WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Should I or shouldn't I

Posts

Should I or shouldn't I

#1

Should I or shouldn't I

Randy Johnson

>About fifteen years ago I bought a carpenter�s tool chest at an auction. It was complete with all the original trays and dividers and even had the key, attached to a length of furnace chain, inside. On the back and inside the original finish is still there, but the top, front, and sides were painted over with beige latex because the previous owner had used it as a sort of small table setting against a wall.

The chest has just a bit more style than you normally see, and I think it made of mahogany. (based on small ding on a bottom corner.) There is sheet metal reinforcing, that I�m hoping is brass, on the edges of the sides and front/back that appears original to the chest .

The question is:

Should I strip it down and refinish it natural, try to remove the latex without damaging the original finish underneath, or just leave it alone? Is there a good way of removing latex without damaging older (possibly/probably lead based) finishes?

I am primarily a Normite, but the hand tool collection keeps growing and the chest is more than large enough for the current collection of planes, drawknives, chisels, and saws. What I don�t want to do is ruin something in the course of �improving� it.

The original finish is flat red on the inside and outside frame with the panel sections either green or yellow. I think it�s yellow but I don�t have it here to look at.

Re: Should I or shouldn't I

#2

Re: Should I or shouldn't I

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>I vote for strip the paint, but leave the original finish. I've taken paint off old stuff before, and found that Bix strip stuff works pretty well. OTOH, I just don't like painted wood, but that's just me.

Bruce

Re: Should I or shouldn't I

#3

Re: Should I or shouldn't I

John K in Hastings, MN

>Is this for use or investment?

If resale is an issue, leave it alone or do the minimum of removing paint.

If it is for use, I'd strip it to bare wood, repair and resand, and restore it to its former glory, then fill it with tools.

They aren't really valuable antiques, you know.

Re: Should I or shouldn't I

#4

Re: Should I or shouldn't I

Adam Cherubini

>They aren't really valuable antiques, you know.

They aren't now. But they maybe someday.

I say try to strip the latex and leave the original stuff intact. My guess would be that it would have had some oil base paint on its exterior. Blue green is typical, but reddish brown was also a cheap pigment. Never seen a tool chest in two colors. I would try as best you can to restore the original paint. Whatever you do, don't strip it down to bare wood. That's my vote, anyway.

Adam

P.S. A red and yellow tool chest? Yikes! Next your going to tell us it belonged to an Scotch/Irish joiner named R.McDonald!

Re: Should I or shouldn't I

#5

I Agree...

Scott Burr in really rainy Ben Lomond,CA

>Just Clean off the Laytex...

Scott, who has been accused of being a few fries short of a happy meal...

Re: Should I or shouldn't I

#6

Re: Should I or shouldn't I

Randy Johnson

>I was at the shop yesterday afternoon and noticed that the panel section is green, not yellow.

As a matter of interest, the son of the person who had the auction where I bought the chest later gave me two more that are nice boxes but lack the style of this one. Both had "stuff" in them. Most of it ran from common to junk but there were a few treasures. A tool collector friend recieved a Winchester monkey wrench and offset screwdriver. There was also a type 11 #4 but rust had rendered it pretty much user only or salvage for parts.

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.