Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Need a tree taken down or milled?

The $5 Dovetailing Vise

Posts

The $5 Dovetailing Vise

#1

The $5 Dovetailing Vise

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>My bench has two face vises at each corner. When cutting dovetails in the past I would span the vises with a Jarrah board, which then created a very large open face vise. This was terrific (no racking, which is what you get when you just use one side of a cast iron vise), but the down side was that adjustment required l-o-n-g arms.

Now I have taken it to the next level. And all it cost was the purchase of two 1/2" bolts with metal inserts. The pictures below are pretty self-explanatory. The vise is easily removable. It is a pleasure to use. And just $5.

Regards from Perth

Derek


img

Re: The $5 Dovetailing Vise

#2

Re: The $5 Dovetailing Vise

Jim Shaver - Oakville, Ontario

>What A great idea!

Take care,

Jim

Re: The $5 Dovetailing Vise

#3

Re: The $5 Dovetailing Vise

paul womack

>Very nice, look very practical.

I think this is a case of convergent evolution; Robert Wearing published a similar design a coupla' decades back.

People might like to compare (and discuss) this alternative approach:

demountable shoulder vise

BugBear

Re: The $5 Dovetailing Vise

#4

Re: The $5 Dovetailing Vise

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>Oooh BB, I like that one. I might have built it if I had thought of it.

Pros for my design: (much) cheaper, holds board very firmly (I suspect that a single screw design might cause a board to twist, plus the "back board" looks a little flimsy), can still use the face vise, you stand closer to the work (nothing inbetween you and it).

Pros for the other design: looks nicer (more traditional looking), more quickly set up (just pop it in the vise).

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The $5 Dovetailing Vise

#5

Re: The $0 Dovetailing Vise

Frank D. in Montreal

>If you have a few holdfasts, that is. Width can be adjusted as desired.


img

Re: The $5 Dovetailing Vise

#6

Re: Great Minds Etc.

Hank Knight from SC

>When I built my bench, I imbedded 4 stainless 1/2 X 13 Machinist's "T" nuts in the dog hole strip. A couple of threaded studs with aluminum speed handles and a piece of 8/4 maple complete the job. Works great.


img

Re: The $5 Dovetailing Vise

#7

Great Minds Etc. 

Hank Knight from SC

>


img

Re: The $5 Dovetailing Vise

#8

Re: Other alternatives?

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>I was thinking the same thing, only simpler yet. With a few dog holes drilled in the front face of the bench, and one simple holdfast (without the mounting hardware of the Veritas), like the models from Galena or Gramercy, why not clamp one edge of the board in the face vise and hold the other edge directly with the holdfast?

Note that, as I don't have dog holes in the front face of my bench, I usually use a pipe clamp across the top of the bench to hold the right edge of the board I'm sawing, but a basic holdfast would be quicker, and the holdfast doesn't get in the way as much as either the pipe clamp or the Veritas holdfast.

OK, I know there is one inconvenience, but it's not as extreme as encountered with a shoulder vise: If the Record type face vise is on the left, and you are right handed, getting up close to the work for sawing the left side dovetails with your right hand can be a bit of a problem.

Re: The $5 Dovetailing Vise

#9

Re: Another alternative & another question *LINK*

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>An alternative to the aluminum speed handles are these wooden ones.

Shop-made Hold-downs

I don't use these in the front face, but I do have several threaded inserts mounted in the top of the bench for their use. While Hank's buried, captured nuts would be stronger, that requires pre-planning :^), and I've never had a threaded insert pull out yet, and my benchtop is not nearly as strong as rock maple.

And now the question: Is the beam spanning the clamps really necessary? I don't use one, but I use a western style push saw, with very little resistance on the return stroke. Is the beam more important with a Japanese saw, since you would get more bowing of the stock on the power stroke and therefore more vibration?

Re: The $5 Dovetailing Vise

#10

Re: Another alternative & another question

Hank Knight from SC

>William, I like your hold downs. Actually, I was thinking about making some with a large head, like a wooden bench screw, to give more bearing surface on the vice jaw, but I've not had any problems with the speed handles. I don't know if the wooden plank is necessary, but it works fine. I guess you could use hold downs on either side of the work and probably get the same effect.

Re: The $5 Dovetailing Vise

#11

Re: Other alternatives?

paul womack

>Note that, as I don't have dog holes in the front face of my bench, I usually use a pipe clamp across the top of the bench to hold the right edge of the board I'm sawing

This technique works best if your rear face-vise jaw is flush mounted.

Since mine isn't, I would require a simple spacer to use this idea, which makes it slightly more fiddly.

The flush vs proud rear jaw dichotomy is not resolvable, since both approaches have pros and cons.

BugBear

Re: The $5 Dovetailing Vise

#12

Re: Great Minds Etc.

paul womack

>aluminum speed handles

Very nice! Where were they sourced from?

BugBear (who would need aluminium speed handles to work in the UK :-)

Re: The $5 Dovetailing Vise

#13

Re: Great Minds Etc. *LINK*

Hank Knight in SC

>BugBear, the aluminum speed handles came from MSC Industrial Supply. Click Link Below and search for MSC # 82405226 | Big Book � Page 1167. Mine are threaded for 1/2 X 13 studs, but they have other sizes.


http://www.mscdirect.com

Re: The $5 Dovetailing Vise

#14

Re: Great Minds Etc.

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>That is VERY nice, Hank. Much, much nicer than my effort.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: The $5 Dovetailing Vise

#15

Thanks, Derek

Hank Knight from SC

>

Re: The $5 Dovetailing Vise

#16

Re: Other alternatives?

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>My rear jaw is not flush with the front of the bench (I don't like pinched fingers, which of course is just one of the issues), but I resolved at least part of the dichotomy by building my board jack with a front face that is in the same plane as the rear vise jaw. It also extends upwards in front of the front face, to the level of the bench top. I don't find this particular arrangement fiddly. In fact, putting a peg in the jack helps to hold the work in place while I'm adjusting it for level and tightening the vise jaws and the pipe clamp. The board jack has two supports on the back. One hooks over the top stretcher, the other rests on thr front lip of the bottom stretcher. If your tool drawers also rest on the bottom stretcher, be sure to set them back about 3/4" to provide room for the board jack support.


img

Re: The $5 Dovetailing Vise

#17

Re: Other alternatives?

paul womack

>My rear jaw is not flush with the front of the bench (I don't like pinched fingers, which of course is just one of the issues), but I resolved at least part of the dichotomy by building my board jack with a front face that is in the same plane as the rear vise jaw.

A neat and thoughtful solution, as always.

Very nice.

BugBear

Re: The $5 Dovetailing Vise

#18

Re: Another board jack

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>This one might help a bit more with construction details. This is a side view, lalying on the floor, with the top end to the right.


It's all made from 1x6 red oak. The supports were attached with screws and glue. If I were to do it again, I would use wedged through tenons. The hook at the back of the upper support was also screwed and glued. Now, I would pin it with dowels.

The bottom support has a dog hole drilled in the top, but not all the way through, to park the dog when not in use. You can just make it out in the first photo. When the jack is not in use, I hang it from the railing of the loft, just about overhead of the face vise.

Originally, the top of the jack was flush with the top of the bench, but I raised the bench top about an inch to make room for a roll out drafting board between the top stretcher and the bottom of the bench top. It doesn't affect the functionality of the boardjack. There is a dog hole every half inch, vertically, almost all the way to the floor. If you thought you needed any finer height adjustment, you could make a dog with an eccentric head.