green waterstone
Adam Cherubini
>Has anybody tried those green waterstones? How do they compare with coarse oil stones?
I'm looking for some coarse honing stuff and want to try something other than SS.
Adam
Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998
green waterstone
Adam Cherubini
>Has anybody tried those green waterstones? How do they compare with coarse oil stones?
I'm looking for some coarse honing stuff and want to try something other than SS.
Adam
Re: green waterstone
William Duffield, on the Cohansey
>Are you sure that's not just algae growth, from keeping them immersed in the pond? You might try putting a Plecostomus in with them.
Ducking and running...
Re: green waterstone
Paul in NJ
>Adam,
I have a green/gray 220/100 grit waterstone that I bought from GW years ago. It cuts about as fast as a coarse carborundum stone. If you are going to use it for chisels or plane blades, I say forget it, get a grinder. It wears so fast that I only found it useful for axe or drawknife blades.
Paul Dzioba
Re: green waterstone
Rob Lee
>Adam -
I'm not sure the green stones are period appropriate for your work...
All the pictures I've seen of 1800's shops, the stones are various shades of grey... Occasionally, they have a brown tint....
:)
Cheers -
Rob
(runnin' after William....)
Re: green waterstone
Dean J in MN
>Adam --
I use a green 220 grit waterstone... But I can't say I can compare directly to a coarse oil stone. I have a Norton carborundum, but don't use it.
For honing the waterstone cuts fast, but wears faster than any of my other waterstones. That can be good or bad... Cambering a fore plane blade is easy on that soft stone... Flattening blade backs requires a lot of attention to the stone along the way.
-Dean
Now that's funny right there
Ron in Kokomo
>
I use one...
Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA
>Although I can't give a compairson to oil stones. It cuts very fast and agressive. Mine is a 100 or 120 grit I believe. I don't store it water, just wet it before using it. It flattens quickly using a drywall sanding screen. Works well for things you don't want to put to a grining wheel.
Re: green waterstone
Dick Darin
>Try the Shapton 120 grit It's very fast, but the real advantage is that it stays usable (flat) much longer than the green stone.
Re: green waterstone
Jim in Burlington On
>Coarse honing stuff if by that you mean chisel and plane blade flattening and sharpening the 800 grit king stone is alot better. The green stone dishes quickly and leaves a scratch pattern that is very hard to get out. Oil stone just cuts to slowly for me.
Re: And the answer is..
ThomD
>I have the large king one, and I don't find they sharpen particularly fast. They are coarse, but not agressive. They are pretty good for flatening 800 brown stones on, and those stones seem to be faster. Green stone don't seem to hollow, but that may explain why they aren't very agressive.
I have had pretty poor overall results with diamond stones. Having said that, some of them are very agressive. The Polycrystalline ones where the diamonds are mounted on steel covering the whole surface. And they work great on old "cast steel" tools.
1x42 or 1x36 sanders with metal cutting belts are incredibly fast and cool. While they can be hard to get crisp lines with. They are great on the slack belt for drawknives, axes etc...
Re: green waterstone
John Aniano, in central NJ?
>Paul,
I'm with you on this. I have one of the dual stones you mentioned and I couldn't believe how fast it became "unflat" and worn. It acually became dished in just a few uses.
Adam,
I know that diamond "stones" are not truly 17th- or 18th-century tools, they still do a heck of a job at aggressively cutting and keeping their nearly flat surface. If course, I have noticed that they bend in the middle slightly under heavy pressure due to the 4 little rubber feet that my two diamond "stones" have on the bottom corners, but just don't use as much pressure and you should be OK. In the latest Woodwork Magazine (I think) T. Odate talked about inventing 0.002" dished diamond stones. You just have to support the two ends of a regular diamond stone and put heavy grinding pressure on them, and they dish out by themselves.
But seriously, all dishing aside, diamond stones work great. Stay away from the very soft waterstones...
John
Maybe the artists were out of green paint
Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA
>