Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Compare cordless drills on the numbers that matter

Orphan chair

Posts

Orphan chair

#1

Orphan chair

Bob Powers

>During a recent daily walk in our village, I came upon a beautiful little chair. It had been treated very badly, and I was reminded of my edict that a wooden chair must be re-glued when it begins to squeak. The chair was out by the roadside, since it was village bulk trash day, so I picked it up and carried it home, about 3/4 mile. I decided that if anybody questioned the reason for an old white-haired man carrying a chair down the street, I would just tell them that due to my advanced age I sometimes needed to rest.

I don't know how to post a series of pictures, so with your patience, I will just post several submittals. Hope it works.


img

Re: Orphan chair

#2

Re: Orphan chair

Sam Simpson

>Hi Y'all,

Well Bob, my staff and I save a lot of these old chairs, so I hope I can give some guidance without being too ambiguous.

As with all things there is more than one way to skin a cat.

The first choice you need to make is whether or not the chair needs to be totaly taken apart. If the joints are loose now is the time to do that, because they are not going to outlast the new caning if they are already sloppy. This decision will tell you if you get to hold the damaged components as individual items and will have a bearing on what methods can be employed.

One method is to shave the damaged area smooth, add a new piece of wood and reshape the add-on to match the opposite side. Your ability to match the finish will also have a bearing on what methods you choose. Another method is to use one of the composite products such as Tuff-Carv. (a Bondo cousin) You then shape the blob of hard material to the desired shape. This method is often selected when the components cannot be held independently and conventional wood working tools cannot be employed.

As far as finishing the two different methods, matching the old finish is going to be more of a faux paint job than a simple finish, so I don't think finishing has too much influence over the material choice.

Another option is to remake the entire damaged component. However, in this case the damaged areas are not extensive and the resulting losses of large areas of original finish don't warrant the total remake of components.

The choice I would make in this case is to use the composite material. This choice allows repair without any extra loss. No extra shaving of existing materials will be necessary. The damage does not appear to structurally weaken the joinery to an extent that necessitates rework of the joints with solid wood. And the extent of the repainted faux finish can be isolated to the damaged areas only.

There are several good books which will guide you to methods of in-painting on antiques repairs. Your first attempt will almost certainly not be a keeper. So be prepared for a few tries at it.

Regards Sam Simpson.

Re: Orphan chair

#3

Re: Orphan chair

Bob Powers

>Sam,

Thanks for the advice. I'm not too confident about being able to take the chair apart. Somebody at some time decided that the best way to hold things together was to drive small brads through the dowels. Do you have a method of getting the nails out short of major excavation?

Re: Orphan chair

#4

Re: Orphan chair

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>There are two ways I have successfully removed these brads. Sometimes, you can get the tip of a pair of finely tuned curved jaw wire cutters under the head of the brad and pull it out. Then, you can steam out the dent made by the wire cutters. The other method is to use a pin punch about the same diameter as the head of the brad, but not a tapered nail set, and drive the brad all the way through. That method requires puttying two surfaces, however. If the weasel was smart, he put the brad in where it would show the least. If you can, find the weasel who originally put the brad in the chair, and use his hand as a cushion between the chair leg and the bench, to prevent any more damage to the chair when you remove the brad.

Re: Orphan chair

#5

Re: Orphan chair

Sam Simpson

>Hi Y'all,

Bob, the age of this chair puts it into a class of semi-handmade. It was assembled in a production line fashion. Small nails were often used during the assembly stage to hold things together while the glue dried.

Again a decision has to be made. Will you do more harm than good by the removal of the nails. The best method of removal is to drive the nail further, to a point that it just begins to protrude through the other side. When it's exit point is located, you drive it back the way it came until it protrudes through the original entry hole far enough to get a good grip on it. Place a small leather washer around the nail head, prior to extraction with pincers, to prevent bruising of the surrounding surface. There are many times that the wood is far too brittle to allow these practices, and more damage results from the attempt. In such cases the attempt is halted after the second failure and a method of glue injections is adopted.

Injecting hot hide glue into the joint is easily done if a few practices are employed. Those are -- drill a small hole into the joint cavity, the same size as the needle (20 gauge works best, #60 drill bit) Keep the hypo-needle warm by immersing it into the double boiler, and inject in a pattern that will allow for clamping of the framework in a succession of boxed elements i.e. back frame, stretcher frame, seat frame and so on. The use of tourniquets will provide better clamping than metal bar type clamps.

