WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

Finishing a workbench

Posts

Finishing a workbench

#1

Finishing a workbench

Darin in Victoria

>Hi All,

I'm trying to figure out what finish to use on my workbench. The bench isn't finished yet, but I'd like to apply some finish on the bottom now while it is still relatively painless to turn it upside down. I've heard that people use BLO for the ease of reapplication and the fact that the surface doesn't get slippery. Poly is out because I don't want a slipping and sliding top. The top doesn't have to be waterproof, but I'd like to use the top as an assembly table. It should be able to handle a few spills or glue blotches. I was thinking that Tung oil or Danish oil may also work. Any suggestions on what product would work well?

Re: Finishing a workbench

#2

Re: Finishing a workbench

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>I use Danish oil. Well, no, really, I spill danish oil, walnut oil, motor oil, shellac, spar varnish, etc., on it from time to time, and mop it up. I also spill several different kinds of glue, including aliphatic resins, Gorilla, epoxy and CA on it. Most of them, except the epoxy, come off OK with a scraper, and they all come off easier where the finish has been maintained. Cured epoxy on bare wood will not separate at the glue line - if you pull, you will probably remove some bench top with it.

Watco is ok, but I would not use Waterlox, or Poly or any oil that builds a heavy surface film, since it will make a mess of your planes when you need to reflatten it. Other varnishes, including spar varnish, don't harden very well, which is also a disadvantage for a bench top. Shellac and wax over shellac don't stand up so well to water based glues.

Re: Finishing a workbench

#3

Exactly the same story here....

HC Sakman

>Rub-on ploy, BLO or any sort of oil you can think of. Rub-on poly as Sir William mentioned it, it's not applied properly, but rather in an erratic random manner, in other words "accidently". Occasional wax, applied w/ or w/o oil also works well.

Chico...

Re: Finishing a workbench

#4

Steve Kubien

What I did

Steve Kubien

>Hi Darin,

I thinned some BLO with pure turpentine and applied several coats (one a day for about 4 days, once a week or so for about a month, and occasionally since then). After all that, I put on a thin coats of Minwax Paste Wax and I have been pretty happy. I generally use a slab of plywood or cardboard when finishing but I've had no problems with yellow glue sticking.

Good luck and I hope this helps,

Steve Kubien

Ajax, Ontario

Re: Finishing a workbench

#5

Re: Finishing a workbench

Dean J in MN

>

Poly is out because I don't want a slipping and sliding top. The top doesn't have to be waterproof, but I'd like to use the top as an assembly table. It should be able to handle a few spills or glue blotches. I was thinking that Tung oil or Danish oil may also work.

I used thinned BLO on my maple top. I think 3 or 4 coats. But I do "upkeep" with a homebrew beeswax paste wax. Glues don't stick to it, it smells nice, and most important of all -- it isn't slippery.

-Dean

Re: Finishing a workbench

#6

Re: Finishing a workbench

Adam Cherubini

>I watco'd my beech bench then waxed it until in shone like a piece of furniture. It sure looked pretty and every woman who happened into my shop wanted a kitchen countertop just like it. Glue drips came right off of it.

I recently planed the top bringing the top back into line with the sagging tail vise. I had every intention of reapplying the watco, but I really prefer the lack of slipperiness. Maybe if you put enough watco to make allow glue tto come off but not enough to make it slippery it would be best.

I'll not wax another work bench.

Adam

P.S. I made bench dogs out of ebony and I'll not make that mistake again either. They're just too slippery.

Re: Finishing a workbench

#7

Re: Finishing a workbench

Alan Bierbaum

>I used waterlox and paste wax. Three coats of Waterlox in the bottom. Waterlox with top coat of paste wax on the top and visible edges. I also use a 4' x 4' piece of 1/4" hardboard to protect the bench from my finishing efforts and for glueups. I find that the spills that hit the bench clean up easily.

As for things sliding around: I don't have a problem. I plane some things against a stop, and clamp some. I chop all of my dovetails with the parts loose on the bench top - no clamps or vise usage.

The attached picture shows the hardboard protective cover in use.


img

Re: Finishing a workbench

#8

Re: Finishing a workbench

Paul M. in San Diego

>I used a polymerizing oil (Liberon oil is my favorite) since this drys reasonably quickly. I did 2 coats, sanding this into the surface with 220 grit to get a thick slurry, then wipe off. Glue doesn't stick (much). If it does, then the scraper whips it off and a touch up with oil cleans up the bald spot. The 220 keeps the top from getting too slippery, and I would not go to finer grits in subsequent coats like I do with furniture. No wax needed.

Re: Finishing a workbench

#9

Thanks guys

Darin in Victoria

>Just picked up a can of Watco Danish Oil and applied it to the bottom of my bench. Looks good on the bottom can't wait until the rest of the top is finished!

Re: Finishing a workbench

#10

Re: Thanks guys

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>If you use your bench like I use my bench, it won't look good on the top for very long :^) But that's OK, because it's really easily fixed, if only you have time to let it dry after you've reapplied the danish oil, it'll look ok again, for a while. In the meantime, an oil and varnish finish does an OK job of releasing glue spills.

OTOH, if you can do it, a rag, wetted with whatever solvent is appropriate for your glue of choice, works well enough for wiping off spills, if you use it soon after setting the clamps in place. Most of them aren't effective at attacking a fully polymerized varnish, while one or another will quickly decimate most other finishes you might choose. For example, you need water to clean up hide glue and aliphatic resins, but it attacks wax and shellac (and bare wood). You need acetone for epoxy, but it attacks lacquers. Acetone also works well for uncured polyurethane glue, and I have been somewhat successful cleaning that up with petroleum distilates and similar solvents (mineral spirits, naphtha, WD-40, turpentine etc.) as well, if used quickly enough, but these also remove wax. Any alcohol, including ethanol, methanol, toluene, isopropol, etc. will attack shellac. Also, ammonia, for example Windex, and many acids will attack shellac. While not many solvents you might throw on top of your bench will attack a polyurethane varnish, many forumulations of poly scratch easily and crack easily from a sharp blow, and are subsequently difficult to repair because more poly does not bond well to a previous coat of fully cured poly.

I don't have any recommendations regarding urea-formaldehyde and resorcinol, because I don't use them. Maybe someone else can help?

Re: Finishing a workbench

#11

Re: Thanks guys

Darin in Victoria

>Thanks William, I suspect that I'll end up having to resurface a few times since glue always seems to get on my work surfaces. However, the oil should work well enough to make it "easier" to lift off. I usually use the yellow PVA and was more concerned about getting that stuff off. Say, doesn't a chisel work best for removing the other glues :)?

Re: Finishing a workbench

#12

BLO and Beeswax

Dave Thompson - Champaign IL

>I also used BLO and a home made Beeswax mix. Dried glue comes right off because of the beeswax, and it's easy to reapply.

As mentioned by others, the finished look may not matter much if you plan to use it since it will be short lived.

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.