Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Want Better Milling & Firewood Knowledge?

Is David Charlesworth Too Good

Posts

Is David Charlesworth Too Good

#1

Is David Charlesworth Too Good

dick cummings in very southern mississippi

>I have been a fan of Charlesworth for a few years now and do use his techniques for sharpening,hand planing etc. However, I often think of the cliches.."Better is the Enemy of Good Enough", "Is The Cost Comensurate With The Gain?" and "Who Cares About a 1000th Anyhow".

What say you all? Have we gone too far in search of perfection? Are we emulating Lexus in our endless pursuit of perfection?

I spent a few 1000 hours using a Scanning Electron Microscope while writing my Master's Thesis in a metalurgy area and do know what high power magnification can make an "edge" look like. I do not have the time to get a perfect edge on a plane blade or chisel. I do try to get somewhat close.

Any comments out there?

Dick

Re: Is David Charlesworth Too Good

#2

I don't understand what you're asking?

Bryan in Broad Ripple, IN

>

Re: Is David Charlesworth Too Good

#3

The times they are a-changin' (long)

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Dick

This is a topic that has potential for much emotion, simply because it has arguments that support it and others that oppose it at the extremes. We had a recent discussion along these lines on the Porch, which centred around proponents for and against the use of honing guides for sharpening. There were some who were catagorical that one should learn to hone freehand, and others who believed that the working with wood was more important.

My argument is that we are ushering in a new era in handplanes, one that is going to insist on a higher degree of discipline and exactness when sharpening blades. This is not because there is a moving towards the machining mentality of some obsessional power tool users, but rather because the new order of hand planes demands precision in setting up.

I describe the following rather simplistically, but sufficiently I hope, since I wish to make a point and not ramble on and on.

If all we used were bevel down planes, then there is no need to be precise when establishing the bevel angle. 25 or 29 or 31 degrees - it does not make much difference. Honing freehand is not going to be penalised if we wander off a designated, say, 25 degree objective. Even honing a microbevel - difficult enough to do freehand - is possible since it matters little if these are off by a few degrees.

However, we are now witnessing a small revolution in handplane design in the form of the increasing numbers of bevel up planes coming into the market. The advantage of these planes is not just that they are fundamentally a better design than the bevel down brigade (since they offer improved blade stability, with resultant reduced chatter), and that they do this at a lesser financial cost as well, but these bevel up planes are just so more adaptable and versatile than anything else. It is the versatility factor that demands a the precision I mentioned earlier on. Where it matters little at what angle the bevel down blade is honed, it matters all what the bevel up blade is honed at since this is what determines their cutting angle. There is a vaste difference between a blade that cuts at 45 degrees and one that cuts at 55 or 60 degrees. So now we need the jigs and guides to hone to precise angles.

Along with this change comes a growing awareness - driven by teachers such as David Charlesworth - that there are sharpening strategies that can reduce the amount of time needed to get a sharp edge and, further more, that it costs little extra time to take this to a near-perfect level. The age of micro-bevels and back-bevels (from the "ruler trick") is now with us.

Yet another component is the advancement in sharpening equipment: better and better waterstones that hone fast and at lower microns, and powered sharpening equipment that makes it a less physical activity, so that we may be willing to take the time to do it properly rather than give up halfway.

I hate sharpening because I am somewhat hyperactive and get impatient when I need to stop in the middle of a task to rehone a blade. Ironically, this has led me to take a keen interest in sharpening, if only to find a way to do it well but as quickly as possible. As my sharpening has improved, so I have come to appreciate a really sharp blade. I tend to work with difficult timbers (Australian!) and these are merciless with less than well-sharpened edges. They also require high angle planes, so the combination of these factors means that I must pay careful attention to the way in which my blades are prepared, particularly among the bevel up ones I use.

In summary, I do see an increasing move towards a science of handtool use in woodworking today, one that promises higher levels of performance at an affordable price, that was once the domain of the very high-end tools in the past. We do have a choice - to go down this path or not. Personally, I do both. I enjoy the simplicity of older tools as much as the higher octane performance of the new generation.

Regards from Perth

Derek

Re: Is David Charlesworth Too Good

#4

Re: Is David Charlesworth Too Good

Alice Frampton, UK

>I think sometimes you need precision. And sometimes you don't. The trick is to know when.

