Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Exotic Hardwood, Personally Sourced Worldwide. Inspected at Origin. Shop Rare Stock.

Bridge City Planes

Posts

Bridge City Planes

#1

Bridge City Planes

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>I am just curious.....

I have a small number of Bridge City measuring and marking tools. All have been gifts. They are nice, pretty to look at and perform well.

I still get their catalog and I am blown away at the price of their hand planes. Then last night I read an article that they were coming out with a multi-pitch plane that will sell for $1,500!

I cannot imagine these planes work any better than LNs or LVs for that matter. Am I wrong? Are these planes worth that money or are they merely "trophy tools"?

Tommy

Re: Bridge City Planes

#2

Re: Bridge City Planes--Lyn?

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>It sounds like an interesting design. Will have to hear from someone who tries one before venturing a guess as to value. Lyn's thoughts would be weighty. I don't know whether he gets to test BCTW products.

A couple weekends ago Garrett Hack was here in Pittsburgh for a hand tools class. He brought along a REALLY expensive smoother from a well known plane maker. I just had to try it out, more than anything else to be able to say I had touched one, and it worked very well. But Garrett told us that he gets just as good results from a tuned Stanley--and then proved it with some sub-1-thou full blade shavings from a Bedrock.

He also told of paying WAY more for a chariot plane from the same maker, according to him not the wisest purchase he ever made. Asked, with a smile, whether any of us wanted to buy it.

I got the impression, without his specifically saying so, that in his view hand planes may be one area where simple solutions are best. For what my opinion is worth, that's certainly how I feel.

Best, Ted

Re: Bridge City Planes

#3

Re: Bridge City Planes

paul womack

>I make no comment on Bridge City Tool in general. IIRC we've *HAD* that flame war.

Then last night I read an article that they were coming out with a multi-pitch plane that will sell for $1,500!

On performance, ingenious and wondrous though a multi-pitch plane is, it seems inevtiable to me that a committed pitch plane (of pitch X) is likely to be simpler and more robust, and hence perform better than a variable pitch plane configured to pitch X.

BugBear

Re: Bridge City Planes

#4

For that money...

Thomas Skaggs, Foothills of Mount Level

>....it seems that I could buy several LN's or LV's of varying pitch and size. Multi-pitch a neat idea? Maybe, but for some reason it brings to mind memories of a Shopsmith I once owned. ;-)

Tommy

Re: Bridge City Planes

#5

Alternate VP solution

Dave Thompson - Champaign IL

>I received their Variable Pitch tool porn poster the weekend after thanksgiving and went through that thought process. Now, I've always wanted a variable pitch plane, however at that price I don't think it'll happen. I did forward photos of that non-produced old patented one that was posted here a few months ago to Tom Lie-Nielsen. He thought it was pretty cool. My hope was that he make a frog for his existing planes.

Regardless, my thinking on the Bridge city was, I can get an LN 164, and 36 additional blades eached beveled at various angles for the same price. ;-) Since I probably only want to cover an angle from 35 to maybe 60 degrees, and I think 5 degree increments would be just fine, 5 additional blades is probably all I would ever really want. Total price $235 + $175 = $410. Of course, 45 and 50 degrees are already pretty well covered by other planes I have (so I wouldn't need to duplicate), which drops this VP solution to $340.

Dave

Re: Bridge City Planes

#6

Life is about choices

Ron in Kokomo

>There are folks who will pay $10,000 for a bottle of wine which they will drink in 30 minutes.

I have had some BC layout tools given to me. As near as I can tell my old Starrett tools work just as well. I mean Square is square... right?

I have a couple of other theories about this which are flammable... :) so I'll keep them to myself and wish you all a very Merry Christmas.

Re: Bridge City Planes

#7

Re: Bridge City Planes

ThomD

>The first or second plane I made back around'80, was capable of 4/10000". It wasn't much, just a scraper blade from one of the scraper planes LV was handling at the time, in a white oak block. The blade was never really tight enough, but for shavings of that size it doesn't need to be.

Ulmia made a variable pitch plane, I never got to buy one, and I don't think they are still available. But they were only a few hundred, and with the right blade, those planes rock. I think a dialable VP would be pretty cool. I like the Rali planes a lot, particularly if Hotley would start making them, or anyone a little more serious. The ability to vary projection even during the stroke is pretty cool, so why not on VP, if that ever gets done.

So far I don't think most BC stuff, least of all their planes, is all that serious. Mostly just for looks, but then the same is true of cabinetmaking also. It's all about doing excelent work that is functional and pleasing. People don't buy furniture on the basis we discuss planes, in fact I'm not sure serious woodworkers, vs tool collectors, worry about the spec sheet on planes either. There is a fedback loop where over time the stuff that seems excessive makes it's way into standard items. And the average woodworker has grown a lot from Popular Mechanics Handy Family cartoon projects to pretty complicated stuff these days.

