Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Gonna spend some money

Posts

Gonna spend some money

#1

Gonna spend some money

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Greetings all

My fledgling plane collection is about to grow again. I have my eye on the new LV bevel up jointer plane. I am going to buy the plane along with one more blade to start. Since I seem to work a lot of curly maple, would the 50 deg blade be my best choice?

Thanks.

Bill

Re: Gonna spend some money

#2

Re: Gonna spend some money

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>Hi Bill

Since honing with a micro-bevel is so quick, you can experiment and change the bevel angle until it suits your needs. In other words, it is unnecessary to suffer pre-purchase trauma!

Personally, I prefer using the BUJ with a 62 degree cutting angle to minimize the potential for tearout in the timber with which I work. For another, 50 degrees may suffice.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Gonna spend some money

#3

Re: Gonna spend some money

Todd Stock

>I work curly with a #4 w/HA frog from LN, so 50 degrees should work well as a starting point.

Re: Gonna spend some money

#4

Will you use it primarily for...

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>surface planing or edge planing?

I use my jointers mostly for edge work, so I just try to plane with the grain and don't worry about bevel angle.

For large surface flattening, I usually use a #6, which is shorter than a jointer. Then follow with a smoother, shorter still.

If you're surface planing stock that has come out of a power planer, I'd just go straight to the smoother. Others would disagree with that.

Experiment.

Best, Ted

Re: Gonna spend some money

#5

Derek, I think that's what Bill meant

Denis Chénard, Orléans, Ont.

>50 degree blade for an effective 62 degree cutting angle.

Great plane BTW, Bill...

DC

Re: Gonna spend some money

#6

Tail to Tale

Jim Shaver, Oakville Ontario

>Hmmmm, Bill,

I remember once asking you about all your tools, your response was they all had tails....now that sounds like a Tale these days!!

The jointer plane is very nice with the stock blade. I have tried one, but I have a 607 bedrock and it's my go to plane right now for that aspect of my hand work.

take care,

Jim

Re: Gonna spend some money

#7

Re: Gonna spend some money

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Thanks for the responses guys.

Derek, I figure I will end up putting a micro bevel on the one blade anyway, but buying one with a steeper initial bevel will save me some time.

Todd, I have an old Stanley #4 I picked up which needs a little TLC, and I may end up putting a Hock blade and iron on it and using it for smoothing of surfaces.

Ted, I will be using it mainly for cleaning up edges. I have really curly stuff in the shop right now that was a nightmare to get jointed with clean edges and machines, so I am pursuing this stone age stuff. ;-)

Denis, do you have one? I remember your post about the "plane day".

Jim, I have a power cord all ready to install as soon as it gets here! Seriously though, I am always looking for ways to improve my work, and power combined with hand has always been my way. I'm just adding more hand tools to the list.

Bill

Re: Gonna spend some money

#8

Re: Gonna spend some money

Derek Cohen (in Perth Australia)

>"Derek, I figure I will end up putting a micro bevel on the one blade anyway, but buying one with a steeper initial bevel will save me some time."

Bill

The angle of the primary bevel makes no difference at all - unless it is steeper than the desired secondary bevel. That is the point I was trying to make originally. Getting a blade with a 25 degree primary bevel just gives you more options than one with a 50 degree primary bevel.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Gonna spend some money

#9

I don't have one... Yet...

Denis Chénard, Orléans, Ont.

>I had to return mine after "testing" :-(

Hey, can't complain, it was great on Veritas' part to let me sample all these planes...

I'm torn between the BU jointer, some Besseys, or a great deal on a Triton router. I could buy all three, but I should hold myself to one. Right now, all of these are more "wants" than "needs", but I know I'll be using them at some point...

Let's see... If I give my Stanley #6C to my brother-in-law, and quit smoking, maybe then I would be "justified" to get the jointer AND one of the other two...

DC

Re: Gonna spend some money

#10

My BUJ and free fence...

Christopher Fitch @ Memphis

>...are in my cube sitting in the box that just arrived about 30 minutes ago.

