Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

A55 Smoothing Plane

Building to enable repair

Posts

Building to enable repair

#1

Building to enable repair

bill tindall

>I would like to start this as a new thread to focus on a sage point Bob made. This original thought came from boat building down below....

"Sorry folks, but if your work isn’t easily repairable, you are merely doing expensive preparation and storage of fuel for the next generation’s marshmallow roast."

In the latest Popular Woodworking advice is given on building shelves and the recommendation is to nail the dado joint. I used to do some repair and I could not agree more that doing repairs is a good way to learn what does not work. Nailed joints were the reason I quit repairs. I once removed 30+ nails from the failed glue joints of a magnificant antique high chair only to have its owner complain about the cost of repair. A failed glue joint is easily repaired, while a failed- nailed joint usually destroyes some wood. And it costs more to remove the nail and restore the wood than the cost for the rest of the repair. I am not conviced that the nail even provides significant additional strength to a sound joint.

An insideous consequence of "reinforced" glue joints is that after the glue fails the joint stays together-but with little strength- which encourages contunued use, delayed repair, and structural damage to the wood in the joint.

Which brings me to pegged M&T joints. Why? I have great respect for the woodworking forefathers, so they must have had good reason to peg a M&T which I have not discovered. I would rather repair one that was not pegged, with wood or nail.

Re: Building to enable repair

#2

Re: Building to enable repair

john jesseph

>Do you think that was much of a consideration in the Colonial era? I am not so sure- I think it is serendipitous that hide glue is so restorable, just lucky for us. I suspect that drawbored M/T joinery was a belt and suspenders way of putting something together to avoid mid-term (roughly, original owners'lifetime) failure, not cross-generational failure. I think of cross-grain glueblocks in fine casework as evidence that long-long term survival was not a priority...

Re: Building to enable repair

#3

Re: Building to enable repair

Joe Rogers, Northern Virginia

>My guess..I may be wrong...Is that the proper pegged joint is for assembly and to draw the joint tight. The term draw bore applies here. This joint is not glued and is available for knock down or dissassembly at a later date.

A glued M+T joint will not require a peg for anything other than adornment. Not that there is any thing wrong with that (said in a George Castanza voice).

People often don't consider anything past the immediate. This subject that Bob has broached has given me a new insight into a vast area of construction projects.JR

Re: Building to enable repair

#4

Re: Building to enable repair

Steve Mackay

>As a master of the improv I can tell you there is NEVER a reasonb for a nail to go into restoration orrepair. Glue & pin, ewven if it is just a toothpick " inside " the joint.I go through toothpicks by the case.And, sorry, but a good wood carpenter's glue, properly set, dry, and aged will outlast ALL of us ! The pin is only hedging your bets !

Re: Building to enable repair

#5

Perhaps this will help *LINK*

David Barnett - Venice, Florida

>"I have great respect for the woodworking forefathers, so they must have had good reason to peg a M&T which I have not discovered."


THE 17TH CENTURY DRAW BORED MORTISE AND TENON

Re: Building to enable repair

#6

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Close look recently

Jim in Burlington On

>I had a close look at 16-18th century antiques recently. Seems about 90 percent or joints were pegged. All of the older pieces appeared to have round pegs. Even the knock down Armoirs had round pegs many looked to be replaced. I've been giving the "how to make my stuff last forever" quite a bit of thinking and plan to look into it some more. Might not be easier to repair but may never need it.

Re: Building to enable repair

#7

Re: Building to enable repair

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>The issue with aliphatic resin outlasting just us is not the point. The problem with carpenter's glue is that eventually one of your joints will fail, maybe long after you are dead, and then the furniture will have to be repaired again. At that time, when it is necessary to destroy all the other joints to disassemble and repair the failed joint, the esteem with which your memory had been held by your descendents, will take major steps backwards. If however, you had used hide glue, as your ancestors had done when they built it, it would have been a simple job to disassemble all the joints as soon as one had loosened, add more hide glue and quickly put it back together.

Toothpics are not a good idea either. You would be much better off using slivers of veneer or even plane shavings or paper. The problem with toothpics is that they are a very hard wood, and apply very large point forces inside the joint, further compressing and damaging the wood of both the mortise and the tenon, and making the joint looser in the future.

I agree with your opinion on nails. If the abusive carpenter with the hammer were still alive, I would use them to nail his thumb to his bench, so he could never destroy another piece of furniture.

However, I have seen and repaired some valuable old antique chairs, perhaps made more valuable by their sad survival rate (these were originally inexpensive utility chars that were originally constructed for local farmers, not for the rich merchants), which were originally assembled with small forged nails holding the joints together. The nails were used instead of clamps, while the hide glue dried, to facilitate assembly. The chairs were not intended to last several centuries, but there are a few still in existence. Regrettably, the nails did not set a good example for subsequent fixer-uppers.

