We value your privacy.
We use cookies to enhance your browsing experience, analyse site traffic, and personalise content.
By clicking “Accept all”, you consent to our use of cookies. You can also choose
“Essential only” or learn more.
>I've got yet another workbench in me and I'm considering using #1 common oak or walnut. Since the top is laminated, I can work it so any knots or imperfections don't show at the top edge. Laminated legs and stretchers can tolerate a few knots. These woods cost only $1.75/bd ft in my neighborhood (northern NJ). Maple, my usual material is about double.
>The potential problem with walnut is it's dark color. To see your work better a light colored top would be better. BUT, many have made tops out of dark wood, Jim Kingschott, David Charlesworth, and Frank Klauz just to name a few Masters who know more than I'll ever know. I prefer a light colored top, my preference and many others as well. The walnut is not nearly as hard as maple of course, but many have made benches out of soft wood, myself included, so that may not be all that important to you. As for the oak, I've seen at least one bench that I can recall, it looked nice but I'd prefer a closed grain wood for the top which would give it a smoother surface. These are just my humble opinions for what it's worth. One last thing, post pictures of the bench when your done. John.
>My brother in law, the lighting engineer, told me to be rid of my brown-masonite covered bench to achieve better visibility for detailed work. I covered bench with an off-white, coated masonite and wow, he was right. It added 25% more illumination on the work and better contrast.
Based on this experience, walnut would be a poor choice.
>Les, I made a bench of oak many years ago. I didn't have much money and I paid only 11 cents a foot for clear material. My only complaint is the coarse texture- I must put something under a paper if I want to make a nice drawing, etc.
Walnut varies quite a bit in hardness so I would look the material over pretty well when you are buying. Otherwise it would be suitable. Walnut will lighten a great deal as it ages. Both walnut and maple tend toward golden as they are exposed to air and light. The oak will darken in time.
I think that oak, walnut and beech will all absorb shock better than maple. They are also easier to work than hard maple.
>I hardly feel qualified to respond, but I did a laminated two layers of not medium, but high density fibreboard and an old library table my sister gave me, almost twenty five years ago. Other than transporting it all over the country, to widely different humidity zones, it's held up fairly well. The tabletop I used had been glued up from all different types of wood, then tinted really dark, as is common practice. It looks good, and works.
I would think if you used a good pumice or even plaster of paris grain filling, the oak would be outstanding. Done right, this yields a really nice surface. and oak is innately attractive, and plenty tough, certainly sufficient to the task.
>Why not maple up front in the "working" portion of the bench (like the first 6-8") and then oak or otherwise behind that. This is consistent historically if that sort of thing bothers you, and practically appopriate if it doesn't. :)
I have seen Shaker examples where maple was used for the front few boards, followed by a few laminations of oak, and then the rear section of the bench being a flat pine slab. The rear section of the bench really is only there for keeping something between the work and the floor. Most of the heavy hitting is happening up front.
This theory is out the window (or requires modification) if you work from both sides of your bench.
>An easy way to get that maple top everybody seems to be chasing is to visit with the local restaurant supply place and ask about a laminated wood countertop.These folks are usually involved with contractors who remodel commercial eateries so they may know where to steer you.
I picked up enough to do the entire shop for a couple of cases of beer and a visit to the job site.One piece even had some nice iron legs attached.
>For manufactured hard maple butcher block tops, probably closest to Les's area is Bally Block, which is somewhere in Eastern Pennslyvania. Seacrh the hand tool archives or main message archives for others' good experiences with their products and location.
>Oak for the top and walnut for the base. It would look real nice I think. That said, I wouldn't use walnut for the top, Seems too soft of a wood. As said, oak is a porus wood you might want to fill the grain when finishing the top.