Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

VPS-Level Performance. Fully Managed. No Hassle.

Rust removal -- redux

Posts

Rust removal -- redux

#1

Rust removal -- redux

Mark Harrison -- in Sydney, Australia

>I bought a couple of Disston tenon saws a while back on the Bay. I finally got around to cleaning them up this weekend.

I bought some citric acid in powder form from the supermarket. I used 75 grams of the powder and 750 millilitres of water to dissolve it in. I also added a squirt of diswashing liquid to lower the surface tension, though I'm not sure this is necessary.

I was amazed with the result. There was an even coating of black where the surface rust was and I used a standard kitchen scotchbrite scourer to clean that off. In just a few hours the saw was clean. To dry the saw I put it into a warm oven (less than 50 degrees celsius) to prevent any further immediate rust.

Seems to be a fairly foolproof and simple method. Certainly a lot less hassle than the electrolysis methods often used.

Just thought I would pass on the experience.

Re: Rust removal -- redux

#2

Jack Guzman from Maine

Thanks

Jack Guzman from Maine

>I am always looking for a better way to clean saw blades.Because of their shape they are difficult to derust with electrolosis.Do you make a bath of the solution?If so how long did you soak it. Or do you just use the solution to scrub with?---Jack

Re: Rust removal -- redux

#3

citric acid vs electrolysis discussed

bill tindall

>First, let me state that I don't know which is "better". My purpose is to explain the differences to help decide what could be better in this or that circumstance.

Exposure of iron oxide (rust) to citric acid will result in the rust dissolving to form soluble iron. Unoxidized iron will be left behind, though continued exposure to the solution will result in additional corrosion, but at a much slower rate than the initial rust dissolution. Most acids will accomplish this same resut becasue any acid will dissolve rust, more or less rapidly. But the advantage of citric, or oxalic acid, is that they work quickly and nothing is left behind that will promote further corrosion. Hydrochloric (muriatic) acid works quickly but leaves behind corrosion promoting chloride which is hard to wash away completely. Certainly citric acid is the least hazzardous acid to use and dispose of, but it is also the most expensive.

Weak phosphoric acid and phosphates convert rust to iron phosphate, a black material, that is resistant to further rusting. It is also a good substrate for protective coverage by painting.

Electrolysis at least partially reverses the rusting process. While loose rust is blasted away by the bubble evolution, the surface rust is converted to an adherent black oxide that is mechanically sound and it resists further rusting.

Electrolysis was the preferred means of stabilizing iron artifacts, and it still is the best way to stabilize iron recovered from salt water because the process removes the salt which will promote further corrosion. I was recently told by a museum conservator that removing rust by gentle mechanical processes is now the preferred procedure for museum pieces. Mechanical removal is in keeping with the current fashion of not doing anything in conservation that will permanently alter a surface. Mechanically cleaned pieces still look redish.

I slather phosphates on tin roofs prior to painting. I found electrolysis good for highly rusted antique plane irons that I had no intention of ever using. Details of the stamped labels were preserved and I like the looks of the result. For light surface rust I would use mechanical removal unless the surface was intricate. For something I was going to use where it would experience wear, for example the saw mentioned above, the citric acid treatment looks attractive, though for flat surfaces mechanical cleaning is a practical option. For a rusted valuable antique I would consult an expert.

Re: Rust removal -- redux

#4

Electrolysis and Acid

Garrett in Victoria

>There's an excellent article on electrolysis in the A&R Department, as well as one on Japanning although that isn't of direct interest here.

As for acids, I've been using a weak solution of phosphoric acid for years. It's the base for most commercial products, removes the rust, and leaves a protective film on the tool's surface. Not good if you want a mirror finish, but it eventually wears off through use.

Cheers, Garrett

Re: Rust removal -- redux

#5

Question

Dan Donaldson

>Would vinegar work as the acid? Most homes probably have it around already.

Re: Rust removal -- redux

#6

Re: Answer

Frank D. in Montreal

>Yes! Vinegar works very well. I add salt to the vinegar, I forget exactly why other than I was told to do it... I let the tool soak and every hour or so return and scrub a little with some steel wool or a scotchbrite. The steel becomes nice and shiny, not dull grey.

Re: Rust removal -- redux

#7

Re: Thanks

Mark Harrison -- in Sydney, Australia

>I just soaked it for a couple of hours. As Bill said, the rust turns black and you just scrub that off. I did it twice to get it to the point I was happy.

I suppose it is possible to just use the scotchbrite pad to get a similar effect, but it would be a lot more effort to get it off. The dreaded wire wheel would also work but it is awfully messy.

Re: Rust removal -- redux

#8

Jack Guzman from Maine

Re: Thanks

Jack Guzman from Maine

>My current method I learned from a post by Todd Hughes.I use a razor blade to scrape the heavy stuff then WD-40 and 220 grit SC sandpaper.It works good,just alot of elbow grease.I like to save my effort for tasks like mortising and scrub planing so I have quite a few uncleaned saws waiting for a round tuit.---Jack

Re: Rust removal -- redux

#9

Re: Thanks

paul womack

>Because of their shape they are difficult to derust with electrolosis.

An outdoor, plastic "planting trough" (or window box) is ideal.

BugBear

Re: Rust removal -- redux

#11

Interesting

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>My mother always had Revereware copper-bottomed pots (so do we - very low-fashion these days), and used to clean them with a lemon cut in half (citric acid) and salt. One of the chemists in the community will weigh in soon, I'm sure, to explain the salt part.

Re: Rust removal -- redux

#12

salt explained

bill tindall

>the chloride part of the salt reacts with iron or copper corrosion to form a water soluble compound. In the case of iron this compound is bright yellow; bright green in the case of copper. This reaction aids dissolving the corrosion. However, chloride sticks in the nooks and crannies of metals and if not removed by thorough washing it will promote further corrosion, think 1960's cars in the frozen north. They lasted 3 years before steel mfgs. learned to galvanize/aluminize autobody metal.

Re: Rust removal -- redux

#13

PS

bill tindall

>oxalic acid and citric acid form a colorless, soluble iron compound in solution, which hastens rust dissolving just like chloride. For these reasons these materials are used to remove rust stains-they attack rust to yield a colorless product.