Cheers, Alf

Available for courses in woodworking philosophy up a mountain near you - bring your own rice bowl...

Re: Is David Charlesworth Too Good

#5

Caveat: Paralysis by analysis.

Matt Malin

>I am teaching my daughter how to play the guitar. Like most kids if she messes up practicing she gets frustrated and it messes with her concentration. I told her, the first couple months almost every sound you make is going to sound like crap. Live with it, it will get better. I have found that over the last year I couldn't live without a honing jig and would never sharpen and hone freehand. Now I freehand sharpen my Two Cherries chisels on water stones. It takes seconds, works well and it comes from practice with Marples blue handles.

Basically, like playing the guitar, precision and concision come from concentration and practice.

If you analyze the quality of your early freehand efforts to death you are going to just get frustrated.

Avoid paralysis by analysis it stymies more budding craftsmen than anything else.

Peace and have a great weekend!!!

Re: Is David Charlesworth Too Good

#6

Re: Is David Charlesworth Too Good

George Huron

>I am of the belief that for most sharpening of a plane iron, chisel or gouge it should take no more than 60 to 90 seconds to end up with a razor sharp blade. If the blade needs regrinding, add another 30 seconds.

Sharpening is like exercise. If you don't make it easy to do, you probably won't do it often enough.

Re: Is David Charlesworth Too Good

#7

What's your point?

Adam Cherubini

>Is Charlesworth fussy? I think so. And so is Jan Vermeer. I love him too.

Is your point that fussy is bad? See, I'll agree with you up to this point. The value we place on the end result is entirely subjective, and that's important to remember.

Jan Vermeer's work, like Charlesworth's, is the work of a master. I like it. But lots of people like painted saws too.

Adam

Re: Is David Charlesworth Too Good

#8

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Is David Charlesworth Too Good

Jim in Burlington Ontario

>I'm certainly of the mind that after looking at pictures of his work that he's onto something big. He writes for a english magazine and after reading the extent he goes with all his work to achieve the perfect finish on it is well worth it. For a man with a PHD you should know if the end was worth the journey to you.

Re: Is David Charlesworth Too Good

#9

Why did I just know...

Mark Harrison -- in Sydney, Australia

>that you would bring painted saws into this :-)

Re: Is David Charlesworth Too Good

#10

"good enough" is the enemy of excellence

Moses Yoder in White Pigeon, MI

>The difference between an average job and an excellent job requires very little additional effort. If I were building a bookcase, I could build a bookcase and say "It's good enough, it works, and it's functional". I am already paying for the materials, plus investing a certain amount of time to build it. And, I am going to have to live with the results for a number of years. I can choose to put in some additional effort into the work while I'm doing the work that goes well beyond just "good enough". I can push my skills to the limit and do it to the absolute best of my ability. The difference overall is that with a little bit more time spent, I can have a project that I will cherish for years to come, and think about all the little pieces of extra effort I put into it that no one else will ever see. In my opinion, this is living beyond the rat race. To do something to the absolute best of your ability, and to try and increase you skill level at the same time, with no reward for it other than the effort itself.

Re: Is David Charlesworth Too Good

#11

It works both ways, for me.

Don Thompson - Cutler Ridge, Florida

>If I go for a while without doing any sharpening, I have to re-learn the techniques.

Don - planning for a sharp-a-thon this weekend.

Re: Is David Charlesworth Too Good

#12

Re: The times they are a-changin' (long)

dick cummings in very southern mississippi

>Thank you for the response. As I noted I am a Charlesworth fan and simply wanted some comments from other people.

Thanks Again Dick

Re: Is David Charlesworth Too Good

#13

Re: What's your point?

dick cummings in very southern mississippi

>I have no real point. The purpose of my posting was to simply solicit comment and that point has been achieved.

Thanks for your response. Oh, I could make some terrible pun about Charlesworth and "points" on a woodworking tool :-( I'll leave those puns up to ya'll.

Dick

Re: Is David Charlesworth Too Good

#14

Re: "good enough" is the enemy of excellence

dick cummings in very southern mississippi

>Thanks for your comments. What each woodworker has to decide is how well to make a piece. My workshop furniture is not as good as my "workbench". I definately spent a lot of time on it.

