Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Nearly 100 Exotic Wood Species, Direct-Imported Since 1972. Shop Slabs & Turning Stock.

Adjustable mouth on block plane, necessary?

Posts

Adjustable mouth on block plane, necessary?

#1

Adjustable mouth on block plane, necessary?

Alan Tolchinsky

>Hi again, How useful is it to have an adjustable mouth opening on a block plane? There is a pretty good $$ difference between the two LN ones and I wondered if it is worth it? Thanks

Re: Adjustable mouth on block plane, necessary?

#2

Re: Adjustable mouth on block plane, necessary?

Bill Houghton, Sebastopol, CA

>I work mostly softwood and mild North American hardwoods. I never adjust the mouth opening on my block planes.

I'm told that it matters for more difficult woods; perhaps someone who works those woods can chime in.

Re: Adjustable mouth on block plane, necessary?

#3

Re: Adjustable mouth on block plane, necessary?

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>That's kind of like asking whether an automatic transmission is useful on an automobile :^) I happen to like stick shifts better, for some cantankerous reason, but an adjustable mouth, on either a bevel up or a bevel down (if you can get one) plane sure is convenient.

The reason the adjustable mouth is useful is that you need fewer planes to quickly get to an optimum surface. If you don't use your block plane for creating a finished surface, you can tolerate a larger mouth opening. If you set a plane with a much smaller opening, then you have to take more strokes with the plane to get the shape and surface you want. If you always use woods with similar, well-behaved characteristics, then a larger, or at least not quickly adjustable mouth will do fine. OTOH, if you are constantly experimenting with gnarly pieces of wood, looking for the ultimate color and figure, then being able to quickly adapt the plane to make the optimum shaving is an advantage.

Either way you look at it you win: more planes with more gizmosity factor gives you tool bragging rights. Fewer, simpler planes gives you skill bragging rights. Quicker results gives you bragging rights, but then BS&T painstaking workmanship gives you bragging rights as well.

Re: Adjustable mouth on block plane, necessary?

#4

Yep, that about sums it all up on all counts

Lyn J. Mangiameli

>

Re: Adjustable mouth on block plane, necessary?

#5

Thanks and follow up angle question?

Alan Tolchinsky

>I'm a stick kind of person myself; been driving them for 40 yrs. :)

What's the best criterion to use for selecting the angle, low angle or regular? It seems most people are buying the LA but are they correct in this? Isn't LA mostly good for end grain and the regular angle used for surface cuts? I was just about to buy the LA but I don't want it primarily for end grain. Is this just a fad or is the LA better overall? Man some tricky decisions here. Thanks Alan

Re: Adjustable mouth on block plane, necessary?

#6

It depends ob what you want to do with it.

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>End grain does not tear out, so a small mouth is not necessary. I have tested this on a few occasions with my Stanley #65 and Hock blade combo. It really does not matter what the size of the mouth - what matters is that the blade is very sharp and has a low cutting angle.

It is a different matter on face grain, especially interlinked grain, where the plade may "scoop" out the chips. A closed mouth here is one of the answers, allowing the block plane to function as a small smoother. A higher cutting angle is preferred, as we all know, on such timber. It is a simple matter to regrind a LA and Standard Angle blade to a 55 or 60 degree cutting angle. This will work a treat on such timber. Or the mouth may be left open for a coarser, deeper cut. You have the choice. The point being that it is only face grain that benefits from a small mouth.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Adjustable mouth on block plane, necessary?

#7

low angle block with a second blade

Ian in Sydney

>It's easy says I (with tongue firmly in cheek)

Just get a low angle block plane and two blades. Get the second blade supplied with a steeper bevel angle (or grind the steeper bevel yourself)

When you want to change from from low angle to standard angle just swap blades.

Personally I favour adjustable mouth low angle block planes. When I need to take off a lot of material I open the mouth up so I can take a thicker shaving. For finish work I close the mouth down and take much thinner shavings.

hope this helps

Re: Adjustable mouth on block plane, necessary?

#8

Re: Adjustable mouth on block plane, necessary?

dave brown

>Personally, I like the adjustable mouth. I wish that it came on the smaller apron-sized planes but I realize that's not mechanically possible.

When I'm working edge grain with my apron plane, it's possible to take a divot out of the wood if I'm not watching which direction the grain is going. With my larger block plane, I can tighten down the mouth and not worry as much about the grain direction.

I have the veritas apron plane and love it in 80% of the situations that I encounter where its (relatively) large mouth opening isn't an issue. I'm probably going to order the smaller LN block plane with the optional tight mouth for situations where I'm worried about tear out or want to use it as a mini-smoother.

Re: Adjustable mouth on block plane, necessary?

#9

possible v. practical

Clay C in Miami

>LN does make their 102 apron plane with an 'adjustable' (more like 'replaceable') mouth. See below - the LN '102 Special.'

It comes with these two extra mouth plates, and 4 extra screws. The extra mouth plates arrive too-tight(large)-to-use, and can be filed down to give whatever size mouth you like or need.

So, it can be done, but it's not what's usually thought of as 'adjustable.'

Clay


img

Re: Adjustable mouth on block plane, necessary?

#10

Re: possible v. practical

dave brown

>That's awesome! How much of a price premium does that version command?

Re: Adjustable mouth on block plane, necessary?

#11

Re: possible v. practical

Clay C in Miami

>By LN's terms, it's only $25 extra, but by the end of the day, it's close to a $50 premium - it's only available from LN, so you get no discount and pay for shipping.

A regular bronze 102 from finetooljournal is $87 shipped free - this one, before shipping, was $125 (v. $99 for regular), IIRC.

Clay

Re: Adjustable mouth on block plane, necessary?

#12

Re: possible v. practical *LINK*

Don Thompson - Cutler Ridge, Florida

>Is that one of the "Special tight mouth versions ... available for specialized applications"?


Lie-Nielsen Block Plane