Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

Posts

LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

#1

LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

Doug Littlejohn

>Adam wrote a real interesting article in this months PWW that discussed the concept of coarse, medium and fine woodworking and the hand and power tools that supported that concept. It makes a bunch of sense to me. Now, I am a budding amatuer WW who is just getting his shop together and has most of the basics in both power and hand tools.

Thinking through Adam's approach and how I would work, I see the use of power tools to do the stock prep, surface planing, thickness planing and maybe initial cutting to working sizes for the stock, etc. This would seem to be mostly the 'coarse' work.

Then I would use hand tools to finish up stock, do the joinery, final smoothing, fitting, etc.. This would seem to be the medium and fine work. Adam built the case that the coarse work in hand tools would be the Jack (Fore) plane followed by the jointer for the medium work and the smoother for the fine work (if memory serves me right).

So now the question is, in my setup of using power for stock prep and then handtools for the rest, would that indicate I would just need the LV BU Jointer and the Smoother?? (I have a full assortment of Stanleys but as a gift to use my gift certs, I'm looking at the BU Veritas planes. Also, I just picked up (on backorder) a LN 60-1/2R on sale for $119 at Woodcraft so don't need any help there (stealth gloat)).

Am I off here? Just the Jointer and Smoother or is there a good reason to get the Jack (Fore) as well?? or am I barking in the wrong tree or even the wrong forest here?

TIA,

Sherwood

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

#2

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

Bjenk Ellefsen

>I will let the more experienced guide you here but just so we all know what article you are refering to it's Coarse, medium and fine by Chris Schwartz and not Adam.

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

#3

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

Greg Sloop, Portland Oregon

>If you have a power jointer then the hand jointer isn't needed, not really anyway.

If you don't, and you're going to do very long pieces, then the jointer is nice.

However, I still think the Jack is the *first* plane to own in any and all cases, privided you don't have other hand planes.

Small block next.

Then Smoother.

Then Jointer.

Clearly, these are my opinions. Some will probably quibble that the small block is first - perhaps.

Still for me the jack is most used.

Lastly, some might feel the smoother comes before the jointer. Again, perhaps. But in my case, I have no power jointer and I can do most smoothing without real hassle on the LV LA Jack just fine.

(I assume you know that the neatest feature of the Veritas Bevel up planes, in that they all share the same irons between all the planes.)

HTH,

Greg

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

#4

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

Jim in Burlington On

>If you have a full collection of stanley's and are looking to add a BU plane start with the jack and get the 38 degree blade. After you try that plane out you'll end up using it for alot of different work forget the label it's a awesome smoother and jointer for 90 percent of all the work I do.

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

#5

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>"Just the Jointer and Smoother or is there a good reason to get the Jack (Fore) as well??"

Hi Doug

I would go along with the advice in Greg's post - if you are starting out with flat surfaces, then the BU Jointer (BUJ) is far, far less important than a plane to smooth the surface.

Depending on the length of the wood you use, you have a choice of (in the Veritas BU range) the LA Smoother (LAS, #4 size), the BU Smoother (BUS, #4-1/2 size) and the LA Jack (LAJ, #5-1/2 size).

There is a limitation when you choose the BUS and BUJ combination - neither can be used on a shooting board. I happen to think that a shooting board is one of the most important tools one has (or should have). Therefore, the smoother needs to be either the LAS or LAJ. Both excell in this department.

So it could end up with these three possible combinations:

- LAS plus BUJ

- LAS plus LAJ

- BUS plus LAJ

Of course if you already have a plane for the shooting board - and essentially you can use anything that lies flat on its side, just that a plane with a low cutting angle works best - then the above combinations are no longer relevant, and my first plane combination choice would be built around the BUS.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

#6

In defense of the jointer

Christopher Schwarz

>Doug,

Based on what you've written, I would skip the jack plane. I think you need a long jointer and a smoother to work with your power equipment.

Let me take a moment to brace for eviseration from the crowd that likes their jack planes. OK.

For cabinet-scale work, a jointer will afford you straighter edges and flatter surfaces than a jack plane. That is a matter of plane mechanics relating to sole length, not opinion.

