Re: Building to enable repair *LINK*
Todd Stock
>Instrument makers use heat and moisture to liquify hide glue, as already mentioned. Guitar necks are routinely removed by pulling the fret over the neck's dovetail joint (13th or 15th), drilling a small hole down through the board to access the joint, and (using a steam source/hose/hypodermic needle) injecting steam to soften the glue. On the portion of the fretboard over the guitar body, a heated banket at 300 degrees F is used to break the glue bond (same for bridge-to-soundboard, bridge plate-to-soundboard, and other joints which require periodic adjustment/replacement/rebuild).
On thin woods (under about 1/2" thick, Titebond is reversable if heating the glue line can be accomplished without too much damage to the finish. Same thing with most epoxies (if not already post-cured), where you can raise the glue line temp to above the transition point (extended exposure to higher temps allows the epoxy to re-cure with more resistance to elevated temps).
The real issue with reversability of Titebond and epoxy in standard woodworking is that the construction practices, material use, and finishes employed seldom allow the quantity of heat to be added to the joint without trashing the rest of the piece. For most purposes, that leaves hide glue as the preferred adhesive where a reversable joint is required or desired, and exposure to water will not be an issue.
Hide glue is great stuff, but requires some changes in technique. Hide glue has a highly variable open time before gelling, dependent on material, room temperature, air movement, and temperature of the glue and the work. Forget doing glue-ups in a 60 degree garage or a drafty workroom - the glue will gel well before the joint can be assembled. Also learn to enjoy that unique odor of dead-horse-under-your-workbench...mmm...smells like luthiery in the morning...
Experimenting with hide glue will cost you nothing more than the a can of dry glue ($12), one of those cheapo orange Rival hot water makers from Walmart ($8-$10), some empty plastic glue bottles ($2 each), and a candy thermometer ($4). Follow the directions to make the glue, then place the half-filled bottle in the hot water pot (set at or a little below 140-145 degrees) and use for the next week or so. Fresh hide glue can also be cut into little cubes after gelling up, then frozen for later small batch use once heated. If you can find those little 1 oz glue bottles, fill with hot, fresh glue, freeze, and pop into the water bath 5 minutes before desired use. This also opens the door to hide glue sizing for stain control, which is a good technique to know when finishing both end grain and woods like cherry and maple, which tend to look blotchy when colored with certain stains and dyes.
The best places on the Web for learning about hide glue are the luthiery and instrument repair sites (just like luthiers would benefit from our discussions on hand tool set-up, use, and sharpening). Here's a link to Frank Ford's article on hot hide glue:
Also check out the Musical Instrument Maker's Forum Hide Glue FAQ.
FRETS.COM - Frank Ford's Hide Glue Article