Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

japanese mortise gauge

Posts

japanese mortise gauge

#1

japanese mortise gauge

frank_shic (walnut ck, ca)

>anyone have any recommendations on adjusting this little contraption? i've noticed that it's tricky enough trying to get the two knife booms to approximate the mortise chisel width but then trying to subsequently adjust this paired combination relative to the fence is driving me nuts!

perhaps i should just suck it up and fork out the dough for the expensive wheel marking gauge with the FIXED cutters from lie-nielsen?

BTW the micro-adjustable wheel marking gauge from lee valley ROCKS THE HOUSE! i can't tell you how much fun i've had this past weekend practicing hand cut dovetails!

Re: japanese mortise gauge

#2

How I do it

Wiley Horne--Glendora, CA

>First, set the two blades' distance apart to your chisel width--don't worry about their distance from the fence, just get the mortise width right. When the gap is right, pinch the two blades between thumb and forefinger so they don't move relative to each other.

Second, with the blades still locked by your fingers, move them as a unit relative to the fence, and get the distance right from the fence to the inside blade. Then lock that up with the thumbscrew or wedge. Bottom line: make the blade width setting and the fence setting in two separate steps.

By the way, how much precision are you going for in locating the mortise or tenon, for example, centering it on a 4/4 board? If you're making a frame for a frame and panel, and the frame will have an integral molding of a given width, then the tenons, mortises, and panel grooves all need to line up at a given distance from the front edge. But I find most of the time, I just want to join front rails or sides (and sometimes back) to legs, and in that situation, close is fine and no agonizing is needed. The important thing is to keep that setting on that gauge, and gauge all similar mating parts off the same face. This is also why it's good to have a bunch of gauges, cause you want to keep your key settings on the gauge for the duration of the project. So you can get that fancy wheel gauge, and maybe a vintage English ebony & brass gauge, and one of those two-arm things, and .......

Wiley

Re: japanese mortise gauge

#3

Re: How I do it

frank_shic (walnut ck, ca)

>wiley, thanks for the extremely fast response and reminder: machine like accuracy isn't always the desired goal. i especially like your advice about needing MORE than just one measly marking gauge! now, what were you saying about english marking gauge? hmmm... time to do a little more "research"!

Re: japanese mortise gauge

#4

Re: How I do it

ThomD

>I have to say I don't use mine much, for whatever reason I prefer laying out with a single blade gauge, but it should be faster with the two beams. I have several of the double beams, including a vastly overproduced Bridge City version. What I do is tap my chisel into the stock where I want to make my cut. Then I hold my gauge over that mark, and press the blades into the wood on either side of the mark. With the blades securely positioned, I move the fence into position against the side of the stock and tighten of the screw.

Gauge lines should be more accurate than machine work, as should most hand tool work. Afterall a gauge has a fence and a blade just like a table saw, why when it is so handy, should it be less accurate?

The key to repeatable accuracy is to have enough gages so that even though you just eyeball everything you, you don't change out your marks so you can hold the accuracy. Another option is to use a piece of scrap to register your marks on. You can then return to them at will with complete accuracy, just stuff the blade lightly in your mark, and snug up your blade, keep the beam parallel to the surface of the stock.

Re: japanese mortise gauge

#5

I like Thom's method

Wiley Horne--Glendora, CA

>better than the one I described above, and will be switching to it.

Wiley

Re: japanese mortise gauge

#6

great ideas

frank_shic (walnut ck, ca)

>thom, thanks for sharing! i love the idea of using a scrap piece of stock to register the blades as well the fence. it may take a couple more minutes of time, but then accuracy is increased on subsequent projects. i'm also toying with the idea of drilling a hole through both moving beams to lock a 1/4" measurement in with a screw.

Re: japanese mortise gauge

#7

Quick modification (*pics)

GolfSteve in Calgary

>I made a small modification to my gauge to get around the problem you describe:-

I installed a small bolt that locks the two knives together, preventing relative motion. I drilled a small hole through the guide rod (visible in the second picture) so that the head of the bolt/screw was accessible.

Once the knives are set to the width of my mortise chisel, it's dead easy to change the fence position without changing the mortise marking width.



My intention was that the slot in the bottom knife would be exactly the right length so that at one end of the slot I would be set for 1/4", and at the other end of the slot I would be set for 3/8". Due to my poor drilling and metalworking skills this did not happen, but I think it was a good idea.