Now I'm looking at the BUS and the Router Plane....(I already have the LA Jack)

Re: Gonna spend some money

#11

Re: Gonna spend some money

Greg Sloop, Portland Oregon

>Derek's right. I always buy the 25 deg one. Then I just put whatever bevel I want on it. For at least a while, I never have to reset the primary bevel as I'm going up and the secondary bevel's not too wide/deep.

If you buy a higher primary bevel, then you have to regind the primary bevel more quickly as the secondary becomes too wide and time consuming to hone each time.

Cheers,

Greg

Re: Gonna spend some money

#12

For edge work...

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>do not get a corrugated sole, just get the plain one.

Best, Ted

(whose trip was postponed to next week)

Re: Gonna spend some money

#13

Re: Gonna spend some money

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Okay Derek (and Greg), now I understand. Perhaps I will stick with just the blade that comes with it for now. That will make SWMBO happy.

Christopher, I was going to order mine today, but had to go inspect a log. It was a bit of a wild goose chase, but it has some small burls on it, and I got a good contact for future wood. I guess I have to wait until tomorrow now. I will be interested to hear your impressions.

Ted, if you are still here, I owe you an email! I may be out your way sooner than I thought, as Sarah got a ride home for fall break. That means I will be carting her back. I will send you the dates.

Bill

Re: Gonna spend some money

#14

OT: Look forward to those dates...

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>and hopefully I can impress you with my ever increasing turning muscle.

Also, don't let me forget, I'm supposed to talk to you about combining one of your trips with a Saturday demo to our turning club. Perhaps in April.

Best, Ted

Re: Gonna spend some money

#15

Re: OT: Look forward to those dates...

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Well, Ted, if you've been eating at that "restaurant" on a regular basis, your turning muscle is going to look like mine! BTW, have you checked out the turning forum today? I put up a piece of burl there that might tickle your fancy. Sort of like that cherry one in your house but with a ragged top and some holes in it.

Bill

Re: Gonna spend some money

#16

Re: Gonna spend some money

Greg Sloop, Portland Oregon

>IMHO, get the extra blade. It will always come in handy!

Cheers,

Greg

Re: Gonna spend some money

#17

Re: Gonna spend some money

ThomD

>Seriously, what is the point to this thing. Smoothing big areas with a jointer is silly, and why does one need a low angle plane for edges. I need answers so I have arguments. I'm thinking of adding one of these.

Re: Gonna spend some money

#18

Re: Gonna spend some money

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Greg, this is a business expense, but SWMBO watches me like a hawk, and I have already pushed the current limit, so if I can wait a bit on the second blade, it is a diplomatic victory for me.

Thom, I was attracted to it for the fence that comes with it. Most boards get jointed on my Mini Max 12" jointer or 8 1/2' sliding table, but this will be great for cleaning up cuts or jointing one or two boards without having to change a setup on the combo. Besides, I have very large hands, so it will be as a smoother in my paw. ;-)

Bill

Re: Gonna spend some money

#19

Yes, beautiful, except...

Ted Owen, Pittsburgh

>in my turning experience, the hole goes in the bottom center. : )

Best, Ted

Re: Gonna spend some money

#20

Re: Gonna spend some money

Derek

>Bill,

In theory a jointer can be used as a smoother. In reality, it does not work as well as a smoother because the sole is too long. A smoother is not to get the board flat but to get out the minor imperfections in the board. The longer plane will only get teh tops of the hills but not get into the valleys in the board. Since a smoother is taking off on the order of 1/1000" and the board, even after planing, is seldom this flat, the jointer will require much more work to do the smoothing job. The smoother gets down into the valleys much more easily.

In addition, a jointer is generally sharpened with a perfectly straight edge (though some do not do this), a smoother really needs some curvature to the edge.

Re: Gonna spend some money

#21

Re: Gonna spend some money

Bill Grumbine (Kutztown PA)

>Thanks Derek, although that much I already know. I was making an attempt at humor. I figure on using the #4 I have for smoothing, and I could probably use it for cleaning up edges on boards run through the power jointer, but I have both the itch and the scratch to buy this plane.

Bill