Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

This is the most versatile work station you will ever use

hollow grinds and geography

Posts

hollow grinds and geography

#1

hollow grinds and geography

Clay C in Miami

>So, while looking for something else, I came across this posting by Christopher Fitch:

"Hijack! sorta... I recently watched a new episode of David Mark's Woodworks show on DIY about sharpening. [...] He ... demonstrated using [a small hand grinder] on a japanese chisel to grind a bevel. I somehow doubt you will see Norm do that..."

I saw that too, and now it strikes me - I have seen recommendations (one from Derek in Oz) that one should not put a hollow bevel on Japanese chisels. I assumed (without thinking about it much) that the harder steel of the laminated chisels is too brittle to support a hollow grind, and will chip.

But, I've also seen some well-trained woodworkers put hollow grinds on Japanese chisels, and it occurs to me that folks here likely know a lot more about the topic than these occasional references that simply say 'don't.'

I'd also note that Marks (and some others I've seen) not only use a hollow grind, but do so on a very small (6" dia.?) hand wheel, with a correspondingly short-radius hollow. Just instinctively, it seems that a Tormek-sized (11" dia.?) hollow would be less of a problem than a short-radius one.

And, what about Japanese plane irons? Other laminated plane irons? Would a hollow-ground iron cause more of a problem (i.e., chip easier) in a bevel-down plane than a bevel-up? (That also seems instinctively so ...)

Many questions, I know, but a short search didn't turn up answers ...

Clay

Re: hollow grinds and geography

#2

Re: hollow grinds and geography

R.J.Whelan

>Clay .... I hollow grind all of my chisels and irons (both Japanese and others). I bought a Tormek about 3 years ago and the larger diameter wheel does seem to help with the Japanese chisels. I did try flat honing the Japanese chisels at one time and the tendency toward chipping on the aris was lower, but not by a lot.

FWIW ... rj

Re: hollow grinds and geography

#3

Re: hollow grinds and geography

Wiley Horne

>Hi Clay,

Just my experience. I've learned that hollow grinding is a key step to fast, easy, and effective sharpening. Mainly chisels and bench plane blades, not gouges or molding plane blades. I'm sorry I waited so long to start.

My experience hollow grinding Japanese chisels is good. Resharpen without breaking work rhythm. The conventional wisdom is not to do it (see Odate), but Krenov did fine with it, and I seem to recall Mr. Charlesworth doing it as well on his Japanese chisels. That emboldened me to try, and I've never looked back. Hollow grind is initially about 25 degrees, with cutting edge honed to about 28 degrees. After a few sharpenings, you're at 28 degrees overall. I do this freehand by eye and feel, and the few times I've measured, these are the approx. numbers, and it hasn't varied more 1 degree or so.

There is a separate consideration with Japanese plane blades: Unlike chisels, they have to be tapped out from time to time. When you tap out, the meat of the iron backing is absorbing and spreading the energy of the hammer blow, and transmitting the energy into the hard cutting steel to persuade it to move. I worry that hollow grinding the iron backing reduces the safety factor when tapping out. It puts the hammer blow closer to the hard steel. And if the hard steel cracks (anywhere but right at the edge), it's all over for that blade. So I take it very easy when hollow grinding a Japanese plane blade.

I would not argue for a second with someone who takes issue with hollow grinding Japanese chisels. There are some good commonsense arguments for not doing it. But I've not had a practical problem, so the benefit of making sharpening fast and easy outweighs conceptual issues.

Wiley

Re: hollow grinds and geography

#4

I tried it once...

Scott Burr in Ben Lomond CA

>I chipped a japanese DT chisel and took it to the 6" grinder to grind the chip out. I didn't like the results of the hollow grind. Seemed more prone to chipping to me. So I attacked it with water stones and removed it. Japanese chisels seems to work better to me with out a hollow grind IMHO.