Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Rare Exotic & Domestic Hardwoods, Milled In-House in Oregon. Browse Unique Stock.

LN #112 or LV #112?

Posts

LN #112 or LV #112?

#1

LN #112 or LV #112?

Terry in Denver

>I know this topic has been hashed out, and there may even be an article covering it, but I can't find it anywhere.

Can someone please point me in the right direction?!

Thanks,

Terry

Re: LN #112 or LV #112?

#2

Re: LN #112 or LV #112? *LINK*

John Todd

>Here's a review by ALF. Seems to come down... as usual... to what you think of Lee Valley's rear tote design. While I have the LN #112, I have all the LV bevel up planes... all 4... and love them. Most of my "bevel down" conventional bench planes are either LN or Clifton, but it not just because of the tote design. Aside from the tote, ALF seemed to like the LV alot.


http://estimatortools.us/ALF/lvscrapers.htm

Re: LN #112 or LV #112?

#3

Re: LN #112 or LV #112?

Terry in Denver

>Thanks, John.

I have a cherry table re-finish job coming up which will require a scraper plane.

Thanks!

Terry

Re: LN #112 or LV #112?

#4

Re: LN #112 or LV #112?

John Todd

>I've got the LN112, but if I had it to do over I'd probably get the LV. The only LV planes I'm not horribly fond of are the conventional "Bench" planes 4 41/2 51/4 and 6. I have a 6, but don't like it as much as my LNs and Cliftons of other sizes. LV always is good value though!

Re: LN #112 or LV #112?

#5

Neither. LN 185

Todd Stock

>

Re: LN #112 or LV #112?

#6

Re: LN #112 or LV #112?

Alice Frampton, UK

>Seems to come down... as usual... to what you think of Lee Valley's rear tote design.

Yeah, sorry about that. I'm a bit of a stuck record in that respect, aren't I?

A small update to my views on scraper plane ownership, FWIW. I subsequently sold the L-N with the intention of getting the L-V - not just because I liked it rather more, althought I did, but also because the L-N had a connection to an event I didn't wish to be reminded of. I know, sounds daft, but the association really put me off using the plane! Anyway, as yet, I still haven't bought the L-V. Simply haven't felt the need with the available range of planes I have, including the Planes-That-Must-Not-Be-Named, and the wood I work with.

Cheers, Alf

Re: LN #112 or LV #112?

#7

Re: Neither. LN 185

Terry D

>Todd:

I considered the #185, but I felt the expansive table top would take significantly longer to smooth the the narrower blade.

That doesn't mean it gets knocked off the wish list, though!

Terry

Re: LN #112 or LV #112?

#8

Re: Neither. LN 185

Todd Stock

>The major advantage of the LV 112 is the designed-in ability to bow the blade, which can be done with a real 112 or with a LN if you have a thinner blade, some super glue, and a few shims. Once the blade is bowed, the cut is not much wider than the 85, so even on larger panels, I use a 5-1/2 to finish and the 85 if necessary. Had the Stamley 112...have the LN 112...use the 85 instead these days.

Re: LN #112 or LV #112?

#9

Re: LN #112 or LV #112?

mikew

>"including the Planes-That-Must-Not-Be-Named"

What planes are those, Alice?

Mike

go ask Alice, when she's...

Re: LN #112 or LV #112?

#10

[grin]

Alice Frampton, UK

>