Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This $39 jig will make you a WOODWORKING GOD!

Woodie - Skewed Rabbett Fettling

Posts

Woodie - Skewed Rabbett Fettling

#1

Woodie - Skewed Rabbett Fettling

Dave (Arlington, VA)

>Hi All -

At while ago I acquired a 1 1/4" Greave & Sons wooden rebate plane, and I have a couple of questions about getting it back into shape.

First, the sole of the plane is not flat across its width. Would you recommend measure, mark and scrape, or planing it on a #6 or #7 sole up in a vise, or something else. I want to make sure that that the sole remains perpedicular to the sides - at least I think I do. Any specific advice on how to do this?

Second, lengthwise - the whole toe area of the plane is a bit lower than the whole heel area of the plane - even adjusting for the fact that the sole is somewhat out of flat from side to side. Is that normal? Shouldn't the entire sole be flat?

Third, the front of the mouth opening on the sole is not parallel to the back of the mouth opening. It's only a couple of degrees, but it is noticeable to the naked eye. I think this may "close up" some when I flatten the sole from side to side - but I can't tell how much.

Fourth, on a skewed woodie rabbet such as this, what might one expect the "workable" distance from the tip of the blade to the front of the mouth to be? Are we talking thous? or will it be workable with a bit of a gap? Right now the gap is about 1/4" - and it is likely to be more after I remove wood from the sole to flatten it.

Thanks and regards -

Dave

Re: Woodie - Skewed Rabbett Fettling

#2

Re: Woodie - Skewed Rabbett Fettling

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>Dave,

The entire sole should be flat and perpendicular to the sides. I checked a few of my woodie skew rabbets. The mouth openings are about 1/16” +/- so ¼” is way big. I’d be thinking about resoling or retiring it if it were mine. The mouth opening should be parallel to the edge of the iron. With such a large throat opening it’s the least of your concerns.

For flattening the sole just proceed as if jointing a board. Try to plane from toe to heel unless you are getting tearout. If you are having trouble getting the sole perpendicular to the sides consider using a shooting board. The iron and wedge should be in place, the wedge should be at working tightness (not sure if that’s the correct word) and the iron should of course be retracted.

Ed

Re: Woodie - Skewed Rabbett Fettling

#3

Re: Woodie - Skewed Rabbett Fettling

paul womack

>The entire sole should be flat and perpendicular to the sides.

Be VERY careful here. I have 2 planes of this type, and in both the body tapers slightly from sole to top.

This means that if the sole is perpendicular to one side, it cannot be perpendicular to the other, since the sides are not parallel.

I wrote on this topic back in 2002.

The (as ever) OLDTOOLS list

BugBear

Re: Woodie - Skewed Rabbett Fettling

#4

How does it work....

Todd Hughes

>now befor you do anything to it?... Does it performance now make you think it needs this work?...How much better do you want it to perform and how much is really needed for what you are planing to use it for?....uhmmm,...You have tried it out...Right?

....Will point out the reason the toe is lower then the heel is from extensive use by some old time wood worker who no doubt thought the plane served him well as it was.....Todd

Re: Woodie - Skewed Rabbett Fettling

#5

Re: Woodie - Skewed Rabbett Fettling

Dave (Arlington, VA)

>Hi Ed -

Thanks for the tips...especially about keeping the blade and wedge in place as I work it. I don't think I would have thought of that.

I also like the idea of a shooting board. I'll have to give that some thought.

On the gap between the iron and the front of the mouth. The reason for the question was to see if - as I go forward with this - I should be watchful in case it needs re-soling. While I've seen articles on re-soling woodies - they are usally coffin smoothers or other bench planes. I assume one would resole a rebate plane pretty much the same way, but I've never seen any one describe it.

First, I plan to get it working...then I'll see how much fine tuning it might need.

Thanks for posting.

Regards -

Dave

Re: Woodie - Skewed Rabbett Fettling

#6

Thanks, Bugbear!

Dave (Arlington, VA)

>Hi Bugbear -

Thanks for the pointer back to the discussion on the Porch. I've printed it out and will read it.

Somewhere - possibly from your post on the Porch (where I lurk) - I had picked up this issue of non-parallel sides. As a result, so far all I've done is check the flatness of sole with a square (from side to side) from both sides and mark the places where they "agree" with a chalk line. In fact, it was this concern that has made me wonder if measuring, marking and scraping might not be a better way to go with this...not too dissimilar from scraping the sole of a metal plane.

