citric acid vs electrolysis discussed
bill tindall
>First, let me state that I don't know which is "better". My purpose is to explain the differences to help decide what could be better in this or that circumstance.
Exposure of iron oxide (rust) to citric acid will result in the rust dissolving to form soluble iron. Unoxidized iron will be left behind, though continued exposure to the solution will result in additional corrosion, but at a much slower rate than the initial rust dissolution. Most acids will accomplish this same resut becasue any acid will dissolve rust, more or less rapidly. But the advantage of citric, or oxalic acid, is that they work quickly and nothing is left behind that will promote further corrosion. Hydrochloric (muriatic) acid works quickly but leaves behind corrosion promoting chloride which is hard to wash away completely. Certainly citric acid is the least hazzardous acid to use and dispose of, but it is also the most expensive.
Weak phosphoric acid and phosphates convert rust to iron phosphate, a black material, that is resistant to further rusting. It is also a good substrate for protective coverage by painting.
Electrolysis at least partially reverses the rusting process. While loose rust is blasted away by the bubble evolution, the surface rust is converted to an adherent black oxide that is mechanically sound and it resists further rusting.
Electrolysis was the preferred means of stabilizing iron artifacts, and it still is the best way to stabilize iron recovered from salt water because the process removes the salt which will promote further corrosion. I was recently told by a museum conservator that removing rust by gentle mechanical processes is now the preferred procedure for museum pieces. Mechanical removal is in keeping with the current fashion of not doing anything in conservation that will permanently alter a surface. Mechanically cleaned pieces still look redish.
I slather phosphates on tin roofs prior to painting. I found electrolysis good for highly rusted antique plane irons that I had no intention of ever using. Details of the stamped labels were preserved and I like the looks of the result. For light surface rust I would use mechanical removal unless the surface was intricate. For something I was going to use where it would experience wear, for example the saw mentioned above, the citric acid treatment looks attractive, though for flat surfaces mechanical cleaning is a practical option. For a rusted valuable antique I would consult an expert.