Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

REAL MILK PAINT

Spinning wheels

Posts

Spinning wheels

#1

Spinning wheels

ThomD

>I thought I would ask here, since it is a hand tool, and I spend most of my time here:

I'm interested in sites, or other resources, for making spinning wheels. I'm interested in stuff that is spinning driven, rather than just stuff a woodworker would want to build. My wife wants a wheel, but isn't an expert on the subject, so what I need is plans or info for real useable wheels. I have one book on making wheels, and a few spinning books. A lot of the traditional wheels don't really spin modern yarns. I could design my own between the plans in one book, the specifications of modern wheels, but if someone has already done the work...

Re: Spinning wheels

#2

Re: Spinning wheels *LINK*

Skip in Falls Church

>My wife is a spinner - both drop spindle and spinning wheel, and I contemplated making a spinning wheel at one time. However, I gave it up as a bad proposition and bought a relatively inexpensive one off eBay.

The guy at the site below might be able to help you though. At least he's was helpful to me in the past. They are always at the Maryland Sheep and Wool Festival - one year I was looking at his Lazy Kates and mentioned to him that they would be really easy to make. I was afraid he'd be offended - or at least a bit snippy but he gave me advice and even sold me parts really cheap. I've repaid him by not making one! :) But I still have the parts and someday..... In any case his spinning wheels (and woodworking) are absolutely beautiful if horribly expensive.

Skip


http://www.dropspindle.info/wheels.html

Re: Spinning wheels

#3

Re: Spinning wheels

ThomD

>I've been looking and finding some stuff. Here is the opposite end of your great link, though probably practical: http://www.babesfibergarden.com/BFG92001/bigriver2.jpg

Re: Spinning wheels

#4

Please post your results...

john jesseph

>My daughters are becoming interested in weaving, and we may get them started spinning also. I would like to see how much of a task building a wheel would be. I might even put a loom on the to-do list...

Re: Spinning wheels

#5

Re: Spinning wheels

Michael Recchione

>Well, this has been a sort of planned project for a while for me. I'm curious about your statement that traditional wheels don't spin modern yarns. Could you explain?

I've made a bunch of spinning/fiber related stuff for my wife and other members of her spinning guild, but have yet to make a real wheel. (Unless you count my copy of a Smithsonian picuture of a Sailish bulky yarn spinner made from an old treadle sewing machine treadle). I've gotten so that my hand spindles are very well balanced and nice - those are the things that the guild members like the best, and I actually have a waiting list for them. Another thing they seem to like is a portable, collapsible lazy kate that works with hand spindles of any size.

But spinning wheels are another story. I made a charka (a small, portable folding high-speed wheel invented by Mahatma Gandhi and intended for spinning cotton), and it came out very nice looking - maybe the best hand-cut dovetails I've ever done. But that's not enough for spinning equipment - it's got to work effortlessly and flawlessly, or the spinner winds up hating it. After struggling with it for a couple of weeks, my wife went out and bought an Osborne (the Cadillac of charkas). I can always count on her to be honest in her feedback, and I don't get cut any slack for being family :-) I should never have given her the 0.1 version.

I had always thought about getting into making this stuff on a slightly larger scale and selling it at Maryland Sheep & Wool and/or Rhinebeck as a kind of retirement business to supplement other things. Until I went up there last fall and saw the proliferation of hand spindles, niddy-noddies, warping boards, etc - all the stuff that's fairly easy to make. It seems that at least one out of two women who are into spinning is married to a guy with a wood shop, and at least one out of every two of those guys has the same idea I did.

Not wheels, though. I had a conversation with Gord Lendrum, of Lendrum wheels, and told him about my disappointing experience at Rhinebeck. He reminded me that "any business that's easy to get into is going to be overcrowded...lucky for me there's more to making wheels." He's right. The first few you make are probably not going to rival the effortless working of a good wheel like a Lendrum or Reed.

My suggestion (based on theoretical considerations, not practical experience) is to make a couple of prototypes where you don't focus at all on appearance, but try to get the ergonomics, the balance and the mechanical bits (deceptively simple) right. Use your wife as a beta tester, but don't give her one of the prototypes :-)

My wife just bought her second Lendrum - she has a folding castle wheel and the traditional Saxony, and she loves both of them. I still have a dream of making her a wheel one day, but frankly, I don't know where we'd put it now...

Re: Spinning wheels

#6

Re: Spinning wheels *PICS*

L. Hanson

>I've not built any myself nor have any plans for one, so I can't be of much help there... but I have seen a couple made, and heard of the difficulties in making one that works well - and thought I could post a couple pictures of them, for comparison's sake. My great great great grandfather was known for making them, and I know that he made at least 79 of them. While I don't have a photo of one of his originals, here's a couple photos of direct copies of them that both my dad and his brother made.

