Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

The ungaloot has a thought

Posts

The ungaloot has a thought

#1

The ungaloot has a thought

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>Monday I got my check from FWW, and I had been eyeing some scrapers in the LV catalog. A scraper is a very simple tool, but a bad scraper is frustrating. A good scraper is pleasant and easy to use. I have been around galoots long enoguh to know that a true galoot takes a beat up rusty old saw and makes scrapers that will take shavings six inches wide and one micron thick. But with some shame I realized I just wasn't that good yet, punched some buttons and had 6 scrapers at my door step tonight. They were shiny and new, complete with edge guards, in 5 different thicknesses. I bought a set of four different thicknesses and the set of two extra thin scrapers.

It is not normal for me to get a tool and use it the same day. In fact, as a general rule new tools set on my desk for a week or two before they are even moved. But tonight I happened to be planing some panels and had a few spots that I thought would really benefit from a scraper. Since I now knew where there was a good scraper just itching to be used I went and pulled it off my desk. I tried a medium thick scraper out of the package without the burr and got some thin piles of sawdust. I decided it needed a hook turned and presto, I was in business. A good scraper makes truly beautiful shavings.

As I was thinking about making scrapers out of saw blades, I thought, why not make saw blades out of scrapers? If Lee Valley was to simply cut these into longer lengths, file some teeth on them, and provide a brass back, they could provide a kit for people to build there own saws. It would be a simple project that would be personalized and make a tool that would work exceptionally well I think. The right thickness and temper and you would have an inexpensive kit that people could buy to build a saw that would rival the best of them. Make a handle to suit, put it together and sharpen it and you're good to go. But perhaps there wouldn't be as much demand as I imagine. At any rate, the scrapers make nice shavings, and I will enjoy them for years to come.

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

#2

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>Moses, those are good thoughts. BUT you have not taken the concept far enough just yet (and others will probably say the same for me):

Consider - if you make a dovetail say out of a scraper blade, why not also add a scraper blade to the (new) saw, for example, keep it sharpened and protected under a brass back. Just slide off the brass back and you can scrape clean what you have just sawn!

Actually, I do know of some who have made saws out of scraper blades - I have had the yen to do so myself (make a small detail gent saw), but they are too many other projects that lie between this and that.

The question I have is whether anything can be made out of used Japanese saw blades, those with the broken impulse-hardened teeth? I really should just grab one from the drawer and see if I can turn a hook ....

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

#3

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

Frank D. in Montreal

>I make small blades (for gauges or micro chisel-like implements) out of scraper blades, they work OK and no heat treating necessary. I guess one could make a keyhole saw out of one fairly easily...now there's a thought.

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

#4

back when Patrick Leach and Pete Taran

Bruce, a MN Galoot

>developed the Independence Tool line of saws, they used the same steel to make scrapers. I suspect it might have been the left-overs of larger stock. I have a couple, the best ones in my small arsenal.

Bruce

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

#5

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

ThomD

>I bought 3 of LVs thinnest scrappers with just that in mind. I have so far only used them as scrapers.

Now that I am heat treating just about everything in sight, I think there would be reasonably simple ways of further hardening the teeth if they needed it, One could also make a sen out of harder steel so that one could scrape these blades thinner in various areas.

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

#6

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

Ted Shuck

>I made a small dovetail saw from one of the 6" long LV scrapers. I think it was 0.016" thick. I asked them to make some scraper blades available in 12" lengths and got a polite "thanks for the suggestion" reponse. Maybe if Rob Lee reads this (!), and realizes there is more interest than one addled galoot, we might see some.

Regards,

Ted

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

#7

Re: back when Patrick Leach and Pete Taran

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>I suspect Thomas Lie-Nielsen is still using the same Swedish source for his saw blade steel, and he also sells scrapers, which he clearly states are made from the same steel as his saws. They also work great. Whether they hold an edge better than the LV scrapers, I cannot tell, because there are too many uncontrolled variables, and I have no burning desire to design and perform a rigorous test.

Has anybody tried any "Special Shovel Steel" scrapers?

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

#8

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

Wayne Anderson

>Why not take materials at hand and make a saw to fit your needs? When I see good parts, I save them to use later. Picked up a good handle from a friend, took a blade and hardware, added a hunk of brass...and made a saw. The handle was painted black, I stripped it and added clear shellac; the blade had a broken handle; and the brass was from a hopelessly ugly saw. It's a frankentool, but better than the sum of its parts. No need to ask someone to supply the materials...they are out there for the taking. -wayne


img

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

#9

Re: Rob Lee

ThomD

>Good thinking, though someone mentioned that these guys sell the appropriate hardened stock. I haven't looked since I find the cross border game gets worse all the time.

http://www1.mscdirect.com/cgi/nnsrhm

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

#10

Home Depot

Sandor in Bear, DE

>I made two dovetail saws (XC and rip) from sheetrock spackle blades. They were the cheap 10" ones from Home Depot - <$4 each IIRC. Nice blue spring steel. I have not used then too much so I don't know about edge retention, but the steel looks to be the standard 1/2 hard 50Rc stuff most saws are made from. Its an easy local source.

