The times they are a-changin' (long)
Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)
>Hi Dick
This is a topic that has potential for much emotion, simply because it has arguments that support it and others that oppose it at the extremes. We had a recent discussion along these lines on the Porch, which centred around proponents for and against the use of honing guides for sharpening. There were some who were catagorical that one should learn to hone freehand, and others who believed that the working with wood was more important.
My argument is that we are ushering in a new era in handplanes, one that is going to insist on a higher degree of discipline and exactness when sharpening blades. This is not because there is a moving towards the machining mentality of some obsessional power tool users, but rather because the new order of hand planes demands precision in setting up.
I describe the following rather simplistically, but sufficiently I hope, since I wish to make a point and not ramble on and on.
If all we used were bevel down planes, then there is no need to be precise when establishing the bevel angle. 25 or 29 or 31 degrees - it does not make much difference. Honing freehand is not going to be penalised if we wander off a designated, say, 25 degree objective. Even honing a microbevel - difficult enough to do freehand - is possible since it matters little if these are off by a few degrees.
However, we are now witnessing a small revolution in handplane design in the form of the increasing numbers of bevel up planes coming into the market. The advantage of these planes is not just that they are fundamentally a better design than the bevel down brigade (since they offer improved blade stability, with resultant reduced chatter), and that they do this at a lesser financial cost as well, but these bevel up planes are just so more adaptable and versatile than anything else. It is the versatility factor that demands a the precision I mentioned earlier on. Where it matters little at what angle the bevel down blade is honed, it matters all what the bevel up blade is honed at since this is what determines their cutting angle. There is a vaste difference between a blade that cuts at 45 degrees and one that cuts at 55 or 60 degrees. So now we need the jigs and guides to hone to precise angles.
Along with this change comes a growing awareness - driven by teachers such as David Charlesworth - that there are sharpening strategies that can reduce the amount of time needed to get a sharp edge and, further more, that it costs little extra time to take this to a near-perfect level. The age of micro-bevels and back-bevels (from the "ruler trick") is now with us.
Yet another component is the advancement in sharpening equipment: better and better waterstones that hone fast and at lower microns, and powered sharpening equipment that makes it a less physical activity, so that we may be willing to take the time to do it properly rather than give up halfway.
I hate sharpening because I am somewhat hyperactive and get impatient when I need to stop in the middle of a task to rehone a blade. Ironically, this has led me to take a keen interest in sharpening, if only to find a way to do it well but as quickly as possible. As my sharpening has improved, so I have come to appreciate a really sharp blade. I tend to work with difficult timbers (Australian!) and these are merciless with less than well-sharpened edges. They also require high angle planes, so the combination of these factors means that I must pay careful attention to the way in which my blades are prepared, particularly among the bevel up ones I use.
In summary, I do see an increasing move towards a science of handtool use in woodworking today, one that promises higher levels of performance at an affordable price, that was once the domain of the very high-end tools in the past. We do have a choice - to go down this path or not. Personally, I do both. I enjoy the simplicity of older tools as much as the higher octane performance of the new generation.
Regards from Perth
Derek