For cabinet-scale work, a smoothing plane will get into the hollows left by your other tools and reduce the number of strokes needed to get your work to a finished state faster. Again, this is because of sole length.

Can you successfully joint with a jack plane? Yes, especially on shorter work. Can you successfully smooth with a jack plane? Yes, if you are willing to take a few more passes.

But there's a reason it's called a jack plane. It's a great length for adaptation. It is a jack of all trades.

Me, I work faster when I have one tool for each of the three operations I discussed in the article you referenced. A jack (set as a fore plane) for roughing. A jointer for truing. A smoother for smoothing.

Hope this helps you where the article did not.

Chris

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

#7

I totally agree.

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

#8

Get the jointer

John Clifford in Chicago

>What ever combo you end up with for now (I've a feeling you'll get all three eventually) get the jointer. A power jointer is good for the "coarse" work but when it comes time to joint an edge for edge glueing forget the power jointer. No matter how nice your power jointer is you'll get a better surface and therefore a better joint with the jointer plane. And one more thing, you can create a sprung joint with the hand plane that you can't do with the power jointer. Just my .02 ;-)

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

#9

Re: In defense of the jointer

Greg Sloop, Portland Oregon

>Chris, I agree...

However, what order do you get them in?

With my Table Saw and jack, I can/could do pretty well without the jointer.

Having the jointer would improve the time factor and perhaps some on quality. But I still use the Jack far more.

You have two items on the balance.

More planes with one dedicated to a smaller range of tasks, with more cost - vs - less cost, but fewer planes dedicated to a wider range of tasks.

IMHO, the Jack is the best bang for the buck.

However, if you're going for more and soon, then perhaps buying the jointer first, with smoother next works too.

Anyway, there's a million ways to skin a cat. I just like getting people a plane as their first that goes everywhere pretty well. If they have a good experience, they'll decide where to jump next and still get a lot of mileage from the Jack.

Cheers,

Greg

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

#10

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

I'm Dave Too

>Funny you should ask. I just got the LV BU Jack this week. I started with the smoother, but it's just too light and short to tackle all of my planing needs. Got the BU jointer last month. Now THAT'S one hell of a useful plane! After looking at the two together, I could see that the 15" BU Jack would fall right in between. I'll be reaching for the Jack plane now instead of struggling along with the smoother for tasks it's not really up to. The extra heft of the Jack is as important as getting the extra length.

You can NEVER have too many planes! :)

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

#11

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>Hi Doug,

It is nice to have all three planes.

I use the my LN Low angle Jack with a low angle blade (and tight mouth) for initial stock prep and getting things pretty flat followed by my jointer plane to dial it in to dead flat (or close to flat).

The jointer plane is also nice for creating "spring joints" when edge jointing boards. I don't think a power jointer can do that.

Once I have one face flat I either flip it and dimension it with handtools or run it through a power planer.

Smoothing plane is a must have. I like the LN 5.5 for the work I do and appreciate the heft it carries.

Not a fan of the Bevel Up parade. I like dedicated planes for dedicated tasks. I do own two blades for my Low angle jack but very rarely use the second blade as the LN 5.5 york pitch gives me a nice surface

Cheers

Dan Clermont

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

#12

Veering off question....About that article...

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I would like to read that article. From your description it piques my curiosity. I'm not sure how one equates choices of tools to "course" or "fine" woodwork? Where can I find that article please?

Does the article imply that choice of tools dictates the difference between "course woodworking" and "fine woodworking"? Does the author further define those terms?

Tommy

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

#13

in Popular Woodworking magazine

Tom Sontag - St. Louis

>

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

#14

Re: Veering off question....About that article...

Dan Donaldson

>The coarse and fine designations are relating to the operations, not the furniture;-) Coarse is the initial prep, such as taking a rough sawn board to generally flat. Medium would be getting it even, and then fine is the final smoothing.

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

#15

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

Patrick Gibbons, Houston, Tx

>If you have a full compliment of Stanleys you don't need the bevel up planes. You want them. That's different. Buy the one that appeals to you most right now.