Dick

Re: Is David Charlesworth Too Good

#15

Re: The times they are a-changin' (long)

Richard R

>I think sometimes we get a little over-excited when it comes to thinking of newer and better ways to get things done in the shop. I'm as guilty of this as anyone. We spend tons of time contemplating how some jig might be cobbled together, when that time would be much better spent by simply teaching our hands to do it. I blame this mostly on the fact that there isn't an apprenticeship system like we had before. We're forced to learn by watching videos, reading books, and asking questions on internet forums. There's really nothing wrong with this. For lack of a better term, I think we miss the forest for the trees (did I get that right?).

Anyway, I'll get to the main point. When you think about it, a plane is nothing more than a jig to hold the iron for the desired presentation to the wood. The wood doesn't know what the bevel angle is, or even if the iron is bevel-up or bevel-down for that matter. The reason a block plane is bevel-up is because it needs to be, not because it cuts end grain any better. The lower angle of block planes requires this. If the bevel were up, then the cutting edge could not contact the wood at this lower angle. Now, I appreciate that the companies making the new high quality planes have re-thought the designs and are providing them at a lower cost to boot. But if these new designs require such a high degree of precision that we need a jig just to sharpen and hone the irons, count me out. I can produce just as nice a surface with a 100-year-old relic, a high-carbon iron, and a bit of hand-honing. I'm not interested in breaking out a micro-superdeluxe scope to view the produced surface, because we shouldn't be caring about such stuff.

Regarding sharpening, I think we've gone a bit overboard in that area, too. Woodworkers simply do not need 15,000 or 30,000 grit stones (and the prices that come with them). Surgeons and the like may need them, but we don't. When you bring an edge to that degree of sharpness, it becomes more fragile. After a few swipes, it's gone and you're back to where you'd be if you stopped at 4000 or so anyway. Especially if you're cutting end grain.

We're perfectly capable of producing precise, tight-fitting joints and glass smooth surfaces with tools that have been around forever. It's a shame that many won't experience it because they think it's either too hard, or our age of instant gratification has clouded their minds.

(BTW Derek, this post isn't directed at you, it just happens that you already had "long" in the subject line)

Am I just a knuckle-dragging oaf? Chime in and tell me...I enjoy topics like this.

RR

Re: Is David Charlesworth Too Good

#16

Perfection is.....

Todd Hughes

>knowing when good enough is good enough....I agree with Richard ...I think to so many people the real goal is not the end product but all the stuff they have to do to get there.Can anyone really look at your completed work and tell you used a plane with a NASA flat sole and a blade so sharp just the shadow from the edge will shave the hair on your arm? I really doubt it. But hey this is what makes these people happy, the process so I am glad for them. I do think that many new guys get caught up in all the modern day wood working rituals and in the end just serves to slow them down from learning the basics they need.....Todd

Re: Is David Charlesworth Too Good

#17

30,000 grit stones?

James Watriss

>Well, fair enough, probably not to that extreme. I wanted at first to point out that more polished edges aren't actually more fragile, quite the contrary. The edge bevel determines most of how well the edge will hold up to the wood.

That said, I think you have a point in that the first 2 strokes will usually take that 30,000 grit edge and turn it into an 8,000 grit edge or less... but the problem is that advances in metallurgy have made this a changing point.

For example: Anyone who's used and is used to Marples/Irwin chisels can tell you that they don't hold an edge for crap. It's just too soft. The problem is also a question of the grain in the metal... it's just too course. What this meant for me is that I was forced to put that mirror polish on the thing to keep it going, becuase as soon as it started to dull down, the edge started to crumble back, and the whole thing went to crap in a hurry. Ditto the OEM steel in the old record planes, back when they made them.

On the other hand, I finally got a set of the L-N chisels with the A2 steel, and decided I was going to give them treatment that, if they were marples chisels, would have been considered unwarranted and unconscionable abuse. They start to dull down a bit, but they don't start to crumble back, because the steel is much finer. So I've been playing with increased levels of sharpness, because the steel seems to be able to support the angles I've been using.