Re: Bridge City Planes

#8

Trophy tools...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond,CA

>I think you summed it all up there Tommy.

Scott who doesn't own (or probably never will) any BC tools.

Re: Bridge City Planes

#9

That;s right!

HC Sakman

>I had two clients who bought my wine cabinets to store their several grand a bottle wines. Sad thing, some of my cabinets went down to the cellars!

Chico...

Re: Bridge City Planes

#10

The main problem

Jim Reed @ Tallahassee

>with any combo tool is set up time. When I get crankin' I use about three #45s with different sized blades. Phooie on combo tools unless you can afford several of them preset to perform a function.

Re: Bridge City Planes

#11

Re: Bridge City Planes

John Edwards

>As with many things in life you get what you pay for. Often times what you pay for isn�t a tangible item you can hold in your hands.

As the Wine response indicated beauty is in the eye of the beholder.

Is the 10,000-dollar bottle better then the 10-dollar? Depends how thirsty you are......

But I�d be willing to bet that the A31 that Mr. Hack is referring too will be worth more in 100 years then the Stanley or LN.

Re: Bridge City Planes

#12

Re: Bridge City Planes

ThomD

>Certainly if they don't sell many of them. And the tools of a master that were ground away on stones won't be available for sale.

Could be wrong though. Some Martin guitars are worth a fortune. You have to make enough of them to get interest, but not enough of them surviving certainly helps value. The stanley market is pretty robust, and those planes are just awful.

Re: Bridge City Planes

#13

Re: Bridge City Planes

Mark Nowicki

>Ok, you have a bet, looser buys beer at Mr. Pickwicks Pub in Stowe, Vt.

See you on December 22, 2105.

Mark Nowicki

Re: Bridge City Planes

#14

A number of years ago in FWW

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>there was an article written by a guy who told of a visit to a friend. Now the friend's shop was a trophy, the newest widgets, handtools, brand new unisaw, the top of the line of every conceivable tool. The author said he was really envious, thinking back on his own very modest collection of tools, thinking of the methods he had devised to overcome not having the right tool. His wife asked his friend's wife what stuff he actually made with all those wonderful tools. The friend's wife replied in a very disgusted tone of voice, "make? You think he actually makes things with them?

Our hero said he thought back on the baby cribs, beds, dressers, tables, desks, chairs, bookcases, and an addition to the house, all made with his odd collection of old tools. He said he went home and made out an order to Garrett Wade for a new set of chisels, the good ones with the wood handles.

Merry Christmas to all!

Bruce, in very white Minnesota

Re: Bridge City Planes

#15

Re: That;s right!

Brent Smith

>Hi Chico,

Don't be sad. For a wine collector, his or her cellar is the center of the universe. Therefore they have placed your cabinets in a place of honour in their homes.

Brent

Re: Bridge City Planes

#16

Re: Bridge City Planes

Todd Hughes

>Never know it could be, always hard to predict the future worth of stuff , but I would be surprised. Historicaly with a few notable exceptions custom made items have never gone up in vaule as much as many simular factory items.Often is hard to find somebody today to resell new custom tools like this to...so what will it be like in a 100 years? Will many people really remember who this plane maker was 75 - 80 years after he died and made his last planes? I'd be surprised. You have to think to about all the future custom plane makers that will be making planes in the next 100 years too that might steal some thunder from this maker.

I don't think much of long term vaule in LN planes either,again historicaly copies or repos just never seem to do very well long term.I do think that original tools such as Stanleys will continue climbing up and up in price esp. for nice examples.I really think we are at the ground floor right now and in 25 years or so will look back with wonder how cheap things could be bought for.

....Is very much like the Vintage gun market was 25-35 years ago. Some custom guns were being made and sold for rather high prices then but today most are out of style and hard to sell for anything.Some would be hard to sell for what they cost in 1965 dollars. Those that invested in nice examples of classic originals did much , much better.... Todd

Re: Bridge City Planes

#17

Re: Bridge City Planes

paul womack

> Historicaly with a few notable exceptions custom made items have never gone up in vaule as much as many simular factory items.

Yeah - the most valuable items seem to be the rarities and exceptions made by the big makers.

(with the usual caveats about condition)

You get the intersection set of fame and rarity.

BugBear

Re: Bridge City Planes

#18

Re: Value of a tool

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>We all have things that we don't need, and a lot of times we will buy better quality things than what we really need. I bet all of my planes will outlast my lifetime.

I was raised dirt poor. My parents had 8 children, were totally uneducated having been Amish. My dad has the equivalent of a 4th grade education, but my mother went all the way through the 8th grade. When my oldest sister was born they actually lived in a dirt floor shack. My mom and dad were both hard workers, but uneducated hard workers don't make much money. My dad ended up ruining his back, had surgery when I was about 12 I think, with no insurance to pay the bill, and unable to work for a long time. They paid every cent of that bill to. My mom was a cook in a restaurant and made I think about $7 per hour at the peak of her career.

