Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

LN 60 1/2 Rabbet Block Plane question

Posts

LN 60 1/2 Rabbet Block Plane question

#1

LN 60 1/2 Rabbet Block Plane question

Alan Tolchinsky

>Hi All, I'm thinking of getting one of these or similar for final fit of tenons. Is it good for this AND as a block plane? Or should I just get a shoulder plane and separate LA block plane? This one seems to do it all. Thanks for your thoughts. Alan in Md.

Re: LN 60 1/2 Rabbet Block Plane question

#2

Re: LN 60 1/2 Rabbet Block Plane question

William Claspy in Cleveland

>It's a nice plane. I like mine and use it occasionally for tenon cheek sizing and rebate tweaking.

That said, you may be asking too much of it. It would not function particularly well at trimming tenon shoulders. The blade pitch is correct, but the size and ergonomics of the plane are not suited to that application. And it is fine to use as a plain old low angle block plane, but keep in mind that the blade advance is not as fully functional as other low angle block planes. Nor does it have an adjustable mouth. It also has a very tight mouth, which is great for taking thin shavings across grain (say on a tenon cheek) but not necessarily so good in use as a regular old block plane.

Other methods you can use for sizing tenons to width are 1. sawing more accurately to begin with (I'm still working on that one...) 2. file 3. wide chisel

Trimming tenon shoulders is more difficult with anything but a shoulder plane. Doable, but difficult. And the 60-1/2 R won't really help you much there.

My two cents.

Bill

Re: LN 60 1/2 Rabbet Block Plane question

#3

Re: LN 60 1/2 Rabbet Block Plane question

Dean J in MN

>Alan --

When you say final fit of tenons, what are you thinking? Trimming cheeks, or shoulders? If shoulders, I'd say either a chisel or a shoulder plane. If cheeks I'd say a wide chisel, skew rabbet, or 60-1/2R.

I picked up a 60-1/2R a while back, and have a shoulder plane. At first they were my go to tools for tenons, now I tend to pick up a chisel for both cheeks and shoulders. I suppose you have to find what works best for you, but that was my discovery.

-Dean

Re: LN 60 1/2 Rabbet Block Plane question

#4

Re: LN 60 1/2 Rabbet Block Plane question

John Todd

>I have Lie-Nielsen 60 1/2 R and like it alot. It's good for general Rabbet work and for wide tenon cheeks. I'm not sure it would really take the place of a regular shoulder plane for working on tenon shoulders and it doesn't have an adjustable mouth of a regular block plane.

Of the planes I just mentioned, I personally would by a LA adjustable mouth block first, a medium shoulder second and this plane last. While not essential, it is a very handy plane and I like mine alot.

Why have one plane when you can have three!

Re: LN 60 1/2 Rabbet Block Plane question

#5

Re: LN 60 1/2 Rabbet Block Plane question

Frank D. in Montreal

>My 60.5R is one of my favorite planes. If I had to start over I'd get one before I got a shoulder plane. I use mine for shoulders a lot, I just love the way it feels in my hands. I've compared it to my shoulder planes and it has about as much uselful registration surface when you lay the side down on a tenon to do shoulders (it has even more registraton surface around the blade than my shoulder planes!). This said, as you can see by the other posts not many people seem to like it for shoulders.

It can do a lot of what a LA block can do, but since the blade extends all the way across it will leave track marks when you work on flat surfaces, which is not good sometimes. You'll never be able to use it as a little smoother. For tenon cheeks it makes the job a lot easier and quicker for me than a chisel.

FWIW,

Frank

Re: LN 60 1/2 Rabbet Block Plane question

#6

Thanks guys, some more info. and another ?????

Alan Tolchinsky

>Thanks so much for the info. To clarify I'm going to be using this for shoulder and cheek adjusting so I may need more than one plane to do these jobs. Is there a best place to buy LN planes or are they all priced the same?

Re: LN 60 1/2 Rabbet Block Plane question

#7

Re: Thanks guys, some more info. and another ?????

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>The Lee Valley large shoulder plane I think is the one you want. I think the LN is 30 or 40 bucks more and I can't see that I would choose it over the LV even if they were the same price. I used a 60-1/2R LN for a lot of tenons this winter, wishing all the time that I had a LV shoulder plane because it brings your hand up a little higher off the bench and is easier to apply the force needed to trim a tenon cheek or shoulder, in my opinion.

Re: LN 60 1/2 Rabbet Block Plane question

#8

Re: Thanks guys, some more info. and another ?????

John Todd

>I'd get the Lee Valley shoulder plane, I suppose I'd buy the medium first instead of the large, though they're both nice. I like their adjustable mouth block planes too, though others prefer pretty bronze Lie-Nielsens.

You can get Lie-Nielsen planes including the 60 1/2 R sometimes cheaper at www.thebestthings.com though on their 1-8 Bench Planes, their stock sometimes doesn't have the new chip breaker. By now their inventory has probably cycled around though, but it's best to check before you buy. That caveat doesn't apply to the 60 1/2.

Re: LN 60 1/2 Rabbet Block Plane question

#9

Re: Thanks guys, some more info. and another ????? *LINK*

Andy Lincoln,In Dearborn MI

>Alan,

Fine Tool Journal has the lowest everyday prices on L-N that I've seen.I also believe that shipping is free as well.

Andy


Fine Tool Journal