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

#16

Thanks Dan

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>Thanks for clarifying Dan. For a moment there I thought I might have a bone to pick. ;-)

I might still hunt down that article.

Tommy

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

#17

Sincere apology to Chris, my bad

Doug Littlejohn

>Both Adam and Chris wrote excellent articles in this months PWW and leave it to me to incorrectly remember who wrote what. Adam wrote the article on setting up your workshop from a handtool perspcetive.

Thank you for correcting my bad.

Sherwood

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

#18

Re: In defense of the jointer

Doug Littlejohn

>Thanks Chris. IF you reread my original post on this, I implied just that. From what I read, the Jack was equated to mostly the 'coarse' work. Sure it can do both smoothing and joint work but as you pointed out, it is more suited for the coarser work.

So my thinking was to get the Jointer, then the Smoother and if $$ permits, the Jack.

What I wanted to add into the mix is that I have alot of Stanley's, albeit not all tuned yet. I have #'s 2, 3, 4, 4-1/2 (my favorite), 5, 5-1/4, 5-1/2, 6, 7. Then I have a 9-1/4, 60-1/2, 60-1/2R (stealth gloat, Woodcraft has them on sale for $119, my first LN), 12, 71, 80, 90, 93, 110, 220 and 112 and I forgot my #62 which I am considering selling and using those $$ to get the Jack later, a sprinkling of shaves and scrapers and last but not least a Knight smoother and a HNT shoulder plane.

I know many of those who frequent this board operate similarly to how I want to operate with the balance of power and hand tools, and I wanted to use my gift cards for something I would not normally have bought (this list of things to get at LV is long) so hence the idea of getting what by most measures are an excellent planes in quality, function and improvement of the technology.

I wanted to hear the debate from all of you on this and I must say thank you to all of you for what you have contributed. Now I have to digest all of it and make a decision.

Sherwood

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

#19

Most definitely

Doug Littlejohn

>that is the case. It is not a case of need, but rather want and desire. Except for maybe the #62 I have, I would not even entertain disposing of any of my Stanley's as I have worked quite hard to obtain my collection. Not that I am a collector but as a general principle, I would much rather work with a tool that has a long history of use than something new and shiney, most of my Stanley's are type 11's, my favorite. If the LV planes were available 50-100 years old, I would be trying to get those, not new ones from LV.

Sherwood

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

#20

Thank you all

Doug Littlejohn

>I wanted to hear (read) a debate of these issues from you folks whom I respect imensly, taking into account CHris's article and what I have and how I want to work.

You have all esponded with good and reasoned thinking and I appreciate it.

Now I have to digest it all and make a decision but I am leaning twowards all 3, although it make not come all at once.

Thanks,

Sherwood

PS - When I do decide and acquire, I will post just so's I can gloat!!!

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

#21

Re: Most definitely

Dean J in MN

><rant mode on>

Sure is a shame LV/LN doesn't make dados, rabbets, fillesters, hollows, rounds, complex moulders, ... HINT HINT HINT ROB/TOM

</rant mode off>

Seeing as you have a full fleet of bench planes, you are just duplicating function if you buy YABP. (Yet another bench plane).

Sorry, had to rant...

-Dean

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

#22

So, then,

Bill Houghton, sunny, but ya can't trust the sky

>what operations, exactly, are you unable to do with your existing set of planes?

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

#23

So....

HC Sakman

>He just wanna buy some new planes, that's all. Don't spoil his fun! ;-)

Chico...

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

#24

Looking for an excuse to buy a plane eh?

Dave Thompson - Champaign IL

>Since you have all that covered in your current aresenal, why not buy some planes that do something different.... like:

073, 042, 041 - shoulder plane. excellent for tennon tuning

98, 99, 2506 - dado/groove/fillester/rabbet fine tuning.

100 - mini squirrel tail. my favorite for small work.

spoke shave - unusual wood shaping.

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

#25

Re: LV BU planes and Adams article (long)

Bob Fawcett

>Interesting you picked that order. That is exactly the order I bought in. I did not have an order in mind, I just bought what I needed as I went along.