Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

planeing after gluing

Posts

planeing after gluing

#1

planeing after gluing

chichi

>I need your help. I machine planed two red oak boards to make a top for a dresser.I jointed and then edge glued them. There is, of course, glue to clean up, but the board surfaces do not meet perfectly at the seam. There is about 1/16 to 1/8" or so ridge at certain points along the seam.

How do I eliminate the seam? The boards are flat and relatively smooth. If I use a smoother plane,I wont catch the ridge unless I really extend the plane blade. An extended blade will cause tear out. If I get tear out, I will have to plane the entire surface. Oak is tough and I am not good with a plane (yet!)I am likely to make things worse or will need to plane so much away, the board will become too thin.

I have had this problem before and never had a good solution. A lot of work and poor results.

To better understand, am I correct that because the board is fairly flat, an extended blade is needed which is risky or can some incredibly finely tuned plane catch the ridge yet not cause tear out in oak? I am sure Rob Coswell with fabulous planes and skill could probably fix easily, but what is the best approach for a rube like me?

Please be as detailed as possible because I have tried everything in the past and I do have a Lie-n bevel down smoother. It is great, but not that great in my hands.I hope I dont have to use a hand scrapper. It has bailed me out on small surfaces ,but scraping a surface this large takes away any sense of fun. I would rather use my scrub and leave a scalloped surface than try to scrape the problem away. Of course, avoid the seam in glue up is the best solution , but we are not all that good.

Thanks in advance.

Bob

Re: planeing after gluing

#2

Re: planeing after gluing

I'm Dave Too

>Belt sander or use a high angle (York angle or greater) plane.

Re: planeing after gluing

#3

Re: planeing after gluing

I'm Dave Too

>and keep the mouth tight (just a bit of daylight showing through)

Re: planeing after gluing

#4

Re: planeing after gluing

John Clifford in Chicago

>You said there is a 1/16 to a 1/8 inch ridge at the seam in some places. First it's probably not that big, I'm sure it's nowhere near the 1/8 and most likely less than the 1/16 too. It will feel like a huge amount when you run your finger over it but it probably isn't as bad as you think. I'm saying this b/c if it is a 1/16 to an 1/8 and you only remonve material at the glue line(seam) you're going to have one heck of a dip in the middle of your board. By the way this isn't a job for your smoother. First you need to get rid of any dried glue if you didn't already, if not you'll dull your plane iron in a hurry planing that glue line. So this means the scraper. Next use a longer plane, jack, fore, or jointer depending on how long this board is. Set the plane for a somewhat thick shaving, say 5 or 6 thou. Anything thicker and you'll have a tough time pushing the plane, unless you have a pretty good curve on your blade. 5 to 6 thou, it's about the thickness of a thick piece of paper. This is a good place to start. Keep an eye on that ridge to see what kind of progress your making. As you get closer start taking finer shavings, you don't want to go to far. When that ridge is gone you need to realize a couple of things. First, you probably took most of your shavings off of only one of the two boards that were glued together. Do you see where I'm going? The board that didn't get planed much is now thicker. Guess where the "extra" thickness is. Yep, on the other side of the board The other side will have an identical mirror opposite of the ridge you just removed. Does it matter? I don't know, will it show? Will the ridge affect any future joinery you may need to cut on this board? Questions you'll have to answer for yourself. By the way your not done with your first "show" side. You'll need to the level the board in it's width or, like I said you'll have a dip at the glue line. I'd keep using that longer plane set for a semi-fine shaving (3ish thou) till everything evens out. Use winding sticks to check your progress and to make sure you don't introduce any twist into the board. Once everything looks good, break out that nice LN smoother finely set for 1 to 2 thou, and smooth the whole face and then you'll be done. Depending on the size of the board it'll probably take less time to do than it did for me to type this. You'll be fine and you'll most likely enjoy the process too. John.

Re: planeing after gluing

#5

Re: planeing after gluing

Kevin F, New Zealand

>If it really is 1/16 to 1/8 I'd rip it apart down the glue line and glue it again, taking great care to get a closer fit this time. When you read what it will take to plane it out, I think you'll agree that mine is a path of less resistance.

To get the boards to align better during the glue-up, you could use cauls that cross the glue line at right angles - with waxed paper to ensure you don't glue them on.

Cheers

Kevin

Re: planeing after gluing

#6

I support this suggestion to start over, how to...

bill tindall

>Rip this assembly apart and start over.

If there is even a 1/16 irregularity in a one joint glue-up there is a flaw in your gluing technique. First, flatten boards before glueing , by whatever means you choose. My choice is a jointer with a power cord attached to get one side flat, followed by a thickness planer. Two flat boards can be glued up so perfectly that a card scraper will remove irregularities.

I never use cauls; I can make more perfect joints without them. I lay the boards on a multitude of clamps, apply plenty of glue to an edge, rub edges together to transfer glue to both edges. Then, starting in middle, begin applying clamp pressure while coaxing the joint into perfect alignment. While diddling with pressure on boards to keep jont aligned, tighten clamps from center to each edge. You can lift up on the ends of the boards to raise them to get the joint aligned (which is why you start in the middle). If all this sounds complicated, then practice making perfect joints on two scrap pieces till you got it right before proceeding to project wood.

In cases I have stood on a bowed joint, resulting from unflat boards, while wife cranked clamps. and in extreme cases even set a jack on a bow and jacked against ceiling joists to flatten a bow. But that is advanced clamping technique, unnecessary for previously flatttened boards.

For multiple joint glueups, glue up from thick boards planed "hit and miss" . followed by flattening the panel after glue-up.

Re: planeing after gluing

#7

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Another plane

Jim in Burlington On

>I've often thought a plane with a groove like a fly rod fisherman's plane would be close to the answer.

Re: planeing after gluing

#8

Re: planeing after gluing/success

chichi

>I followed John's instructions and he was right, the lip was not that bad. I reworked the entire piece length and width with a #5 set for a heavy cut. I followed up with a bedrock smoother and then the Lie-n smoother.Surface was very flat and smooth except for one board which had some very coarse swirly grain. I used the sander for a few minutes and follow up with the scrapper. very satisfactory result in 20-30 mins. after I tuned up the #5. Thanks for the encouragment and advice.

Bob

Re: planeing after gluing

#9

Re: planeing after gluing/success

John Clifford in Chicago

>Good job Bob. Now wasn't that fun too. The more you use the planes, the better you'll get, and the more you'll turn to them. Then of course you'll "need" more planes and you'll find those are great to use/have/look at, and the next thing you know you'll have planes any which way you look in your shop. And then you know what you'll have? I good start ;-) John.