Sandor

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

#11

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

Rob Lee

>Hi Ted -

Of course I'm reading.... I read all the boards!! :)

Rest assured that your suggestion IS on file...we listen very carefully to what you guys (and gals) ask for... it's in our best interest to do so.

A difficulty with providing longer pieces of scraper steel, is that we'd have to run a LOT of it... the conversion process from coil is automated, and we don't do that part....

I'd suggest trying a piece of steel from someting like a drywall knife at HD.... usually made from spring steel of a reasonable quality....

We'll get to saws eventually - but what you're buying there is really set and sharpening.... and that's what we've got to work out... the rest is easy. (well, as easy as anything gets.....)

Cheers -

Rob

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

#12

Duh...

Rob Lee

>... I just read Sandor's post (after making mine...).

Therefor, I must be a great mind...... :)

Cheers -

Rob

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

#13

Re: The ungaloot has a thought - Drywall knife

Ted Shuck, Centennial, CO

>Rob and Sandor,

Thanks for the suggestion of using a drywall knife. I had not thought of that. I'll stop the HD close to my office on the way home tonight to have a look.

Thanks,

Ted

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

#14

Sounds like ungulate...

Denis Ch�nard, Orl�ans, Ont.

>No bull about it? :-)

DC

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

#15

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

Todd Hughes

>In my experance it is rather difficult to harden and tempet something as thin as a saw blade with out it warping on you. If after tempering the steel isn't to hard you may be straighten the blade like you do on a bent saw though ....Todd

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

#16

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

ThomD

>I agree, but there are all kinds of home options from differential heating jigs to salt pots. Some of these require a complicated approach like a salt pot, but while there are momentary complications and costs to those things, they can remove the guesswork, and are very scaleable to the small shop.

I was dreaming of the Japanese ones that use an electric impulse. I'm figuring they are air hardening steels. Imagine making the teeth, them just resting the whole edge on a glowing red hot piece of copper. Or maybe individually pulsing each tooth with a TIG. If there was enough interest, someone would figure out a barnyard method!

I was reading the Nevil Shute book "Trustee from the Toolroom", which seems to be on a minor revival these days. In it one of the things the hero does is HT something in sand, which is something I never hear about in my circles, but appears to have been a standard basement workshop technique in Shute's day, and I think it is the technique the Japanese sawmakers use. Whatever the Japanese do, it can be done in a shop the size of a one bike garage.

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

#17

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

Todd Hughes

>Well I think saws with only hardened teeth like these impulse ones are a pretty bad idea and is probably only done to make it easier and cheaper for the factorys to make them today. Hard to sharpen and once you are past the teeth after a few sharpenings you would beinto soft steel. I really don't know what the advantage would be for a saw to have a differentialy hardened blade with harder teeth and a softer body..... I think saw makers probably got most of it right a few 100 years ago....Todd

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

#18

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

ThomD

>The advantage is that if these alternative materials like drywall knives are a few points off perfect, or a few points off perfect for certain woods, then you can harden only the tips. Shouldn't affect the filing. Might make it less necesarry.

Since a lot of tools in the old days where diff hardened, I would have to agree they may have been onto something. It's perfectly obvious they did it for economy and/for for technical reasons, and those things apply today also. If you want the whole tool relatively uniformly hard, then stick to the gentle non-burning methods.

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

#19

Re: Home Depot

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>Sandor,

Good to see you back on WC. Where've you been hiding, and when did you move from MD to DE? There's going to be a Springfield breakfast (the usual suspects) next month, but I guess from Bear it would be a bit of a hike for you.

ref: http://woodcentral.com.ldh0138.uslec.net/cgi-bin/archives_handtools.pl?read=8454

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

#20

Moses...

HC Sakman

>Please try normally sharpened 4",6" or 8" jointer blades. They do wonders and hardly need re-sharpening. (OK they do need sharpening but their HSS sharpness lasts a loooong time.) Down side, they don't flex much but then again, they don't really need to flex.

Chico...

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

#21

Not hiding...

Sandor in Bear, DE

>Just mainly lurking. Speak only if you can add to the conversation : )

Moved from MD to DE mainly b/c of $. Actually lack of $.

We bought our house in MD on two salaries, but now with the baby, my wife is staying home so.....

Land and houses are much less expensive in DE, plus I found a great job with a company called Dade Behring.

And we are 2 hours closer to family now (SW of Philly).

anyway, I look forward to setting my shop back up. I learned a lot since setting up the last one. New one will be hand centric instead of power centric.

Sandor

Re: The ungaloot has a thought

#22

Re: Not hiding...

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>Well you may be closer to some good old tool shopping now too.

Will you be able to make the trip down for PATINA this spring? I will be sorry if the location precludes another chat in person.JR