Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Build it. Rock it. Rockler has your woodworking tools.

Size of abrasive the only factor in edge keenness?

Posts

Size of abrasive the only factor in edge keenness?

#1

Size of abrasive the only factor in edge keenness?

Denis Chénard, Orléans, Ont.

>Take two different honing compounds with the same particle size. Assume both compounds are hard enough to hone an arbitrary piece of steel. Is it possible that one compound can put a keener edge than the other one?

Or, put another way, is grit size the only determining factor for edge keenness?

Concrete example: 0.5 micron green compound vs. 1 micron diamond paste. Which one gives a sharper edge?

Just curious,

DC

Re: Size of abrasive the only factor in edge keenness?

#2

Re: Size of abrasive the only factor in edge keenn

Paul Kierstead

>I think one of the fallacies you have right away is that particle size is constant. The particles will break down at varying rates for different types which will certainly effect the output; this is the whole principle of waterstones, no?

Re: Size of abrasive the only factor in edge keenness?

#3

I can answer the first question

bill tindall

>The scratch pattern left by the abrasive will be affected by the properties of the abrasive particle as well as its size. If the abrasive wears to produce rounded edges it is going to cut different than a particle that wears in a way that the cutting edges stay sharp. Some abrasives like silicon carbide crush easily to produce smaller particles. "Ceramic" abrasives (seeded sol gels) (probably what is used in Sharpton stones) fracture at their surface to yield sharp edges while maintaining origial particle size. Harder abrasives will penetrate better, etc. In the case of diamond the effective particle size depends on the hardness of the substrate to which it is "attached/embedded".

In addition I would presume that an efficient cutting (sharp) particle will produce a different scratch than one plowing across the metal. This is certainly the case for abrasive wheels. The burnishing of a dull particle could well affect edge properties for better or worse.

Elliot has shown that diamond produces the sharpest edges.

Re: Size of abrasive the only factor in edge keenness?

#4

I think not

bill tindall

>I have not read an authoritative discussion of how waterstones work, but this is what I think happens. I think they are composed of aluminium oxide particles bonded with a weak bonding agent, probably clay. In use, the clay fractures easily which releases worn abrasive particles and exposes fresh sharp particles. Regular aluminium oxide is tough so these particles don't fracture to smaller ones like silicon carbide. They dull by edge rounding. Do to preserve cutting efficience one must get rid of the worn particles and expose new ones. (see my discussion of grinding wheels in Article Section)

I speculate the Sharpton stones are composed of abrasive particles like what is in the Norton "G" wheels and what Joel sells. These are aluminium oxide particles grown from a seeded sol gel(colloide).They have the desirable property of preserving bulk particle size while continuing to micro fracture at the surface to produce and maintain sharp edges for cutting. Unfortunately they are very expensive to make. Such a particle can be bonded with a more durable bonding agent to provide less stone wear.

Re: Size of abrasive the only factor in edge keenness?

#5

Re: I think not

Paul Kierstead

>Bill:

"Do to preserve cutting efficience one must get rid of the worn particles and expose new ones. (see my discussion of grinding wheels in Article Section)"

Yes, however, if one does not get rid of the worn particles but instead leaves the slurry, they get a finer finished (and presumably sharper) edge. Mind you, I am 100% willing to be wrong on this.