 AUD per hour). I certainly could buy a lot of new LNs or Barrs if I did extra time at work. Life is not like that. I would much rather see tool restoration as part of the hobby woodworking is for me. If it takes a couple of hours (or more) to restore one $10 chisel, so be it - this just makes it more special.
In the end it will come down to your own personal objectives and beliefs. For myself I have many tools that are valuable, not for their commercial rate, but for the time put into them that has created an intimacy that a new tool cannot do.
Regards from Perth
Derek