So maybe it's not just the angles... maybe it's the steel in the blades. It seems that once they start to go, some of them really break up, and some hold up... which goes back, really, to the original point. With new steels out there, that are getting better and better, how sharp is too sharp? If the steel could sustain a 30,000 grit polish for a reasonable period of time, would it still be too sharp?

I dunno. I'll side with the serious sharpenng camp on this one, simply because I tend to think that people who are that conscientious about their tools are equally so about their work, and that's why they go to such lengths to make clean edges on their tools. That's not to say that folks who keep things "sharp enough" are bad folks... I'm one of them, sometimes, but I've met a few people who think that the bench grinder will make things "sharp enough."

Re: Is David Charlesworth Too Good

#18

When "I" changes to "we"

Frank Mutchler in Colorado Springs

>there is a subtle but important change in emphasis.

What I like, what works well for me, what interests me, what I think is important, what I think is silly, what I feel, etc. may very well be 180 degrees off of someone else regarding the same subject. That's fine...I can choose to, or choose not to, learn from someone else and so modify my behavior.

When "I" changes to "we", I think of the dynamic as "group-think". I try hard but not always successfully to avoid it. In the last sentence of the above paragraph I had to go back and change "we" to "I" and "our" to "my".

Re: Is David Charlesworth Too Good

#19

Re: 30,000 grit stones?

Richard R

>James,

Yeah, I admit I was being extreme bringing up the 30k thing. But I did watch a Shapton video advertisement touting their higher end stones. Guy in the video was honing an iron and picked up the iron with the stone stuck to the bevel. Big deal. I can do that with my Arkansas or my 4000 waterstone. Marketing/advertising at its best, I suppose.

Guess I should've given my post a needs vs. wants theme. We don't need that level of sharpness, but if a ww'er wants it and has a fat enough wallet, then God bless 'em. It's just that I see an awful lot of posts on many of these forums asking about these expensive, unnecessary items. 99% of the time I just lurk and keep my mouth shut, because the chances are good that the poster has already made up his or her mind that they're going to make the purchase anyway, and are simply looking for other satisfied customers in order to justify the transaction. If the end result makes them happy...

I won't argue the metallurgic (is that a word?) aspect of edge retention, etc., because I don't have the scientific background to do so. I'm just basing my former statemtent(s) on my personal experience.

RR

Re: Is David Charlesworth Too Good

#20

David Charlesworth has.. *LINK*

HC Sakman

>taken the "maintenance and upkeep" (as I'd generalize) of hand tools to a different level.

Both of his books are pretty much dedicated to that.

What I really liked about his books were; He mentioned in great depth some of the details which do make a world of difference. I'd never seen these fine points talked about anywhere else except places like BP and WC forums.

Practicality of his methods though.... are a matter of practice like many other things. Excellence is very easy habit to form. Once you own it, it's hard to go back to ordinary and many things appear to be sub-standart.

HCS


My new place

Re: Is David Charlesworth Too Good

#21

Re: The times they are a-changin' (long) *LINK*

Derek Cohen (in Perth, Australia)

>Hi Richard

I must take issue with you on a few points.

You wrote: "The wood doesn't know what the bevel angle is, or even if the iron is bevel-up or bevel-down for that matter." .... I agree

...but you also wrote "The reason a block plane is bevel-up is because it needs to be, not because it cuts end grain any better. The lower angle of block planes requires this. If the bevel were up, then the cutting edge could not contact the wood at this lower angle".... Here I must totally disagree. A block plane is bevel up to reduce the cutting angle. It has only been a recent phenomenon that we have increased the bevel angle of the bevel up blade to create a high cutting angle. Traditionally they have been honed at 25 degrees which, along with a 12 degree bed, creates a low cutting angle. Yes, you can cut end grain with a HA blade, but you do this so much better with a LA one.

You also stated, "But if these new designs require such a high degree of precision that we need a jig just to sharpen and hone the irons, count me out. I can produce just as nice a surface with a 100-year-old relic, a high-carbon iron, and a bit of hand-honing".... That is your choice, as it is the choice we all have, and will continue to have. As I mentioned before, I try my best to reduce sharpening time to a minimum. When I use bevel down planes, I freehand all my blades. However, I do also use the new era bevel up planes - because they are so damn good, and very little works as well on Australian hardwoods at the price. Until you have experienced this, you really will not appreciate the importance of this new generation of planes. And to this end I will search for the quickest route to a sharp blade, a route that does not compromise the design of the plane, or its efficiency.

