Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Personalized Wooden Watches, Engraved Free

Chisels . . .

Posts

Chisels . . .

#1

Chisels . . .

Steve Mackay

>All-righty ; You guys have me 'bout up to speed on vintage planes and rust ( he-he, er, saws ). Now I'm paying attention to the old chisels on e-bay. Whats the dope ? I saw you mentioned " flavors-of-the-month " but want desirable equipment 'till I die AND BEYOND !

Re: Chisels . . .

#2

my jaundiced perspective on buying used chisels

bill tindall

>I will make the assumption that you intend to use these. If you are just collecting ignor the following.

I have found nothing to suggest that vintage chisels have some inherent advantage over quality modern chisels. Chisels must have flat backs , at least near the edge. Used chisels typically are more or less abused and sellers are clueless about the issues of flattening the back or a chisel. Hence, the chisel you receive will have a dubbed back or a pitted back and it will take a long time to get it into useable shape. If your time is worth $3/hr it will be cheaper buying new chisels.

Ditto for anything else used that will need flatening and sharpening that may have been mis-ground or rusted.

Re: Chisels . . .

#3

Old Chisel Quality

Steve Elliott

>It was an old chisel I bought at an "antique" store that woke me up to how well a chisel can hold an edge. It took some work to lap the back, but I still use it and consider it one of my best.

From my own experience I can't recommend any brand, although I have a couple of Anton Berg chisels I like. They're not as good as that first chisel I bought, which doesn't have a legible brand name. For reliably good steel I buy Japanese chisels now.

Re: Chisels . . .

#4

Chisels and what to look for

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>I approach any tool,new or used,as a starting point.Bill says the time involved flattening the back etc.of old chisels means it`s cheaper to buy new.From what I`ve seen myself and heard here the new ones take just as much work for less of a return(unless you want to part with $250 for LN).

Things I would avoid;Pitting on the back of flat chisels or inside of incannel gouges.Ask if there are ANY cracks in the back and don`t buy if there are.A chisel that`s bowed can be rough flattened with a vise or wood blocks and mallet to save time on the stones.

Names to look for;Swan,Whitherby,Eric Anton Berg(also known as shark brand)and Charles Buck.For the larger sizes Douglas,Merrill,Underhill are some of the ones I`ve had good luck with.I try to buy laminated chisels.

I buy my chisels locally for the most part as I can inspect them and they go for less than just the shipping for Ebay purchases.The exception has been if I buy a lot off the `bay of 5 or more chisels with at least one really good one in it.I have yet to pay more than $15 for the best chisel I own(that includes my Whitherby slick).Hope I didn`t just jinx myself.

Good hunting to you.

Mainely,Bob

Re: Chisels . . .

#5

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Chisels and what to look for

Jim in Burlington On

>E-bay and shipping of single chisels will drive you crazy. I have seen several E.A Berg chisel set's sell for more than new LN. I have bought a few of the German copies of Stanley 750's in the 5-10$ range at flea market's they are pretty good chisels.

Re: Chisels . . .

#6

Steve Kubien

Users or collectables...

Steve Kubien

>If you are set on getting vintage chisels, I'll take a bow to the more experienced folks who have already posted. If quality chisels to be used are your aim, I am very happy with my Hirsch chisels (I got mine at Lee Valley). They're not expensive ($20-$28 Cdn each or $125 for set of 6). Minimal flattening was needed and they hold an edge just fine. Remember, just because it's older, doesn't mean it is better.

My 2 cents

Steve Kubien

Re: Chisels . . .

#7

Why I buying chisels on eBay

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Steve

Many of my vintage chisels have come from eBay, some have been purchased from dedicated oldtool websites in the UK, and a few through fellow members of the Porch. Living in Oz, it is extremely rare to find vintage tools (of the variety/make I seek) at swap meets or garage sales. This is the real Old Tool Hell. With regards the price/value of vintage chisels, most of you guys (and gals, sorry Alf and Pam) will feel differently about this than I simply because of the greater availability you have in the States and the UK (my perception at any rate), and the law of Supply-and-Demand rules in this regard. Just the mail cost of each chisel to Perth is roughly $10!

I divide my vintage chisels into two categories: (1) those that are in near original condition (i.e. good handles and full length, unpitted steel) which are usable with just the usual cleaning/tuning (lapping backs, perhaps refinishing the handles if needed). (2) and those that will require a fair amount of time to make usable (i.e. only a decent blade, which will require a need handle to be made in addition to the usual cleaning/tuning). In group #1 the competition will be strong (because everyone wants these chisels), while those in group #2 may be picked up quite cheaply.

These days I tend to go for group #2 since I am comfortable making my own handles (in fact prefer this).

What brands do I concentrate on: For bench chisels I only buy Witherby (very tough steel and hold an edge almost as well as my Japanese chisels); for paring and dovetail chisels I like Berg (very slender shoulders that will get into acute angles well); Mortising chisels have been a mixed bunch to date, but over the past several months I have been concentrating on the Oval Bolstered variety, and this means Ward, Sorby and a few others (most of these require new handles, which I am enjoying making in different woods).

At the end of the day the monetary cost of importing vintage steel can get quite close to the cost of new steel bought locally. I do have a "collection" of Japanese chisels as well, mostly new, some vintage. Then there is the so-called cost of refurbishment. The time is takes to make an old chisel usable is not viable if one places an hourly labor cost on it all. However, this is not the way I look at it. I do not factor in my time as if I were at work (the current recommended rate for a clinical psychologist in private practice in Australia is $181 AUD per hour). I certainly could buy a lot of new LNs or Barrs if I did extra time at work. Life is not like that. I would much rather see tool restoration as part of the hobby woodworking is for me. If it takes a couple of hours (or more) to restore one $10 chisel, so be it - this just makes it more special.

In the end it will come down to your own personal objectives and beliefs. For myself I have many tools that are valuable, not for their commercial rate, but for the time put into them that has created an intimacy that a new tool cannot do.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Chisels . . .

#8

Re: my jaundiced perspective on buying used chisel

ThomD

>1) The cast steel chisels are often very good, and you can pick up for a few bucks through to 10 bucks a chisel that would cost 80-120. I have several timber iszed chisels that are better than Barr chisels, and they cost me a pretty penny.

You can flaten the backs in seconds with a belt sander. That's what you will get if you buy them new.

I prefer to see old tools before I buy, but most of that may be due to how ridiculously expensive ebay related shipping is to Can.

Re: Chisels . . .

#9

Re: Why I buying chisels on eBay

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Derek, I've drooled over piles of Addis and Herring chisels, as well as quite a few wooden molding planes, from Australian sellers. I never bid on them because of the shipping costs. :)

Pam

PS All you'd need to do to include Alf, me, and any other women wandering through, is to say "most of you."

Re: Chisels . . .

#10

availability

bill tindall

>You can include eastern TN in the list of places where one will never see vintage hand tools of any quality. Back when makers of fine cabinetry were buying these quality chisels (planes, saws, etc.) in the NE, people here (and a lot of other places) were living in log cabins in the woods. Over the years few of these tools have diffused far from their origin and many of those that have have sufferd from the journey.

Re: Chisels . . .

#11

Re: Why I buying chisels on eBay

paul womack

>In the end it will come down to your own personal objectives and beliefs. For myself I have many tools that are valuable, not for their commercial rate, but for the time put into them that has created an intimacy that a new tool cannot do.

Seconded, emphatically.

BugBear