First, this one is maple, made by dad:


Another view:


This is my uncle's version of the same spinning wheel, made out of walnut:


Another view:


Here's an original spinning wheel, made by my g-g-g-granddad's brother, one of slightly simpler design:


I can only present the photos here for your comparison, and I'm sorry that I don't have any direct experience building them to share with you. I can tell you that it's a proven design that was highly sought after in its day, but don't know what that would mean with "modern" yarns. Both my uncle and dad spoke of the difficulties in making them so they worked properly - and the wheels themselves, while complex, were not the only difficult part to make - much of the mechanism up top has to line up well and spin freely, and was the subject of much discussion. What's really cool about the originals g-g-g-granddad made is he turned them on a treadle lathe, even though had lost one leg after an accident hewing some ash...

Leif

www.norsewoodsmith.com

Re: Spinning wheels

#7

Re: Spinning wheels

DP

>There were plans several years ago in FWW for making a spinning wheel. Don't have the issue number handy but I'm sure you can find it through the index on their website.

Re: Spinning wheels

#8

Re: Spinning wheels

Garrett in Victoria

>You might want to post this on the Turning Board since spinning wheels are, in fact, made by turners. Almost everything in them is a turned part.

A friend in our turning guild makes them professionally. He's booked up about 2 years ahead, so if you enjoy it...

Unfortunately, I know nothing about the use and type of wheels.

Cheers, Garrett

Re: Spinning wheels

#9

Traditional wheels and modern yarns

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Traditional wheels were made in two main types. A flax wheel (saxony wheel) was a small sit-down wheel with a treadle made to spin flax into a strong thin yarn. Wool wheels (walking wheels) were large (about 4 foot diameter) wheels worked standing up. They had a naked spindle about like an ice pick and were used for wool and generally made a thicker yarn. I think a wool wheel makes yarn faster with a skilled spinner.

Spinners today prefer a small wheel with a larger orifice and larger flyer and bobbin set up than on the old flax wheel so they can spin wool and other thicker yarns.

Re: Spinning wheels

#10

Re: Spinning wheels

Skip in Falls Church

>Hi Thom,

Thanks for the site address, my wife was looking at it when I left for work. For what it's worth, she didn't know of any issues involving spinning modern fibers on older wheels - and she'd like to know about them. She's got several types of modern synthetics that she's lookin at spinning in the future. She's got about 30 pounds of wool to spin along with a couple of pounds of alpaca fiber on her list for now.

Also, if your wife needs any help when she starts on her wheel my wife would be glad to supply some.

Skip

Re: Spinning wheels

#11

It's not so cut and dried...

Michael Recchione

>Actually, the great wheel type wheels (like the Indian charka and the walking wheel) antedate the more modern flyer-type wheels by probably something like a thousand years. They were essentially just handspindles set up with a better way to keep them spinning - they don't use bobbins or flyer assemblies at all, and are often not treadled. The great wheel or walking wheel is turned by hand. In fact, except for the challenge of producing the rim and spokes (the rim is typically bent and joined), this is a relatively easy wheel to make - you don't have to worry about getting the flyer assembly to draw correctly or the treadling to be even and smooth, the drive adjustments to work right...

But, while wheels of this type (the spindle as opposed to the flyer type) were certainly used for wool, they were also used for everything else until the late 1400s, when the first "modern-like" flyer and bobbin type wheels appeared in Europe. While it's true that the earliest records of these wheels show them being used for flax spinning, there are pictures from the early 1500s that show them being used for wool as well. That certainly qualifies as "traditional" in my book.

The familiar saxony-type wheel is one variation of the bobbin&flyer type of wheel, but there are many others, and lots of them were used for spinning wool. There were also many different variations of drive type, bobbin size and orifice size, some of them optimized for a particular type of spinning and for different fibers. Typically, a flax wheel will have a distaff assembly to hold the fiber prior to spinning it. If the wheel doesn't have that, it was probably used primarily for wool.

Re: Spinning wheels

#12

Re: It's not so cut and dried...

Warren in Lancaster, PA

>Michael

I apologize for simplifying. I just wanted to give some idea why a modern spinner might not want a typical saxony set up. In addition to a small orifice, small flyer with small, closely spaced hooks, and a small bobbin, the saxony also usually has pully ratios that give high twist. Everything is made for fine yarn. I have occasionally made new bobbins and whorls (pulleys) for spinners who want to make coarser yarns.

Your post gives the impresssion that the great wheel was something discontinued after the middle ages. There were new patents and much production in the early nineteenth century. And it is certainly not the case that saxony wheels without distaffs were made for wool. Many eighteenth century spinners used free-standing distaffs. In fact, I think that more often than not eighteenth century illustrations show free-standing distaffs.

Re: Spinning wheels

#13

Re: Spinning wheels

Greg Benulis

>The article that I am aware of that FWW published was called "Spinning Wheels" by Bud Kronenburg in FWW #11, Summer 1978. It has also been republished in the book "Fine Woodworking on Spindle Turning". The article gives the details for a Saxony wheel. It has a well dimensioned drawing of the authors Shaker styled wheel. He also recommends a book "American Spinning Wheels" by David Pennington and Michael Taylor published by Shaker Press, Sabbathday Lane, Poland Springs, ME.

HTH

Greg

Re: Spinning wheels

#14

Re: Spinning wheels

ThomD

>Thank your wife for the kind offer!