Re: japanese mortise gauge

#8

Re: great ideas

George Makowski

>Frank, Why not just make a dedicated 1/4" gauge? It can be based on a sliding beam with fixed scribing points so you can scribe at any distance from the edge or both distance from the edge and distance between the scribing points can be fixed so that everytime you reach for that tool you get that measurement (See Adam's "Arts and Mysteries" on dedicated tools that match your other tools and the processes that you use).

The best measurement is a "dead" measurement--one that has no number put to it but is taken from life.

Good gauging!

George in AL

Re: japanese mortise gauge

#9

another interesting thought

frank_shic (walnut ck, ca)

>george, i think i could probably make a marking gauge if all it entails is just cutting a hole in the middle and fitting the sliding beam to it, but what do you do for the marking cutters? x-acto blades?

Re: japanese mortise gauge

#10

actually, it's a GREAT idea!

frank_shic (walnut ck, ca)

>kinda like what i was thinking of doing, except that i was just going to default the whole thing to 1/4".

Re: japanese mortise gauge

#11

Re: another interesting thought

ThomD

>The best option are the blades Japan woodworker sells, they are available in a range of sizes, and are quite cheap, 5 dollarish (?).

I make a lot of my own tools, and you can heat treat a scrap of O1 tool steel in a propane torch. You can quench it in a can of olive oil or bacon drippings, then you can draw the temper by putting it for an hour in a toater oven at around 400.

You can grind it out of hacksaw blades, but even that is a little light. A belt grinder makes all the grinding go much faster. A 1x42 unit costs about as much as a marking gauge these days. You need the good belts though.

When I work wood though, I am usually stradling what the piece needs, and what the wood I have on hand will offer. I don't compromise, but I will take a piece of wood, and start working on it, and adjust the pieces relative to the yield, and if that works out I will look at the piece, is it too heavy, or too light. Eventualy I will start the joints. I probably have checked the dimensions, and some mechanical projects do depend on rigid dimensions, but I want to be open to the process. This is partly aesthetic and expressive, but it is also a mater of good structure. Let's say you were building from plans, and the piece called for 1/4 in. plywood for drawer bottoms, well I know they use 1/4" plywood in the hulls of some 35 foot sailboats, so maybe I would choose some other stock for the smaller drawers. I'm responding to a variety of things including my experience. What I am getting at is I rarely would have use for fixed gauges, but then someone else might.

Re: japanese mortise gauge

#12

Re: another interesting thought

Dean J in MN

>Frank --

Two 4d nails will work for pins on a mortise gauge. Or you can use drill bits. The bits are a bit harder to shape, but stay sharper longer.

Not to add confusion -- but you can mark our your mortise with a single arm/cutter as well. The chisel defines the width of a mortise, not a gauge line. Of course you still need to mark the tenon, which *is* defined by the gauge lines. But a pair if gauges set to the finished mortise width (both the near and far from the face edge) will work in a pinch.

-Dean

Re: japanese mortise gauge

#13

didn't work, wiley!

frank_shic (walnut ck, ca)

>wiley, i tried pinching the two beams together and you know what happened? the entire thing locks together so that you can't move the fence! ARGH!!! now to try the registration wood block...

Re: japanese mortise gauge

#14

Re: didn't work, wiley!

Wiley Horne--Glendora, CA

>Hi Frank,

I don't pinch them together in the beam, which would of course lock everything up, but rather out where the cutters are. So you have thumb and forefinger of one hand clamping the cutters together, while the other hand is adjusting the fence and tightening the thumbscrew. This works well for me.

However, as I said above, I'm changing. I really like the directness of Thom's method. It's less fiddly and more direct. As I understand it, you don't need a spacer block--just drive the chisel in where you want the mortise, and set everything directly off of it.

Wiley

Re: japanese mortise gauge

#15

Re: another interesting thought

George Makowski

>Frank, A post below beat me to it, but for regular gauge points I use nails set in holes drilled in the beam and the sharpened. I lock the beam (beams on my mortise gauge)on moveable gauges with a wedge.

I haven't made a round beam gauge, always rectangular. I imagine that a good wedge should lock a round beam hard enough to prevent it rotating in use.

On the arguments below about fixed gauges, they are easily made for a single job or to set a standard for a number of operations to ensure consistency of lay out.

George in AL