Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

100+ Wood Species + Full-Shop Services: Lumber, Veneer, Tools & CNC. Everything in One Place.

Gloat-eight months in advance

Posts

Gloat-eight months in advance

#1

Gloat-eight months in advance

John Clifford

>I just placed an order with Wayne Anderson yesterday for a 10 inch smoother with ebony infill and an ivory inlay. In fact I'm getting one just like the one pictured on his website listed as 10 inch smoother in the gallery section. He said about eight months or possibly sooner. That puts it at sometime in January, or if the "if sooner" works out maybe sometime near Christmas. No matter when I get it, it will be like Christmas to me. Quite possibly the best Christmas ever. Better than even getting a Red Ranger (or is it Red Rider?) BB rifle.

By the way, when I was talking to Wayne he said he was making a plane for Thomas Lie-Nielsen. How's that for an endorsement!

Ah well, I guess I'll go back to Wayne's website and drool over the picture for awhile.

Re: Gloat-eight months in advance

#2

Oh, I thought,

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native in FL. Exile :~(

>That perhaps maybe you had just found out that there was to be a new Galoot amongst us in 8 months. Well, I guess I'm half right as I'm sure that you'll treat your new plane as if it was a new baby eh?

Sooooooooooo, any word on what plane Wayne is making for Tom? Sure this is great endorsement for Wayne, but I think kinda' hurts Tom alittle.

Todd O.

Re: Gloat-eight months in advance

#3

Re: Oh, I thought,

Dan Donaldson

>I don't think that it hurts Tom at all. The type of planes that Wayne makes are totaly different from those that Tom does. Anyone can appreciate phenomenal craftsmanship;-)

Re: Gloat-eight months in advance

#4

Re: Oh, I thought,

wayne anderson

>It is actually a trade...plane for a plane. Mutual appreciation of each other's work. No more...no less. Wayne

Re: Gloat-eight months in advance

#5

Re: Oh, I thought,

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native in FL. Exile :~(

>Just kinda' struck me that if it was known that tom would be seeking out a "competetors" plane than folks might say "Hmmmmmmmmmmmmm, if Toms planes aren't good enough for him, than why should I buy one either"? There is no doubt in my mind that Tom appreciates fine craftsmanship as much as the next Galoot does and and I can see why he, as much as the next Galoot would lust after one of Waynes creations for either use or collection/display purposes. That's all I was thinking.

Than again, I'm way overtired today and may not be thinking clearly. Those four 18 hour days in a row sure wear me down,not to mention that for the past two weekends I'd been painting the house. Been trying to get my shop back into some kind of order today since last weekend I got a new gara, er, er, shop door installed, and sice it had been broken for over a year I had been using the door as a wall/wood storage area, and now that this space is gone I'm trying to rearrange. Having trouble getting out of my own tracks tho.

Todd O.

Re: Gloat-eight months in advance

#6

Re: Oh, I thought,

Mike L in Trabuco Canyon, CA

>Apples and oranges i.m.o. Todd. LN planes are known for fine engineering and utility. They're pleasing to the eye but not works of art (again, just m.o.). Wayne's planes are not only finely engineered (that's mostly presumption on my part but I bet it's true) but they're works of art.

Regards,

Mike

Re: Gloat-eight months in advance

#7

No argument here

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native in FL. Exile :~(

>I certainly concur with your thinking Mike, tho to a smallpoint I'd also say that toms Tools are a bit of works of art, albiet they are reproductions, with improvements made, to previously made tools. I think that Tom has done a fantastic job of bringing a fine user and good looking tool to the masses who, for whatever reasons choose to buy his products. While Wayne on the other side of the coin makes functional works of art that fits into aneven smaller niche market than Toms.

In closing, both of these makers, and numerous others (LV, Steve Knight, Shepards, Clark and Williams spring to mind) all deserve and very hearty slap on the back for providing we tool users with Quality tools in al the various $$$$ ranges. Sure they may cost a wee bit more, but you don't see "Made in China" on them either.

With all that said, I still say that dollor for dollar you can't go wrong with vintage tools especially for the common ones, but when it comes to the speciality tools than one from a "Modern Master" is probably the best way to go.

Todd O.

Re: Gloat-eight months in advance

#8

Re: works of art

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>There is no doubt that the wayne anderson plane is a work of art. But, take a look around the hand tool isle the next time you go to the borg, and then compare what you see when you look at a Lie-Nielsen #4-1/2 bench plane. These are tools that are made on a production line, but in my opinion, although they are not the same as the Anderson plane, they are on the same level of workmanship when one takes into consideration that they are made on a production line in a country where the bottom line seems to be the only line.

Re: Gloat-eight months in advance

#9

Re: Oh, I thought,

John Clifford

>Wayne, said he's making an even trade? I have and love Lie-Nielsen planes but I can't imagine that being a fair trade. Unless he's trading maybe 4 or 5 LN's for one of Wayne's planes.