Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Premium Live Edge Slabs, Hand-Selected in the Berkshires. Shop Unique Hardwood Pieces.

LV Honing Guide Mk 2 � Second Impressions: Chisels

Posts

LV Honing Guide Mk 2 � Second Impressions: Chisels

#1

LV Honing Guide Mk 2 � Second Impressions: Chisels

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>It is my intention to post a series of mini-reviews on the LV Honing Guide (Mk II) as I gain experience with it. The initial post a few days ago were First Impressions from observations made at a recent sharpening workshop I ran in Perth. The Mk II was only used on plane blades at that time. While the opinion of all participants, including myself, was very favourable, the use of parallel sided, wide plane blades is a fairly safe test for honing guides. It is the narrow, wedge-shaped chisel blades that offer the greatest challenge: will they fit, will they remain square, how thick a blade can be used, how narrow a blade can be used securely, how short can one go, and what angles may be honed? These questions are examined here.

The chisels on test

I have included a selection of chisels I own, chosen to challenge the Mk II. They include:

Japanese chisels: bench, dovetail and mortise chisels

Western paring chisels: Witherby and A E Berg

Western mortise chisels: Ward

Firmer chisels: very short Japanese chisel, very large Woodcock chisel.

Measurements

Measurements included the length of the blade, its width, thickness at entry and exit to the guide�s hold down, and the bevel angle employed.

Since all the chisels had no difficulty in being held in the Mk II for honing, and at the desired bevel angle, the defining evaluation was a rating of the stability with which the blade was secured in the hold down. Ratings of 0-5 were employed, with a 5 being the best rating (rigidly stable), 4 next (can be moved with much force), then 3 (can be moved with moderate force), 2 (can be moved with mild force), 1 (can be moved without force), 0 (cannot be secured at all). Note that all the rating are subjective (i.e. I did not measure the force applied). In my opinion, a rating of 3 is just satisfactory, a rating of 4 is good, and a rating of 5 is excellent.

Notes about the Mk II

All these chisel blades had one thing in common � they tapered. Some tapered more than others. The Mk II hold down attempts to manage this by being able to pivot as it is tightened, thus being able to provide even pressure across the full width of the blade�s face. There also appears to be a plastic lining (non-slip) inside the hold down. My feeling is that this material was not working optimally since some blades could be made to slide around (unless high levels of down force was applied through the screws). Perhaps this plastic could be made from a softer material?

The other observation is in regard to the hold down itself. I have previously noted the importance of maintaining equal pressure at each end (via the screws) as otherwise the blade will be skewed in the holder. This becomes more critical as blade become increasingly narrower. Maintaining equal pressure is achieved by eye. I found that unbalanced pressure would lead to the blade pivoting more readily in the holder, and that this would be a sign that the screws needed to be adjusted.

Results

The overall conclusion was that the greater the �wedge factor�, the more the blades were at risk for movement in the hold down. All the blades were considered to be held satisfactorally, but some were only just satisfactory.

I have included details of all measurements below for reference.

(1) Japanese chisels:

18mm wide bench chisel

60mm long blade, 30 degree bevel, 6mm entry to hold down, 6.5mm exit from hold down. Rated 3/5

42mm wide bench chisel

60mm blade, 30 degree bevel, 7mm entry, 7mm exit. Rated 5/5

3mm wide dovetail chisel

63mm blade, 30 degree bevel, 7mm entry, 7.5mm exit, Rated 5/5

6mm wide dovetail chisel

63mm blade, 30 degree bevel, 6mm entry, 6.5mm exit. Rated 4/5

9mm wide mortise chisel

65mm blade, 35 degree bevel, 11mm entry, 11mm exit. Rated 5/5

(2) Western paring chisels:

�� Witherby - 90mm blade, 25 degree bevel, 5mm entry, 6mm exit. Rated 3/5

�� Witherby - 90mm blade, 25 degree bevel, 4mm entry, 4mm exit. Rated 4/5

�� A E Berg - 90mm blade, 20 degree bevel, 5.5mm entry, 6mm exit. Rated 5/5

�� A E Berg - 90mm blade, 20 degree bevel, 4mm entry, 4mm exit. Rated 4/5

(3) Other Mortice chisels:

�� Ward - 130mm blade, 30 degree bevel, 11mm entry, 12mm exit. Rated 3/5

(4) Firmer chisels:

3/8� Woodcock - 125mm blade, 25 degree bevel, 4mm entry, 4mm exit. Rated 4/5

�� Japanese � 37mm blade, 30 degree bevel, 5mm entry, 6mm exit. Rated 4/5

Summary

A wide range of chisels were examined, extending from the flatter Western pairing chisels, to shorter Japanese bench chisels, triangular dovetail chisels, thick mortise chisels, and even a very short Japanese firmer chisel. Bevel angles included 20, 25, 30 and 35 degrees.

All chisels were managed satisfactorally, however it was noted that the greater the wedge shape, the greater the risk for moving out of square. With narrow chisels, the Mk II hold down requires careful adjustment to prevent this occuring. I'm sure that experience will provide further insights into its use (since I am likely missing something here).

Picture below of the chisels used here.

Regards from Perth

Derek


img

Re: LV Honing Guide Mk 2 � Second Impressions: Chisels

#2

JL

Re: LV Honing Guide Mk 2 � Second Impressions: Chi

JL

>Many thanks - I think :). Now I am tempted to go out and buy one.

Re: LV Honing Guide Mk 2 � Second Impressions: Chisels

#3

Re: LV Honing Guide Mk 2 � Second Impressions: Chi

Bobby Perez

>It is very difficult to have the best of both worlds in the Mk II honing guide. Plane blades are flat and chisel comes in different shapes. As little I have read, the MK II is very close to achieve this but there is always the risk to move the chisel out of square as noted by Derek. It is my recommendation that LV works on a new honing guide for chisels only and continues to improve the MK II for plane blades with some chisel honing capability.

Re: LV Honing Guide Mk 2 � Second Impressions: Chisels

#4

You're A Gentleman & A Scholar, Derek

Tom Colligan, Peoria

>

Re: LV Honing Guide Mk 2 � Second Impressions: Chisels

#5

A minor correction, and further examinations

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>There are two corrections that I need to make.

The first is to the sizes of the Berg chisels. There were not �� and �� as stated, but 1/8� and �� instead. Measurements apply respectively (1/8� for ��, and �� for ��).

The second correction is in regard to the �plastic lining (non-slip) inside the hold down� (see �Notes about the Mk II). I have now examined this more closely and discovered that it is just anodized paint.

Further examinations

Since I believed that there was a benefit to be had from a non-slip in this area, I did glue some soft thin rubber sheeting to the bar that supported the face of the chisel (this plays no part in determining the honing angle). This made little noticeable difference to the stability of the chisels that rated 3/5.

It occurred to me to compare the clamping features of the MK II against the Mk I among some of these chisels, particularly the ones that rated 3/5.

18mm Japanese butt chisel

�� Witherby paring chisel

�� Ward mortise chisel

The Mk I was judged more stable on all three of these chisels. That is, there was less movement once the hold down was tightened.

Before this is seen as an indictment of the Mk II, consider that the 3/5 rating was still satisfactory for honing. That is, it is stable enough not to move while honing unless the blade is bumped moderately hard. A 4/5 grading is preferred, however, which is what I would rate the Mk I on these three chisels. Further, the blade of the Japanese chisel was almost maxed out on the Mk I with little further adjustment possible. By contrast, the Mk II had considerable adjustment still on tap.

Conclusions

Keep in mind that we are discussing rather extreme chisel shapes above. The majority of chisels are more flat than wedge shaped, such as paring and butt chisels, and these do not pose much of a problem for the Mk II. Even the thick Japanese mortise chisel was very stable.

There is also one outstanding difference between the Mk I and Mk II, which was mentioned earlier, that being the Mk II�s much greater ease of set up.

Having said this, I feel the need to better understand the pros and cons of the different hold down systems utilised by the Mk I and Mk II. I will report on this later.

Regards from Perth

Derek