Thank you for taking the time to post. I appreciate it.

Regards -

Dave

Re: Woodie - Skewed Rabbett Fettling

#7

Re: Woodie - Skewed Rabbett Fettling

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>I went back and callipered a few. As one would expect with wood that’s 150 years old +/- I found some irregularities. Most were +/- 1/128" and one was out 1/64".

Good catch, Bugbear.

Ed

Re: Woodie - Skewed Rabbett Fettling

#8

Resoling

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>Dave,

I haven't done any resoling but I have a wooden skew rabbet that was resoled with (I think) rosewood. It looks like the new sole was glued on in one piece and then the mouth was opened up.

Ed

Re: Woodie - Skewed Rabbett Fettling

#9

How does it work???

Dave (Arlington, VA)

>Todd...Todd...Todd...How does it work? Have I tried it? Well, normally those would be excellent questions of me, but this time I did uncharacteristically actually try it, before deciding to fiddle with it.

It does not take full length shavings. In fact, it is enough out of flat on the sole so that you only get a pretty small ribbon of wood from the far left part of the plane blade - almost like a spill-plane (without the nice little spirals). As I try to project the blade gradually to take larger and larger shavings eventually (not too long) you get to a point where the left side of the blade digs in too much and the plane won't do much more than gouge the wood.

The out of flat condition (both side to side and lengthwise) made me wonder the same as you - if, at one point, this wasn't a nice little user that saw alot of action.

However, in it's current condition, I'm wonder if folks had tried it, couldn't make it work, and that's why I picked it up for $5.

So, the short answer to your question is, yes, I have tried it, and it is pretty much unusable in its current condition.

Thanks for posting.

Regards -

Dave

Re: Woodie - Skewed Rabbett Fettling

#10

Re: Resoling

Dave (Arlington, VA)

>Hi Ed -

That's great...and encouraging. I was sure they had had to be resoled, but I think this may be the first I read (or, at least, read and noticed) where there is an example of one that has been resoles.

Looks like it was glued on as a single piece, eh? Hmmm. Sounds like that might not be too hard. Ignorance is bliss. I'm curious. How much rosewood was added to the one you have?

Again, thanks for posting.

Regards -

Dave

Re: Woodie - Skewed Rabbett Fettling

#11

Look at this *LINK*

Dan Donaldson

>Here is an article by Bob Smalser on rehabbing woodies. (insert shameless plug for articles page here ;-)) It should have some useful info for you


Rehabbing Woodies

Re: Woodie - Skewed Rabbett Fettling

#12

Re: Look at this

Ed Mulligan, Cape Cod

>Yep, great stuff by Bob Smalser.

My rabbet planes are all 3 1/4" to 3 3/8" high, so a new sole should be thick enough to restore the original height +/-.


img

Re: Woodie - Skewed Rabbett Fettling

#13

Yes, they are quite helpful

Dave (Arlington, VA)

>Hi Dan -

Thanks for the link. I always follow Bob Smalser's posts with interest and recalled this one, as well. I definitely would consult it before giving this a shot. I particularly like (and need background) on the epoxying effort - if I decide to give it a shot. However, as my particular "problem child" is a rebate plane and not a bench plane, I expect I would need to use a few different procedures on things like opening the mouth up.

Thanks. I appreciated your post.

Regards -

Dave

Re: Woodie - Skewed Rabbett Fettling

#14

Great pic! Thanks

Dave (Arlington, VA)

>Hi Ed -

Thanks for the pic. I do think that is the first pic I've noticed of a wooden rebate plane with a "new" sole added. Glad to see an example.

Also I went back and remeasured my plane. I must have initially misread the gap between the front of the mouth and the blade, because now it appears to be about 1/8". Still, pretty big, and likely to get bigger if I remove material from the sole in an effort to get it flat.

I think - mindful of Todd's post - I will flatten the bottom of this plane, and see how it performs before deciding, one way or the other, to add a new sole. I did measure the height of the plane and it came in at about 3 1/4 inches - maybe a smidgeon more...so it's not off yours by much. I was hoping that I could use this to shape raised panels. We'll see.

Regards -

Dave