Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

Dilemma, I need your input please

Posts

Dilemma, I need your input please

#1

Dilemma, I need your input please

Doug Littlejohn

>Several of my presnts were of course LV gift cards. I think I have decided that rather than just keep getting things off of my running list, to get something I normally would not.

So, I think I would like to get one of their BU planes and the question is, should I get the Jack or the Smoother??? I can only get one right now and I would like to get the one that has the most uses. (I have a rull range of Stanleys, #2 thru #6, 4-1/2, 5-1/2, 62, etc.)

Also I have heard tell that their LA Jack works so much better than the 62 that I should maybe sell the 62 and buy the LV LA jack instead. What are your thoughts on that? or does the BU Jack fill in for that?

I'm pretty confused which way to go (course if I had $$, I would just buy them all!! dream on!!).

TIA,

Sherwood

Re: Dilemma, I need your input please

#2

Re: Dilemma, I need your input please

Bob Fawcett

>I have the LA Jack. When I bought it it was my only plane. I used it to scrub, joint, and smooth. It does a good job for all. Just change or reset the iron. Can't comment on your stanleys, the only one I ever used was a recent model that had never been tuned. It was almost unusable.

Re: Dilemma, I need your input please

#3

Re: Dilemma, I need your input please

HC Sakman

>LA Jacks are my most used planes. More the better, fitted with different angled blades. Jacks are good for all, hence the name "Jack". ;-)

Chico...

Re: Dilemma, I need your input please

#4

Re: Dilemma, I need your input please

Jerry Nicholson

>This is NOT to be taken as advice but I have gotten the impression that you could sell a decent #62 for enough to buy a whole bunch of LV planes. I just got the BU smoother for Christmas, along with a 60 degree blade and am thinking about selling my Clifton #5 and getting the LA jack, probably with a spare 50 degree blade.

Jerry

Re: Dilemma, I need your input please

#5

Comparison/review of the LV LAJ and Stanley #62 *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Sherwood

I have both the LV LA Jack and the Stanley #62. They are quite different planes.

As you know, the #62 inspired the LAJ, but where LN copied the #62 fairly closely, LV increased its size and created a #62-1/2. So comparing the two planes is like comparing a #5 with a #5-1/2.

I like the LAJ for its heft and durability. On a shooting board this translates into trimming hardwood endgrain with ease. Yet I also enjoy the more delicate feel of lighter #62, and prefer it for trimming softwood endgrain. If you have ever used a small block plane (like a 60-1/2) on a shooting board, then you will know what I mean.

On face grain the heft of the LAJ lifts it into a different class altogether. It has a wider blade (I will exclude thickness here since I have fitted a thicker LN blade to my #62), which it shares with the Bevel Up Smoother and Bevel Up Jointer. In this sense, the LAJ has a wider potential application.

Do you keep the #62? I guess that depends on whether you can justify this financially, and whether you can rationalise having two planes that overlap on the same tasks.

Below is a link to a more formal review and comparison of the two planes.

Regards from Perth

Derek


Review/comparison of LAJ and #62

Re: Dilemma, I need your input please

#6

The LV LA Jack is the most versitile.

Greg Sloop, Portland Oregon

>It depends on what you currently have, but around 80-90% of my work gets done with the Jack.

If I could only have one, it would be a LV LA Jack.

Block plane next, then LV LA jointer, and LV LA heavy smoother last.

Cheers,

Greg

Re: Dilemma, I need your input please

#7

Thank you all very much. one more short question?

Doug Littlejohn

>Where would the LV medium or large shoulder plane fit in??

TIA,

Sherwood

Re: Dilemma, I need your input please

#8

Re: Thank you all very much. one more short questi

Greg Sloop, Portland Oregon

>For me, probably way down on the list. After any of the above, and probably after one of the skew planes.

But don't trust me, I'm in territory I'm way out of my depth on.

If it requires some hand-plane I don't already have or can't jigger to work, then really, I probably don't need it. (I have: LN LA Block, LA Jack, Smoother, Jointer, and a nice Stanley 78 Rabbet)

The Jack gets all the work. The others mostly sit around looking pretty...

(Just don't tell my wife about that...)

Cheers,

Greg