Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Urban Salvaged Hardwood Slabs, Milled In-House from Rare Trees. Shop Unique Walnut Stock.

wow... that's a lot of planes.

Posts

wow... that's a lot of planes.

#1

wow... that's a lot of planes.

James Watriss

>I was just thinking about hand planes a minute ago, and I'm wondering if maybe I have too many. My main excuse is that half of them are at school, and the other half at home, and I use the shop at home, too, but there are still a lot of planes. From what I can recall, I have... 23 planes? Everything from 3 to 8, (3 #3s, 2 4's, 2 4.5's...) block and shoulder planes, a couple of old wooden razee jointers (26 and 29") a japanese smoother, and an old mathieson. On top of all that, I also have my first shepherd kit on the way, and I'm in the middle of finishing a matched set of hollow and round planes from a workshop I took with Larry Williams.

When does one finally admit to having a problem?

Re: wow... that's a lot of planes.

#2

Steve Kubien

There's a minor problem and quick fix.

Steve Kubien

>James,

It takes a brave person to acknowledge that they MAY have a problem. If you truly had a problem, you would feel compelled to act upon it. That could lead to the tragic loss of tools and that should only happen due to death or financial hardship.

Your problem is not too many planes. Your problem is that you do not have enough saws, braces, eggbeaters, chisels, gauges, etc to mask the number of planes you have. Branch out my child. Seek the tools you do not have but feel you could become compulsive about!

And for G*d's sake, don't let your wife know!

Steve Kubien - who needs to liquidate somewhat

for financial reasons

Ajax, Ontario

Re: wow... that's a lot of planes.

#3

Re: wow... that's a lot of planes.

Bob Dodge

>Good Grief James,

Delete this thread immediately, before "da lil' woman" see's it. I'll be ina heap-o-trouble. ;-))

Bob

PS. My motto is: "Never, but never, allow common-sense to interfere with a tool purchasing decision."

Re: wow... that's a lot of planes.

#4

Problem? What Problem?

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native in FL. Exile :~(

>Only problem I can think of is a storage problem, but that's no problem.

Look at it this way: Do you have a roof* over you and your familys head? Food for them, clothes for them, putting a little $ in the bank for the future, all bills are paid? Than what's the problem? Trust me, you'll never have enough green to buy all that you WANT, and once you accept that, and just buy yourself some "new rust" every once in awhile you'll be fine and there'll be no problem.

I have I don't know how many #5's and passed on one last week that is still hurting me. Real nice Type 11 or 12 for $20. Ahhhhhhhhhhhhhh well, I'm still living so I guess passing one over from time to time won't kill anybody either.

* preferably buying a home of your own, as renting and living with in-laws is in most cases a waste of $$$.

Todd O.

Re: wow... that's a lot of planes.

#5

Only 23...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>Not near enough to think you have a problem...yet. Wait till you get to 100 or more, then come talk to us...

Re: wow... that's a lot of planes.

#6

Re: get with the program

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>Someone is going to have to give these things a good home. I think now that you are admitting to only having 23 planes, it becomes obvious you are not doing your share. This is a great disappointment to the rest of us who are really trying to hold our end of the load. If you do not report back in a year that you have more than 80 planes, we are going to hold your nose to a hand cranked grinder until you do your civic duty.

Re: wow... that's a lot of planes.

#7

Darrell in Oakville

Re: wow... that's a lot of planes.

Darrell in Oakville

>23 planes is "a lot"?!?

What about your half-set of hollows and rounds? What about a set of side beads, a couple ovolos, ogees, and a few other small molding planes? Rabbet planes, need lots of those in assorted sizes, with various options. Plows, match planes, scrapers, compass planes. Gotta have wooden, metal, transitional, and infills of each size. And preferably multiples of each, for backup. Twenty Three? Dude, you have barely scratched the surface. Here, take a look around my shop

http://www.cs-club.org/~scottq/darrell/Shop360.html

THIS is where you are heading. Somebody bring the teflon boots over here, James needs a push...

Darrell

Wood Hoarder, Blade Sharpener, and Occasional Tool User

Re: wow... that's a lot of planes.

#8

Re: wow... that's a lot of planes.

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native in FL. Exile :~(

>Dang Darrell, how big is your shop?! Arrrrrrrrrrrrrrrgh I need more wall space!!!

Nice, nice shop tho, looks really comphy and homey. Looks like you could get lost in there.

When facing your clamp rack, offf to the left looks to be a huge Handscrew. Am I right? Man, that things is a Monster!

you use that Handcranker drill press much? how's it's accuracy?

Todd O.

Re: wow... that's a lot of planes.

#9

Darrell in Oakville

Re: wow... that's a lot of planes.

Darrell in Oakville

>Hiya Todd,

I have a little over 300 square feet down there. Most of the walls are covered in a thin layer of tools. The big handscrew was made by Bliss in RI and yes it's a Big One. I use the post drill quite a bit. Just the other day I drilled some pen blanks. I used to have a electrickery powered drill press, but sold it a year after I got the post drill. The drill press never saw any use at all once The Beast was installed :^) If you centre punch your holes then the drill bit will follow, so accuracy just comes naturally. I often wonder why power tool (ab)users are so worried about 0.004 runout on a drill press. My post drill has about 1/8 inch of play in the shaft and I can still drill a good hole for a pen blank. I've even used my post drill as a milling machine to flatten the bed on a plane casting.

