WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

My Spoonmaking Attempts

Posts

My Spoonmaking Attempts

#1

My Spoonmaking Attempts

Jim Crammond in Monroe, Mi

>After the spoonmaking exercise was discussed on the Hand Tool forum, I started thinking about the approach I would take to make a spoon. Because of my experience making ladder back chairs, I thought that working the wood green would be easiest. I outlined the procedure in my mind after doing a little research via the internet.

For wood selection I choose a piece of apple otherwise destined to be firewood that had been cut around New Year, so it was still fairly wet. The piece was about 3 inches in diameter and I cut it to a 13� length. After starting a split right in the center of the limb with a hatchet, it was rived with a froe and mallet. The piece split cleanly with no runout. I then sketched the shape of a spoon on the surface of the wood. My plan was to saw around the wood at the base of the bowl and rive off the excess of the handle. I had problems with holding the limb to rive it, so I went right to the shaving horse and drawknife. In retrospect, it probably would have been quicker to waste away some more wood with the hatchet at this point.

I then roughed out the spoon with the drawknife and cleaned it up with a wooden body spokeshave. So far I had spent about 50 minutes on the spoon.

To hollow out the bowl, I planned on wasting out as much as I could with a brace and bit, but I realized this would leave holes from the leadscrew and since I don�t have any spoon bits, I proceeded to a gouge. This stage actually went pretty quickly, in about 20 minutes I had a spoon, albeit a rough one.

The wood was too wet to proceed with any further refining of the spoon, so I put the other half of the log, the spoon and all of the shavings in a paper bag with the hope that it would dry slowly and not crack or otherwise deform.

All in all, I was satisfied with my first attempt. It took about 1 hour and ten minutes, it resembled a spoon and I learned a few things to try on the next attempt at making a spoon from green would.

In my second attempt with green wood, I did more shaping with a hatchet, roughing out the handle and bowl with it. The spoon shown in the picture is the result of an hour of work. At this point the spoon needs to be dried out in order to smooth the surface.


img

Re: My Spoonmaking Attempts

#2

Re: My Spoonmaking Attempts 

Jim Crammond in Monroe, Mi

>


img

Re: My Spoonmaking Attempts

#3

Second Approach

Jim Crammond in Monroe, Mi

>After making a spoon with green wood, I decided to approach the process in a different manner. I choose some air dried cherry, drew an outline of the spoon, hollowed out the bowl while the stock was still roughly square, sawed out the outline of the spoon using a turning saw, cleaned it up using spokeshaves and finally sanding it to an acceptable surface.

In my first attempt, after an hour the spoon was roughed out, but not what I would consider usable. I took another half hour to clean it up and make it a usable spoon. My stock selection for the second attempt was not as good. This piece of wood had some grain reversals and a hidden crack that resulted in the removal of more stock than I would have liked. I stopped after an hour on this one. I suppose it could be used, but it is not as refined as I would like.


img

Re: My Spoonmaking Attempts

#4

Re: Second Approach

Jim Crammond in Monroe, Mi

>This last picture shows all four spoons I made. The two spoons on the left are made of cherry with the outside spoon being the first attempt. The two spoons on the right are the apple examples with the outside spoon being the first attempt.

I found many good resources about spoonmaking both on the internet and in print. Del Stubbs� site: www.pinewoodforge.com has a number of links to sites that show some incredible examples of spoons and links for tools used in spoonmaking. Roy Underhill�s The Woodwright�s Workbook and Drew Langsner�s Country Woodcraft both have short sections that address the subject. I though it was interesting that both of these mentioned that traditionally, spoonmaking was an activity that was done at night after dinner or at times of bad weather kind when there were other things that could be done but instead you could take it easy, work on a spoon and not be criticized for goofing off or being lazy because the recipient of the gift of a spoon was normally the person who may be critical.

I have to say that I enjoyed this challenge a lot. I doubt that I would have tried making a spoon if Dave C. had not brought up the subject. The one hour limit makes the project interesting and forces you to think through the process to work as efficiently as possible. It also allows some valuable information to be discussed as a group. However, when I make spoons in the future I will ignore any kind of time limit. I felt rushed through the whole process and I am not really happy with the results because of rushing. In my opinion, it limits my enjoyment of the process.


img

Re: My Spoonmaking Attempts

#5

Re: Second Approach

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Definitely above and beyond, Jim. Strangely, I think the first attempt (left most spoon) looks the best.

Pam

Re: My Spoonmaking Attempts

#6

Agreed

Jim Crammond in Monroe, Mi

>Pam,

I agree, I think the proportions are the best of the group and I did take more time with this one so it is more refined looking.

Jim

Re: My Spoonmaking Attempts

#7

Re: Second Approach

Greg Betit, Crown Point NY

>I agree, the hour time limit is a fun thing to do for one spoon, but I wouldn't want to stay in the "production" mode each time I make one. For me it is something to do while I think through the next step in something else, or something to do when I know I only have a short time in the shop.

Greg

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.