hollow grinds and geography
Clay C in Miami
>So, while looking for something else, I came across this posting by Christopher Fitch:
"Hijack! sorta... I recently watched a new episode of David Mark's Woodworks show on DIY about sharpening. [...] He ... demonstrated using [a small hand grinder] on a japanese chisel to grind a bevel. I somehow doubt you will see Norm do that..."
I saw that too, and now it strikes me - I have seen recommendations (one from Derek in Oz) that one should not put a hollow bevel on Japanese chisels. I assumed (without thinking about it much) that the harder steel of the laminated chisels is too brittle to support a hollow grind, and will chip.
But, I've also seen some well-trained woodworkers put hollow grinds on Japanese chisels, and it occurs to me that folks here likely know a lot more about the topic than these occasional references that simply say 'don't.'
I'd also note that Marks (and some others I've seen) not only use a hollow grind, but do so on a very small (6" dia.?) hand wheel, with a correspondingly short-radius hollow. Just instinctively, it seems that a Tormek-sized (11" dia.?) hollow would be less of a problem than a short-radius one.
And, what about Japanese plane irons? Other laminated plane irons? Would a hollow-ground iron cause more of a problem (i.e., chip easier) in a bevel-down plane than a bevel-up? (That also seems instinctively so ...)
Many questions, I know, but a short search didn't turn up answers ...
Clay