I am not wealthy now by any means; but I have worked hard to get where I am, and I live comfortably. There were many things I wanted when I was child, but I realize now that I was actually much better off without them. There are many things I want now that I can't afford, and I believe I am probably much better off without them. But occasionally, I like to buy a good tool that costs too much. I think it is a reward for being honest, faithful, and hard working. I don't normally analyze it, but this post made me realize it more than ever; to pick up a good tool and use it gives me a sense of satisfaction; a sense that there is some justice in the world, and people who work at it can get the things they want.

This might sound selfish and shallow, but I am really not that kind of person. I realize that tools do not really mean anything in the long run; people do. But occasionally it is nice to treat yourself to something you don't need, as a reward for the hard work you do. I think the Bridge City tools fit this category well. I don't own any, but perhaps someday I will.

Re: Bridge City Planes

#19

This is so true... I just changed a word of it.

HC Sakman

>"Objects do not really mean anything in the long run; people do."

They do indeed Moses...they do indeed.

Chico...

Re: Bridge City Planes

#20

Tool Porn even an outsider can spot

David Charters (Durham, NC)

>Several months ago I came across a beautiful pic of a BC block plane and had it on the desktop of my computer at work for a while. I showed it to a coworker and she said it reminded her of Playboy! I was not sure where that came from, but she mentioned decadence, and how it was over the top. I guess you can think of it as fine jewelry for woodworkers. Personally, I like to adorn my shop with old iron, but I sure wouldn�t turn down a BC plane if one was given to me. At least it makes me feel better about springing $50 for a #4 sweetheart in great condition instead of $10 for a dog chewed rusty one. Hey, decadence is a sliding scale, I can get it on the cheap and still feel like a princess in fine jewelry (or a pig with lipstick on?).

Re: Bridge City Planes

#21

The value we put on tools

Bob Hackett(Mainely,Bob)

>No Moses,it doesn`t seem shallow at all to me.I worked for better than 15 years(somtimes 2 jobs)to pay for my Snap-on toolbox and it`s contents.I allowed as how they were the best tool for the job and they paid for themselves every day I worked with them.

When my wife gave up flower arranging and took up carpentry one of the first things I did was to take her out and get her some Redwing boots and a quality pair of gloves.When cold weather hit I made sure she had a set of Carharts and Redwing insulated boots.She now understands why I spent the money.

I`m going to go out on a limb and say that unless you`ve been dirt poor(and I have too)you can never really understand what it`s like to have to live that way.I`ll also be the first to say that I sometimes find it hard to understand how rich people`s minds work,especially folks who have been rich all thier lives.I used to build yachts so I have alittle experience with rich people,I`m sure I was just as much of a mystery to them.

What all this is leading up to is that for some people pride of ownership is enough.Even if they do nothing more than set something on a shelf they`re happy to lay out whatever it takes to buy that something.For others it`s that they need a tool to get a specific job done and they understand that a quality tool works far better and ultimately pays for itself.

I`ve heard it said before here that something like a Holtey plane means nothing if you don`t posess the skillset needed to use it properly.

I`ll end my rant by quoting from the crude handmade sign over Cecil Pierce`s shop door "The finest tool evey made is the human hand,but it is weak and it is fallible".

Mainely,Bob

Re: Bridge City Planes

#22

Re: This is so true... I just changed a word of it

Richard Rerra

>Having seen the workshops of some and the astounding variety and wealth of hand tools, and power tools that became cordless... became air powered I often just say to myself "will it make me a better wordworker?" ..or "did the guy in the 18th century need it to make a Newport highboy?" More often than not it's no to both questions. Of course I'm known to be so cheap my wife encouraged me to buy a power planer the day she saw me sweating over a board I was flattening. I guess she was afraid I was gonna have the big crusher

Re: Bridge City Planes

#23

Re: Bridge City Planes

R.J.Whelan (Eastern Sierra, CA)

>Tommy .... Bridge City planes are undeniably pretty and they probably work quite well.

I happen to work part time for a fairly renowned photo gallery where the work of the principal photographer is split between open edition images (about 80%) and Limited Editions. Many collectors are not interested in open edition art; they focus, instead, on signed and numbered limited editions (which cost 2-4 times more than an open edition). This artist makes 300 copies of his limited editions; there are serious collectors for whom this number is way too high, they are looking for editions of 25 to 50.

Since starting work at this gallery I've learned that one doesn't have to understand or agree with a persons choices, but you should respect their passion and applaud the financial commitment they make - I don't have a strong desire to own one of these images but I darn sure appreciated the commission generated when I sell one.

rj