uses for the #1 bench plane?
James Watriss
>I've been looking at this silly miniature for some time now... is there actually a use for a lie-nielsen #1 plane? Or is it just a collectible sort of a thing?
Just thought I'd ask...
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
uses for the #1 bench plane?
James Watriss
>I've been looking at this silly miniature for some time now... is there actually a use for a lie-nielsen #1 plane? Or is it just a collectible sort of a thing?
Just thought I'd ask...
Re: uses for the #1 bench plane?
Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI
>I often times break edges with a block plane. The #1 plane would be much easier to hold I think for this use, because the handle would make it a little easier to hold. If I had one I would use it quite a bit I think, but I have a lot of other tools on my wish list, none of which is a necessity.
Re: uses for the #1 bench plane?
Larry Williams
>Back in our architectural woodworking days we once carved about a hundred linen fold panels for one job. I found Lie-Nielsen's #1 indispensable for that job. The cutting geometry of a block plane would have been a handicap in the mahogany we were using.
Set for a real fine cut, the #1 could drop a corner down into the folds and let us clean up the inevitable tear out on the curves without creating facets that would cause problems. I thought it was so important for that job that Bill now makes a 1 1/4" coffin bodied smoother for just that and it's proven itself for other uses as well.
Re: uses for the #1 bench plane?
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>I have never handled, nevermind seen, a LN #1 so cannot comment on this plane, per se. However I do find a small, narrow high angle handplane invaluable. This might be for smoothing small areas that would be unmanageable with a larger smoother, repairing tearout, or getting into the troughs on long edges.
The two I turn to are the 1-3/16" wide bevel down Mujingfang mini smoother (identical to the HNT Gordon palm smoother), and my 1-5/8" wide bevel up Stanley #18, both with 60 degree cutting angles.
Regards from Perth
Derek
a #1 might be a bit small for some
Ian in Sydney
>I got to look at and handle a #1 and a #2 at the Sydney Woodshow.
Both LNs are very nice looking tools. Whilst I could hold the #2, I found the #1 too small to get a satisfactory grip on. I suspect that with longer practice I would work out which fingers should grip the tote and which should lie along the blade.
I can see a use for a small smoother, but whether a bevel up block plane with a steep microbevel works as well (or better) I'll leave to Derek to discuss.
What about...
Bob Hackett
>using a block plane with a large front knob and either a squirrel tail or a ball rear knob like the LV?Seems like it would be far easier to grip never mind being more cost effective.
MB
Then again,it may be someone is looking for justification for paying the high price for a new or used #1.
A Nice Gift.
Bob Smalser, Seabeck, WA
>Any uses suitable for its tiny size are done just as well with other planes.
Re: What about using a block plane...
Denny
>That's the approach I took, LV LA Block with front and rear handles. With a high angle blade it's quite effective.
Re: a #1 might be a bit small for some
Dan Donaldson
>I have one and I hold it more like a block plane, with the tote in the web between the thumb and first finger and thumb and fingers on the sides. It is handy, but not necessarily a good first or early purchase. I only have one because we were at the local Woodcraft store and my Wife saw it. She likes small things and thought that it was cute, so she told me to buy it. When it comes to buy and tool in the same sentence, I NEVER argue with her ;-) That said, It is useful for small jobs, and the wraparound grip fits my hand size pretty well.
Paper weight
Jim Stafford
>I'm sure there is probably a purpose for it, but if I had an office job (I don't), this would make the most outstanding paper weight and conversation piece I could think of.
Re: uses for the #1 bench plane?
R.J.Whelan
>James ... I use mine all of the time - I use it one-handed, much as I would a block plane ... rj
Re: Paper weight
Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native in FL. Exile :~(
>Jim,
That's my way of thinking as well, but than again, I've never had an opportunity to put a #1 to wood so I can't discuss how well/bad it performs. fiqured that it could also serve as an Executive pencil sharpener.
My plan is when I find one in a rust busket/box at the flea market to play it off as a woodworkers paperweight that is simply for holding down plans.
Todd O.
Prefer a #100
Dave Thompson - Champaign IL
>I have an LN #1 and other similar sized planes. My preferred plane of this size is a squirel tail Stanely #100. It fits very nicely in the hand.
With the #1, I always have to be careful about knocking the lateral adjustment out of wack, since it's difficult to grip with out touching the blade.
Re: uses for the #1 bench plane?
Todd Stock
>A Superior Works #601 will round out a collection of Bedrocks without all that LN bronze bling-bling...
But seriously, I can't think of a use that calls for the #1 over other planes of similar size.