Re: Building to enable repair

#8

Re: Close look recently

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>Those knockdown armoires are most probably mid to late 19th or early 20th century. The reason they get damaged so often is that the stupid, untrained, unsupervised moving gorillas don't recognize them for what they are, and try to pick them up and move them in one piece. DAMHIKT! (The last bunch escaped before I could get hold of a mallet to teach them a lesson.) These are designed for static loads only. Most of these can be easily damaged just by trying to slide them across the floor. You should always unload and disassemble them before trying to move them anywhere.

Re: Building to enable repair

#9

Re: Building to enable repair

Sgian Dubh

>I agree with you Bill that repairing furniture patched up with nails in an effort to reinforce the joint, or nailed in the first instance is a pain and adds considerably to the cost of the repair.

Dowelled joints too present an extra challenge to the restorer or repairer.

I suspect too that contemporary furniture makers sometimes award more credit to our forebears as cabinetmakers than they always deserve. The question is, did our forebears make furniture with an eye to its future repairability or not?

I think it's true to say that traditional joinery often has more inherent strength than contemporary practice. For instance the fully M&T'd joinery of an 18th. century cabinet door has more inherent strength than contemporary cabinet doors assembled with routed matched cutters that create a scribed (coped) joint with a stub tenon.

The 18th. century cabinetmaker simply didn't have the technology we have now and used techniques that were contemporary then. The additional inherent strength of the full M&T over a stub tenon is mostly a happy accident for those that enjoy old, antique and ancient furniture, the last perhaps exampled by rare church items and the like from the 10th to 16th centuries.

There surely have been a lot of wooden items made since man began working wood that was simply banged together in a hurry using minimal skill and effort. This stuff fell apart long ago and there's almost no record of it for us to examine. There's much contemporary furniture made nowadays using the same minimalist approach, and it'll mostly be in the landfill twenty or so years from now.

But on to pegged tenons. Ancient church furniture that commonly features this joint is often assembled dry. It's the pegs that pull the tenon in tight to the mortice of course. Perhaps the glue making technology of the time was unreliable or unheard of in the village joyners and coffin makers shop in middle England at the time of construction.

News and technology didn't spread around the world in an instant then as it does now. There are examples of war news in far off lands taking months to reach home, by which time the expeditionary force was a bedraggled and defeated rabble with no easy way home. If this white hot news could take so long to reach a monarch, what chance of news of new techniques travelling quickly?

I suspect that the pegged tenon was passed on from generation to generation and was known as a 'good thing.' The addition of reasonably reliable glue in later generations probably became known as a 'good thing made better.'

Pegged and glued mortice and tenons are still being made and it's probably thought of by contemporary makers as either a 'good thing', aesthetically pleasing, or both.

This leads to the question; if an M&T is not only pegged but glued with epoxy resin is it a 'really good thing' because of its initial strength, or not? There are many makers out there that swear by this technique in their chairmaking endeavours-- I pity the poor repairer of those chairs forty, fifty, sixty or more years from now! Slainte.

Re: Building to enable repair

#10

Re: Building to enable repair

Steve Mackay

>Roger that. Consider me educated a bit more. Now that folks pay me for this stuff I can lean toward the more traditional ( and superior ) methods. More fun too. My only point was the prdictable break. If it is going to break make it go where it can be repaired with the least damage. With my miniature stuff I just KNOW they are going to break it at some point so make it where average joe can fix it easily. Thanks again. The hide glue still apears like voo-doo alchemy. Saw a bit on a violin maker with all those cool miniature planes and hide glue. Pure majic and art !

Re: Building to enable repair

#11

Re: Building to enable repair

charlie

>What is the technique used to dismantle a still sound hide glue joint?CH.

Re: Building to enable repair

#12

Re: Building to enable repair

David Barnett - Venice, Florida

>You can inject hot water. Steaming can work on some joints. Or move to Central Florida (or Arizona for the 'dry method', which works wonders for stringed instrument disassembly).

Re: Building to enable repair

#13

Re: Building to enable repair

charlie

>So I presume one must access the insides of a "tight" joint with a syringe?...and then, how much time is required for the glue to soften up? CH.

Re: Building to enable repair

#14

Bob Smalser on glues

Frank D. in Montreal

>Hi Richard,

I don't recall exactly but I believe Bob Smalser studied the rapairability of various modern glues and IIRC epoxy came out ahead (easier to re-glue) than some PVA glues which were difficiult if not imposible to repair. Sorry for the incomplete info, I looked in the Articles section and the archives and couldn't find Bob's post. Maybe someone can point us to it.

Re: Building to enable repair

#15

Re: Bob Smalser on glues

Sgian Dubh

>Without finding the article you're refering to Frank I'd guess the thrust of Bobs argument is that fresh epoxy resin will bond to cured epoxy resin with a little preparation of the old glue surface, whereas PVA won't bond to cured PVA; the old PVA has to removed leaving freshly exposed wood.

Whether or not you'd want to glue over old epoxy resin is a different consideration. The old epoxy resin might be in a poor state and crumbly which I've seen quite often.

