Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A natural, durable finish with minimal coats and fuss popular among woodworkers, flooring professionals, and furniture makers

Revisiting Tenon Length *LINK*

Posts

Revisiting Tenon Length *LINK*

#1

Revisiting Tenon Length *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Chris et al

Many thanks for the input regarding the tenon length. I thought that I would follow it up with details and a picture of my final decision.

To recap, the legs were 40x40mm and the apron was 19mm wide. Hence I planned to make the mortise-and-tenon ¼” wide (following the rule of 1/3 and this being the width of my nearest mortise chisel). That much was pretty standard.

I had planned a mortise depth of ¾” (19mm), which I thought adequate since the “hall table” was not going to carry much weight and the apron depth of 3” (75mm) should provide more than enough glue area. Your comment of “5 times width” set me thinking.

In the end I compromised on a 1” (25mm) long tenon, each mitred and set ¼” from the outside edge. Picture below.

In the second post I will say a bit more about the project.

Regards from Perth

Derek


img

Earlier thread on tenons

Re: Revisiting Tenon Length *LINK*

#2

More on the project (in case you're curious)

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>This “hall table” (I’m not sure if that is the correct name for something that is to placed behind a couch in the living room) was just a simple project as part of my planned review of the LV Bevel Up Jointer (BUJ), which is in final preparation. For all my reviews, whether this is clear or not, I usually build something so that I also gain as much of a real world experience as possible. For this review I have decided to use the BUJ as the only bench plane (other than the comparison with my Type 11 Stanley #7). I thought that this would be a great way to evaluate its flexibility. So, two blades (HA and LA) along with a spokeshave, shoulder plane, tenon saw and a few chisels. The BUJ doubled as a smoother as well. I did use a tablesaw and a bandsaw in the initial preparation (of the timber, per se), as only a masochist would not since the timber used was Jarrah and Black Butt, both hard-as-nails aged Aussie woods I get as salvage.

I don’t usually show the final products, but here is the table I knocked up. Oil and wax finish. (You’ll have to wait for the review to see how it was made :) ).

Regards from Perth

Derek


img

Re: Revisiting Tenon Length *LINK*

#3

Re: More on the project (in case you're curious)

Paul Kierstead

>That is one very very fine looking hall table (or is it a sofa table?). In particular, the design (and execution!) is light and balanced and the top is interesting without being squirrelly. Excellent work.

Re: Revisiting Tenon Length *LINK*

#4

Re: Revisiting Tenon Length

mikew

>Hey Derek!

I see now what you were talking about...For a double rail such as you have made, I traditionally do a sliding dovetail for the top rail.

However, I suspect the 1" tenon will last plenty long. It looks like it fits well, which is a prime reason for M&T failure.

Mike

Re: Revisiting Tenon Length *LINK*

#5

Re: More on the project (in case you're curious)

mikew

>Quite nice, Derek!

Can't wait for the review/tutorial.

Mike

Re: Revisiting Tenon Length *LINK*

#6

Re: More on the project (in case you're curious)

Sgian Dubh

>Derek, I notice that you chose to use bridle joints in preference to mortise and tenons in the corners where the rails meet the leg. Is there a particular reason for that choice? Slainte.

I can think that the choice is justified because there should be plenty of strength in the mortise and tenons used in the stretchers just below to hold the leg framing square and rigid enough for a light use table. Slainte.

Re: Revisiting Tenon Length *LINK*

#7

Actualy it's a ...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Sofa table, and a very nice looking one to Derek. Looking forward to the write up...