The other matter is whether 15K or 30K (and similar) grits is necessary. My opinion is that they are not. In fact I posted to this extent a short while back ("My sharpening philosophy"). The question is "what is SMOOTH enough for the task at hand"? Well, chisels do need to be sharp but not necessary to have as smooth an edge as smoother plane. Similarly, a scrub plane really could just be honed to 1200 waterstone. It should cut as well as a 8000 stone, but the edge will just not last as long (depending on the timber used). Theoretically, a lot of sharpening time could be saved in this area. But in the real world we continue to hone to higher-than-necessary levels. It would be interesting to read the opinion of others in this regard. I do not recall having done so before.

Regards from Perth

Derek


Link to "sharpening strategy".

Re: Is David Charlesworth Too Good

#22

A Wonderful Philosophy for Life

Bob Hutchins in central TX

>Howdy Moses!

You very plainly exposed a philosophy that holds well across endeavors far beyond woodworking. Education, career, peronal relationships, spirituality, character and personal integrity -- the list could go on and on -- all are areas where your philosophy would be profitably applied.

Thank you for an excellently considered and formulated view. I for one, believe it worthwhile and try to follow it.

BobH

Re: Is David Charlesworth Too Good

#23

W. B. Yeats...

Frank D. in Montreal

>said this somewhere:

A young boy watched his dad spend long days building a stone wall, making sure every stone fit perfectly. The boy asked his dad: "Why put so much time and effort in building a dumb stone wall?" The man replied: "Because I'll have to spend the next 40 years looking at it."

Re: Is David Charlesworth Too Good

#24

Re: The times they are a-changin' (long)

Richard R

>Derek,

You wrote:

A block plane is bevel up to reduce the cutting angle...

Another case of me not being thorough in my post. Yes, a lower angle of attack is needed to slice through end grain cleanly. But, the bevel must be up in order to accomplish this lower angle. It's physically impossible to lower the angle to the standard 12 degrees (or any angle lower than the iron's bevel angle, actually) and have the bevel down. The only part of the plane's sole that would be usable would be the portion in front of the mouth. A moot point, anyway, but I just wanted to clarify what I initially meant.

RR

Re: Is David Charlesworth Too Good

#25

Re: 30,000 grit stones?

James Watriss

>I hear ya. The ability to get a vacuum seal on a stone is not something that should really be a selling point to anyone who uses good stones, and I've seen a lot of garbage come and go, too. I work at an unnamed woodworking store that bases a lot of their business on chinese and 3rd-world-made merchandise that is either needless gadgetry, or garbage, or oftentimes both.

That said, I'm also a student at the North Bennet Street School, and I learn a lot there, too, about the value of keeping things sharp, and a lot of techniques that make almost all of the gadgety junk look absolutely redundant, if not entirely useless.

I fall into the category of someone who gives a lot of things a chance, simply because I don't mind spending the money on something if it seems like a good idea. It's a philosophy that's let me down a few times, but it's also brought to my attention that sometimes there ARE new things under the sun, so it's good to keep looking.

I don't know much about metallurgy either. I think a 30,000 grit stone being used on something that can't hold an edge, like a marples chisel, is useless and wasted effort, because that's a tool that can't and won't hold that edge.

That said, I also go for the romantic idea that was widespread in Japan regarding the honor that should be given to one's tools. They are the means by which many people make their living. So it's only justified that they be given proper attention by the owner.

In the age of semi-disposable power tools, it's a debatable issue whether that's still the case. I know some carpenters that would feel fine tossing out a $150 circ saw after a year or two, figuring they got their use from the tool. At the same time, there are people who will spend a little less than that on a very good handsaw, and have it last them far longer. They'll put in a little time once in a while to get it sharp again, and go back out and use it some more.

And then again, there are also people who will spend $300 on a Lie-Nielsen plane without accepting that they might need to tune the thing up from time to time. So who knows, really.

I guess it's just ongoing commentary about the modern mentality shift, and the counterculture that naturally seems to spring up around any trend.