Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

St. Roy: Tenon saws are for wimps.

Posts

St. Roy: Tenon saws are for wimps.

#1

St. Roy: Tenon saws are for wimps.

Paul Kierstead

>Ok, he didn't actually say that, but I just watched St. Roy cut a couple of tenons with a regular ole full sized rip saw (A D8 or the like). He did reasonably nice too, without cutting himself even.

Having recently discovered the limits of using a dovetail back saw as a tenon saw, am I crazy to be investigating "Tenon saws" (i.e. back saws which have very wide blades)? Or is St. Roy just being peculiar, or perhaps doing something which requires great skill (which I am lacking)?

Re: St. Roy: Tenon saws are for wimps.

#2

Re: St. Roy: Tenon saws are for wimps.

mikew

>Not to discount the Saint's abilities...but he really isn't building fine furniture. He is doing as my great uncle and grandfather (and their forefathers) did. They made functional pieces using tools they decided to use at the time.

And from watching the little bit I did on last week's show, the tenon saw he had and was using needed sharpening *real* bad. In that case, I might have use a handsaw as well...

Re: St. Roy: Tenon saws are for wimps.

#3

Re: St. Roy: Tenon saws are for wimps.

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>My suggestion would be to go out in your shop and try cutting a tenon with a D-8 ;) See how you like it. TV shows I think are mostly run for entertainment, perhaps not so much for content. Although using what you have instead of going out and buying another tool is a very good point.

Re: St. Roy: Tenon saws are for wimps.

#4

Re: St. Roy: Tenon saws are for wimps.

Paul in NJ

>It makes perfect sense for me to use a rip saw to cut a tenon when your tenon is too deep for your back saw or the tenon is wide and your back saw does not have a coarse enough pitch. Most furniture won't have such large tenons but perhaps a workbench or an entry door might have them. I don't see any problem of cutting to the 'line' with a rip saw accurately enough to make an adequate tenon.

Paul Dzioba

Re: St. Roy: Tenon saws are for wimps.

#5

Re: St. Roy: Tenon saws are for wimps.

Dave Anderson Chester, NH

>Just this past weekend I had to make some vertical cuts on the posts of some cabriole legs to shape them for a Queen Anne handkerchief table. I used my 13pt tenon saw which is filed rip and it went just fine. I also have a Disston #7 crosscut in the 18" panel saw size with 10pts which would have done just as nice a job, though more slowly. Having said that, I wouldn't want to use my 26" #7. Too awkward and and I suspect the flex of the blade would diminish accuracy considerably.

Re: St. Roy: Tenon saws are for wimps.

#6

Re: St. Roy: Tenon saws are for wimps.

Dean J in MN

>

Having recently discovered the limits of using a dovetail back saw as a tenon saw, am I crazy to be investigating "Tenon saws" (i.e. back saws which have very wide blades)? Or is St. Roy just being peculiar, or perhaps doing something which requires great skill (which I am lacking)?


Tenon saws not only have wide (deep) blades, but are also longer than what you commonly find. I have a 16" backsaw, closer to a tenon saw, but really prefer a frame (bow) saw to cut tenons. It is lighter than the long backsaw, and has fewer tpi (9). Roy's solution has merit, a longer saw with fewer teeth to allow a tenon to be cut with speed.

Give a frame saw a try.

-Dean

Re: St. Roy: Tenon saws are for wimps.

#7

Re: normal

paul womack

>but I just watched St. Roy cut a couple of tenons with a regular ole full sized rip saw (A D8 or the like)

This is illustrated in Ellis for large tenons.

BugBear

Re: St. Roy: Tenon saws are for wimps.

#8

I do it this way all the time

Michael Recchione

>For larger tenons. I don't understand the "fine furniture" versus utilitarian distinction. If the joint fits, it fits - it doesn't care how you cut it. Even tenons for things like workbenches are relatively short; I've never noticed any problems with the saw wandering or anything. The rip saw I use is a Sandvik No. 220, which is a little shorter than some of the others mentioned - it doesn't feel unwieldy at all.

Re: St. Roy: Tenon saws are for wimps.

#9

Re: St. Roy: Tenon saws are for wimps.

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>In general I find St Roy quite entertaining.

St ROy tends to get things done with very few tools and is "very relaxed" in his woodworking techniques (although quite hyper)

Can't see myself ever using anything but a backsaw to cut tenons but what makes St Roy entertaining

Dan Clermont