Darrell

Wood Hoarder, Blade Sharpener, and Occasional Tool User

Re: wow... that's a lot of planes.

#10

I hope you're kidding us :>)

Victor Parisian

>

Re: wow... that's a lot of planes.

#11

Are you sure you are on the right side?

Ron in Kokomo

>There are some guys over on the Power side with more than 23 planes :)

Re: wow... that's a lot of planes.

#12

Re: wow... that's a lot of planes.

James Watriss

>LOL

ok, ok... I get the picture.

So... out of curiosity, for those of you who have 100s of planes... how many of them are tuned up and see regular use?

Re: wow... that's a lot of planes.

#13

Re: wow... that's a lot of planes.

Dan Clermont in Burnaby

>I believe I have 18 bench and specialty planes and probably another 15 moulding planes.

I really do use them all. Matter of fact today I used the 607, #8, scrub, rough jack, jack, and 5 smoothers trying to get the right angle and plane to remove the tearout.

My arms are sore.

Dan Clermont

I could get by with a Block plane, rabbet plane, scrub, jointer and 5 1/2 as a smoother but like using different planes with different angles

Re: wow... that's a lot of planes.

#14

I finally stopped counting

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>If you're a rust collector, it's easy to get the numbers up, particularly in bench planes. I have about two or three more bench planes than I need, but they were about $2 each, hard to turn down.

I stopped counting, though - it's just not worth it.

Re: wow... that's a lot of planes.

#15

Re: wow... that's a lot of planes.

Tom MacGregor

>I just took 80 tools, including about 35 planes, from my shop and put them on consignment at a local antique store. Most were found early on (high on the slope?). I'm doing this to free up some money and space to buy better stuff now that I know more. I view it as a process of natural selection in the evolution of my shop. Bear in mind that most people don't even understand why you'd want more than one plane. That's due to their ignorance. If you were collecting gold coins few would question it because they would perceive a value to the collection. If the viewer of the neighbor's salt & pepper shaker collection sees them as "cute" (again adding a value!) it's OK for the neighbor to have just added set #327 shaped like miniature garden gnomes. Quit feeling guilty and go find some more planes to save before they get drenched with polyurethane and nailed to the wall of the nearest Applebee's.

Re: wow... that's a lot of planes.

#16

Harrumph !!!!!

Dave Anderson Chester, NH

>James, you need a little help and guidance since your mental state is obviously a bit shaky right now. I have exactly the prescription for you::: Abandon your class at NBSS a week from tomorrow (9/9/05) and take a short drive north and west to Nashua, NH. At the Holiday Inn off route 3 there will be a parking lot and hotel ballroom full of fully qualified folks who will be available to adjust your attitude and provide counselling. As a side benefit there will be literally tons of tools to peruse and make offers on. No, you don't need to thank me. I'm always happy to lead someone back to the true path.

Re: wow... that's a lot of planes.

#17

I'll try to be there NM

James Watriss

>

Re: wow... that's a lot of planes.

#18

Totally Unacceptable....

Gerry Doll

>I thought an over age 18 disclaimer was required before posting tool porn, especially when in video format.

Nice work, beautiful collection.

Gerry

Green with envy

Re: wow... that's a lot of planes.

#19

Danger, Danger, Will Robinson!!!!

Gerry Doll

>James,

The following is a direct quote from the Chester Toolworks website, " I completely and absolutely deny that I have any kind of hand tool addiction.-- DSA"

David is purveyor of beautifully crafted hand tools, and is in total denial regarding his affliction. Proceed with extreme caution.

Gerry

Re: wow... that's a lot of planes.

#20

Problem?

Ernie Miller

>Let me tell you about a problem. once not to long ago I purchased 50 planes at one time from a well know pusher over in England. it took about 5 weeks to get here. and then I had back surgery. and they arived the same day. I had to stay flay on my back so I laied on the floor looking and druling over my new tools. it was totaly agonizing to know it would be a week or more befor I would be able to get to the basement shop to try and use one. I was able to convince my wife the next day to go down to the shop somthing she never does and get me a stone or two so I could at least sharpen them. It ended up being almost two weeks befor I ever got to put one to wood. RElax you are ok things will be fine. Enjoy the ones you have whyle you look fro your next one.

Re: wow... that's a lot of planes.

#21

Re: Problem?

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native in FL. Exile :~(

>Enjoy the ones you have while you look for your next one.

-Ernie, with slight editing by me

Yes Ned, that is actually the "fun" part, a.k.a. "The hunt" Yes, it's the hunt itself that is so addictive. Wake up on flea market day and think "What will I find today" and "Will I have enough $$$ for what I find" Pawing around in old cardboard boxes full of rust, or sorting thru a pile of assorted junk to find a gem, than trying to contain your excitement when you do find one so as not to tip off the seller that it's worth more than the $1-5 you're hoping s/he'll ask for it. Yes, hunting rust is a learned skill just as in any other hunting. Wanna make it really fun, go rust hunting with a fellow rust junkie. That'll keep you on your toes. Now you have to use the art of deception as well. this is when you spy a table of rust a liitle way away, and try yo get your buddy not only to NOT see it, but get him/her interested in something else thereby getting first crack at the "goodie table". Lots O' fun. :~)

Todd O.