Re: Functionality vs. Traditions vs.
William Duffield, on the Cohansey
>Aren't these kinds of questions great? There's just no Right Answer, because the guy asking the question usually has no idea how complex his question really is, or how many different choices he has. He usually gives us insufficient clues about what he is trying to accomplish with the tool in question or where he is going with his woodworking, so we get to guess, or make up our own scenario.
Just when we think we understand all the pros and cons, Rob goes and throws a wooden shoe into the gears.
The choices are legion, in routers, as they are in planes, or chisels, or marking and measuring, or anywhere else our imaginations take us. There are traditional tools from the traditional mass producers of iron and steel and brass, There are even older tools, from before the industrial revolution, there are the tools we can build ourselves, there are new tools still being produced by the old companies, and there are new tools produced by new companies with a vision of the future, and even new tools produced by companies without that vision of a new, sophisticated market but with a view of a different, perhaps "third world" market. And also, there are Porter-Cable, Bosch, Triton, Whiteside, CMT. etc. (Let's not go there).
And, there are the applications the budding Neanderthal knows he needs the tool to accomplish, and those others he won't discover until he has used the tool and has begun to understand it. For routers, there are hinge mortises, tenon cheeks, flattening the field of a piecrust table, letting in veneers and string inlays and purfling and quirks and so many other things to route out.
When one chooses a router, is it just to efficiently work wood, or is there also a connction to traditional ways of woodworking, maybe even those of your direct ancestors, or is the building and using and understanding of the tools you have built yourself what drives you to choose a particular tool? Should you choose the tool that works the best or that is the most versatile? Is durability or time spent on maintenance important to you? Is the best tool a lot more than you need? How much time can you afford to spend searching for an old tool that does what you need? Does it have to look like the tool your grandfather, or your great great grandfather used? Is one router enough for you, or do you need lots of them?
Even if we decide individually that one of Rob's is more router than we need or are willing to pay for, at least we can be assured that it will have an advantageous effect on price of the old Stanleys we may want to buy. Routers are simple enough that no woodwork should be afraid to build one of his own.
We can help you, Frank!