I think the main issues concern orifice size for larger modern yarns, and speeds. These would be easily dealt with on a home made machine since one could just adjust the parts as required.

Machine size is an issue. Some of the more versatile home made machines are large for speed and for large bobbins and orifices. Others are compact for ease of storage.

Here are some making links so far. These include a few online sources for DIY, but mostly easier to copy existing machines. (I think the best sources are the books I already have):

http://www.jb.man.ac.uk/~caj/diy.html

http://www.ashford.co.nz/home/home-frameset.htm

http://www.ncidata.com/~columbine/

http://www.sunworx.com/hikuri/hikuri.htm

These are the two coolest loons I have ever read about. You have to see: http://www.sunworx.com/hikuri/hikuri.htm

http://www.louet.com/wheels1.htm

Re: Spinning wheels

#15

Re: Spinning wheels *PICS*

ThomD

>Those are lovely, thanks for posting pictures.

I'm by no means cocky about making a wheel. However... One of my main areas of interest is making tools, or objects that are mechanical. Started with canoe paddles, canoes, yachts, planes (both kinds), bows, benches, anything that cuts. On and on. So by now I know where to look for the structural and design issues that affect not just the look of something, but functional issues.

When I first thought of doing this maybe 10 years ago, I was a little scared of the assembly issues, but after years of green woodworking chairs and such, I go back and look at these things, and they look easy. Time to get the parts and patterns I made for a Shaker wheel out and finish it.

Another thing I didn't have in the past was the resources to do the metal parts, but I have a TIG/stick welder, a forge, and a metal lathe these days.

I'm embarassed because of all the things I have made, the only one the wife ever asked for was the spinning wheel...

Re: Spinning wheels

#16

Re: Spinning wheels

ThomD

>I have Bud's book "Spinning Wheel, building and restoring". It is the best I have seen. Back in the day when woodworking books were more than put tab "A" in tab "B". "The Spinner's Workshop" by Mercer is another interesting book from that period.

There was another interesting article in FWW, not sure when, on making a wheel out of all laminated materials. I have almost all of FWW, and they haven't done much on spinning. The UK magazines are more consistently on that beat. However, I haven't collected many, the turnning seem too fussy for my taste. One thing they do have are woodturners, spinners, and weavers exhibit, which seems like a good idea.

Re: Spinning wheels

#17

Re: Please post your results...

ThomD

>Assuming one has some idea of what the key pieces are, a wheel that "motorizes" the unit and then the other parts that twist the yarn, and what are the critical details for those, then there are some brutally simple ways of getting those parts into a format. Bicycle wheels, wheelchair wheels, plywood discs. I have seen several very attractive versions of the louet wheel, that looked easy to make. Part of the reason I chose the previous links is that some of the formats like the babe, Louet, Columbine, or the Ashford portables break up the traditional form into pieces one can easily disect. The descriptions include dimensions, ratios. A lot of other info can be gouged out from examining the pictures carefully.

My interest is to make a classic wheel, but not as a reproducting, so I am willing to take info where I can find it.

Re: Spinning wheels

#18

Re: Please post your results...

ThomD

>This guy has loom plans, and wheels. I have no idea how good they are. http://www.craftdesigns.co.uk/

Re: Spinning wheels

#19

Re: It's not so cut and dried... *LINK*

Michael Recchione

>I didn't mean to give the impression that the great wheel type wheel was discontinued after the middle ages - they were certainly in common use throughout the American Colonial period and probably until the industrial age (when much handspinning died out), which is why you still see so many of them in historic houses and Americana museums. In fact, some modern manufacturers offer either great wheels themselves or smaller quill spindle wheels even today - I was suggesting that might be an easier way to go for a first attempt.

The separate distaff information is new to me - I thought most flax wheels usually had at least a hole to stick the distaff into, but you learn something new every day :-)

However, the real point I wanted to make was that flyer and bobbin wheels have been used for wool for about 500 years, and that, at least since the beginning of the "spinning revival" of the last 30 years or so, have been virtually the only wheels used for wool. You're absolutely right that copying an old flax wheel wouldn't be that useful today unless the size of the applicable parts were adjusted to allow bulkier yarns to be spun. But copying virtually any saxony wheel produced since 1970 or so would be a pretty safe way to go. A bigger flyer, bigger bobbins, a larger orifice and a good choice of drive ratios and you're good to go - most commercial wheels have all those things now, although some are optimized for something and less good for something else.

I guess one good thing to do is to decide what sort of stuff she wants to spin, mostly. Then it's easier to decide what the rest of it needs to be. And a single wheel might not be the answer for everything, any more than any of us try to get by with just one plane. (or just one workbench).

But I still believe it might be a good idea to ease into making a full-blown bobbin&flyer wheel that's not only a joy to look at but also a joy to use - I think getting it right the first time would take enormous luck. Starting out with just getting a wheel to spin with perfect balance would be a good sized bite to chew on for a first attempt. That's why a quill spindle wheel like a great wheel or a non-folding charka might be a good first project in this direction. Just my two cents.


some modern quill spindle wheels

Re: Spinning wheels

#20

Thanks!!

john jesseph

>