"Review" on Veritas low angle Jack plane
kenc
>Thought Id post my opinion (for what it's worth) on the Lee Valley low angle Jack. I know it's been done before, but as far as I know only by folks who have been given them free of charge and thus been paid for the priveledge. I do respect the opinions of those who provided the "test report" on the various L.V. tools, but I also know that some people (not including myself) consider those opinions *potentially* biassed.
The plane and optional 50 degree blade arrived on Saturday, perfect timing for an immediate use on a pair of cherry side tables I'm building. Cherry is very expensive out in California, so I am forced into using boards that if price were no option I'd not bother with. These board have various patches of sharply reversing grain, and it was the problems I was having with my 605-1/2 and various other of my "old" planes that caused me to purchase the LV.
First impression was of very nice quality, *especially* given the $179 purchase price.
On the body, I would prefer a shiny black Japann type finish, but there's no denying the crinkle black is nicely done.
The sides are as square to the sole as makes no difference, the sole respectably flat and the woodwork - reminiscent of old Millers Falls planes IMO, very nice indeed. I've read reservations about the shape of the tote, but I found it quite comfortable.
I was most impressed with the lack of backlash in the Norris style adjuster - not many of my original Norris planes has an adjuster that is as nice as this one!
The 25 degree blade ('iron' if you prefer - I don't) took about an hour to flatten with 800, 1200 and 6000 grit waterstones. The 50 degree blade only took about ten minutes. I think either would have functioned quite nicely as supplied, but I thought I'd be thorough.
One problem I encountered was in sharpening the bevel on the 50 degree blade - I use a Makita wet wheel to do the bevel side, and I could only barely elevate the whole assembly enough to do the 50 degree blade since it (the blade) is so much shorter than a normal bench plane blade.
I used the plane for edge jointing boards about 2feet long and it did a wonderful job, the plane feels good in the hands and seems to sit squarely to the job without a lot of trial and error adjustment.
I face planed the glue ups and in general the 25 degree blade did an excellent job, there was little effort in pushing the plane and it produced full width transparent shavings. There was some tearout where I expected there to be, so I substituted the 50 degree blade. According to the literature supplied, this blade is 50 degrees (giving a 62 degree pitch) with a slight secondary bevel being applied. I don't bother with secondary bevels, so I guess my final pitch might have been closer to the "half pitch" of yore - about 60degrees.
There's no doubt that the effort required to push the plane with the 60degree pitch is significantly higher than with the 37degree pitch setup. I'd guess about 3 times as hard, but what a fabulous finish it produces! No tearout and a glass like finish resulted. Again, full width almost transparent shavings, Excellent!
So that's about it - with the two blades, this could just about be the ultimate single plane to own if you could only own one. For $179 plus $30 for the 50 degree A2 blade this must rank as the deal of all deals in handplanes.
I haven't tried the LN low angle jack, but I would certainly miss the Norris adjuster that the LV has. If you're sitting on the fence about buying this plane I say go for it.
Ken