What I was refering to with the epoxied chair joint scenario is that sometimes to disassemble the loose joint you are required almost to completely destroy it leading to potential complete rebuild. It's surprising how many people use epoxy resin because of its gap filling ability and perceived capability to make up for deficient joinery. You sometimes see a plug of glue in mortices that widen as they get deeper. Don't ask me how that condition occurs. I just know it sometimes does, ha, ha. Slainte.

Re: Building to enable repair

#18

Yup

Frank D. in Montreal

>Thanks Alf,

Of course there's a third place where I didn't look! Not quite as I remmbered it; not totally off-topic either but Mr. Dubh undrstood my point and explained what I missed in his post.

Thanks again.

Re: Building to enable repair

#19

Re: Building to enable repair *LINK*

Todd Stock

>Instrument makers use heat and moisture to liquify hide glue, as already mentioned. Guitar necks are routinely removed by pulling the fret over the neck's dovetail joint (13th or 15th), drilling a small hole down through the board to access the joint, and (using a steam source/hose/hypodermic needle) injecting steam to soften the glue. On the portion of the fretboard over the guitar body, a heated banket at 300 degrees F is used to break the glue bond (same for bridge-to-soundboard, bridge plate-to-soundboard, and other joints which require periodic adjustment/replacement/rebuild).

On thin woods (under about 1/2" thick, Titebond is reversable if heating the glue line can be accomplished without too much damage to the finish. Same thing with most epoxies (if not already post-cured), where you can raise the glue line temp to above the transition point (extended exposure to higher temps allows the epoxy to re-cure with more resistance to elevated temps).

The real issue with reversability of Titebond and epoxy in standard woodworking is that the construction practices, material use, and finishes employed seldom allow the quantity of heat to be added to the joint without trashing the rest of the piece. For most purposes, that leaves hide glue as the preferred adhesive where a reversable joint is required or desired, and exposure to water will not be an issue.

Hide glue is great stuff, but requires some changes in technique. Hide glue has a highly variable open time before gelling, dependent on material, room temperature, air movement, and temperature of the glue and the work. Forget doing glue-ups in a 60 degree garage or a drafty workroom - the glue will gel well before the joint can be assembled. Also learn to enjoy that unique odor of dead-horse-under-your-workbench...mmm...smells like luthiery in the morning...

Experimenting with hide glue will cost you nothing more than the a can of dry glue ($12), one of those cheapo orange Rival hot water makers from Walmart ($8-$10), some empty plastic glue bottles ($2 each), and a candy thermometer ($4). Follow the directions to make the glue, then place the half-filled bottle in the hot water pot (set at or a little below 140-145 degrees) and use for the next week or so. Fresh hide glue can also be cut into little cubes after gelling up, then frozen for later small batch use once heated. If you can find those little 1 oz glue bottles, fill with hot, fresh glue, freeze, and pop into the water bath 5 minutes before desired use. This also opens the door to hide glue sizing for stain control, which is a good technique to know when finishing both end grain and woods like cherry and maple, which tend to look blotchy when colored with certain stains and dyes.

The best places on the Web for learning about hide glue are the luthiery and instrument repair sites (just like luthiers would benefit from our discussions on hand tool set-up, use, and sharpening). Here's a link to Frank Ford's article on hot hide glue:

Also check out the Musical Instrument Maker's Forum Hide Glue FAQ.


FRETS.COM - Frank Ford's Hide Glue Article

Re: Building to enable repair

#20

Re: Building to enable repair

Bob Smalser, Seabeck, WA

>I can only add that although they both release with heat, you'll never successfully reglue over aliphatic polyvinyl residues like you will the protein glues, which are perfect for those often-broken round tenon joints in chairs.

Once wood is contaminated with white or yellow PVA glue, the residue has to be taken down to fresh wood for successful regluing.

Re: Building to enable repair

#21

Re: Building to enable repair

charlie

>Thank you very much for responding with this detailed and invaluable information Todd. My experience with hide glue is minimal. My challenge at hand is the re and re of early chairs where some of the joints remain tight and should preferably be dismantled to allow for proper re-assembly. I also notice a new thread above on the subject and I now feel that sufficient information will be provided to allow me to proceed with confidence. Thanks again. CH.

Re: Building to enable repair

#22

Re: Building to enable repair

James Watriss

>One of the first things that comes to mind is that it seems like a lot of old furniture building techniques are adapted from old timber framing techinques. Unless an area became particularly affluent, Connecticut in the height of sea trade, for example, there wasn't always a need or a market for someone to specialize in fine furniture. Woodwork was woodwork.

Another thing to remember is that when people do manage to uncover old workshops, there's one tool that's conspicuously absent, at least in the numbers we see today; clamps. It's true for most of us that you can never have too many clamps. But considering that modern tap and die setups are a comparatively recent phenomenon, clamps would have been much more expensive back then. It's true that a lot of woodworkers did have a number of ingenious ways of fixing things to benches and so forth, but if you can't clamp something in place, or can't do it easily, pinning a tenon is as good a method as any, I'd think. I suppose that's a good lesson to take away from the old timber framers... after all, how the hell would you safely clamp something like a barn together?