Re: Orphan chair
Sam Simpson
>Hi Y'all,
Well Bob, my staff and I save a lot of these old chairs, so I hope I can give some guidance without being too ambiguous.
As with all things there is more than one way to skin a cat.
The first choice you need to make is whether or not the chair needs to be totaly taken apart. If the joints are loose now is the time to do that, because they are not going to outlast the new caning if they are already sloppy. This decision will tell you if you get to hold the damaged components as individual items and will have a bearing on what methods can be employed.
One method is to shave the damaged area smooth, add a new piece of wood and reshape the add-on to match the opposite side. Your ability to match the finish will also have a bearing on what methods you choose. Another method is to use one of the composite products such as Tuff-Carv. (a Bondo cousin) You then shape the blob of hard material to the desired shape. This method is often selected when the components cannot be held independently and conventional wood working tools cannot be employed.
As far as finishing the two different methods, matching the old finish is going to be more of a faux paint job than a simple finish, so I don't think finishing has too much influence over the material choice.
Another option is to remake the entire damaged component. However, in this case the damaged areas are not extensive and the resulting losses of large areas of original finish don't warrant the total remake of components.
The choice I would make in this case is to use the composite material. This choice allows repair without any extra loss. No extra shaving of existing materials will be necessary. The damage does not appear to structurally weaken the joinery to an extent that necessitates rework of the joints with solid wood. And the extent of the repainted faux finish can be isolated to the damaged areas only.
There are several good books which will guide you to methods of in-painting on antiques repairs. Your first attempt will almost certainly not be a keeper. So be prepared for a few tries at it.
Regards Sam Simpson.