Regards Sam Simpson.

Re: Orphan chair

#6

Re: Orphan chair

Bob Powers

>Thanks again Sam. I'll do as you suggest.

Your comment about the age of the chair and its being semi-handmade interests me. Have you a sense of the age? It shows lots of wear along the edges of the seat. It has also apparently been in bad shape for a long time but was still being used, since the dowels that are exposed show considerable wear from movement.

Re: Orphan chair

#7

Re: Orphan chair

Sam Simpson

>Hi Y'all,

Bob, the chair is of an age between 1840 and 1880. That date can be narrowed down by identifying the method of fastening of the seat rail to the back legs. In the earlier chairs the seat was let in and pegged from the side of the back leg. On the later chairs the seat was still let in to a slot but a screw was driven from the back of the leg. The screw was covered with a plug. The screws can be identified and the date narrowed to a decade. I think I saw band saw marks inside the back seat rail, this would date the chair to after 1865.

The chair was probably made in Grand Rapids, MI. A good description of the factories of that period can be found in the book -- "Four Centuries of American Furniture" by Oscar P. Fitzgerald. Page 245

Sometimes remnants of a label can be found. Though there were more than fifteen furniture factories operating in Grand Rapids, there where three big ones.

Berkey and Gay, Phoenix Furniture company, and Nelson Matter and company. I have seen the name Phoenix on a chair identical to yours, so I'm fairly confident that's what you have.

Regards Sam Simpson.

Re: Orphan chair

#8

Re: Orphan chair

Bob Powers

>Sam, you are an absolute wealth of information, and I am most appreciative. I took another look at the chair, and the seat is let in to a notch in the back leg and pegged from the side. There are saw marks on the back seat rail, but they are at an angle to the vertical, and were made with a coarse tooth saw.

I am not a collector of antiques, but this one just grabbed me. There it was, sitting by the side of the road along with another element of our throw-away society, an IBM Selectric typewriter!

Thanks again for the help.

Re: Orphan chair

#9

Re: Orphan chair

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>Those are good tips, Sam. What do you prefer to use for punches?

I'm curious about the use of brads during assembly, since most of the chairs I have had to repair did not consistently use brads in all the joints. (Probably most of them weren't from Grand Rapds, however.) That is why I assumed the brads had been added later, especially since I think I have noted a strong correlation between nailed joints and joints that have needed subsequent repairs.

In these cases especially, it is imperative that the nail be removed. The weaker the joint, the less likely that an injection of additional hide glue will restore it to soundness. And, of course, if the spindle has broken at the nailed joint, then the joint must be taken apart before a replacement spindle can be built and installed, or before the broken spindle can be restored.

Also, I have found that previously repaired joints may not have been reglued with hide glue, in which case, it is better to disassemble and clean all the junk out of the joint before introducing fresh hide glue.

I agree that sometimes injecting new hide glue with a hypodermic needle is the best approach to stabilizing the joint.

Re: Orphan chair

#10

Re: Orphan chair

Bob Powers

>After reading William's message concerning the use of brads in the construction of furniture, I took another look at my orphan. The only brads that I can spot go through the front to back leg spindles. Interestingly enough, those are the only solid joints on the chair. I suspect they are original, since they don't show the damage incurred by other attempts to repair the chair.

Re: Orphan chair

#11

Punches

Sam Simpson

>Hi Y'all,

William, I made a set of custom punches for this very purpose. They are fashioned from old auto valve lifters. About five inches long and 1/4" diameter. The ends are ground long and thin, without a taper, in different diameters (pin gauge thickness) and have a small dimple in the end.

Selecting the correct punch, or drift as they are often called, will result in a hole no larger than the original pin head.

As far as the pins being original to the chair, it is often difficult to be sure until you have removed a couple. But once removed, mid nineteenth century pins are easily identified. They have a longer sharper point than most modern pins. I often think of the shape being more like an old gramophone needle. They are often better formed and have fewer less distinctive clinch marks than a modern pin. A modern pin by contrast is often coated and ill formed with aggressive clinch marks.

The reason pins where used in the manufacture of these chairs, is not because the pins offer any additional strength, but rather because the stretchers where glued and clamped in a jig. So that the jig was not occupied while the glue dried, pins were added and the chair passed on to the next stage of the assembly line.

Regards Sam Simpson