WoodCentral Forums

Est. 1998 — 27 years of woodworking knowledge

spoon contest rules?

Posts

spoon contest rules?

#1

spoon contest rules?

mike recchione

>I set out to make a one hour spoon from firewood today, and got about 40 minutes into it when the spoon snapped in two at the bowl/handle joint. Oh well.

One problem is that it's April, I'm down to the end of the firewood store, and there isn't much in the way of worthwhile wood left. I noticed that one person had made his spoon from 2x stock. Is that allowed for the contest? I'd like to use 5/4 or 8/4 cherry because it's fun to carve. If it is allowed to use lumberyard wood rather than a log, is there a time limit adjustment that we'd have to make to compensate for not having to deal with splitting the log or removing bark, and for already having a flat surface to work with?

Re: spoon contest rules?

#2

Re: spoon contest rules?

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>First, think challenge rather than contest. Of course you can start with milled lumber, no time adjustment. Not everyone has logs laying about; but for those who do, if you like, start the clock after you've milled the log.

Sorry about your split, what a bummer.

Pam

Re: spoon contest rules?

#3

Re: spoon contest rules?

mike recchione

>"Sorry about your split, what a bummer."

Thanks, Pam. But it was a lot of fun, anyway. I haven't had much shop time in a while, and what I have had I've used to make hand spindles for my wife and her spinning guild. This is lathe work - enjoyable and rewarding, but not particularly physical. It was nice to do some woodworking that involved swinging axes and mauls and mallets for a change. Makes me feel like spring is really coming, even if the weather hasn't realized it yet.

I'll try to find a nice scrap of something - I got to thinking that I've been wanting a good pancake spoon for a long time.

Re: spoon contest rules?

#4

Oh, that sinking feeling...

CONGER - The Irish diaspora in Munich

>... snap..., and you think that the bowl wont even make a useable eggcup!

-g- who extends his sympathy, because he has been there so often!

Re: spoon contest rules?

#5

Crafts Auction-OT

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>Mike,

Are you going to the crafts auction? If so I'll throw some dogwood, or apple (I may have pear) into my car for you. If you're not, but Jeremy is, maybe he'd be nice enough to transport some pieces of wood for you.

Let me know if you're interested (or anyone who's going to the auction for that matter) any time before then.

Adam

Re: spoon contest rules?

#6

Re: Crafts Auction-OT

mike recchione

>Hi Adam,

Thanks so much for the offer. I've got some dogwood (semi-dry by now - maybe 4 years old or so?), but would love to try apple if you've got some to spare. I didn't realize dogwood is non-toxic for cooking, but I guess it is. I hadn't considered using it for spoons. It's not the easiest wood to work, but I've been keeping this stash for things like turned mallets and chisel handles, which it's really good for.

When is the CRAFTS auction? If I can't make it there, I still plan to come visit you at Pennsbury one of these weekends.

- Mike

Re: spoon contest rules?

#7

Is dogwood toxic?

Adam Cherubini, NJ

>Mike,

I don't know about dogwood, or even apple for that matter. Do people spray stuff on apple that would make it unsuitable for use as a spoon? I guess if you can eat the apples, you should be able to lick the wood. Yikes! Maybe one of our chemists will chime in here.

Pretty sure we have some pear at Pennsbury. And you're welcome to my apple. Let me know when you are coming and I'll be sure the manor joinery is well stocked and our axes are sharpened!

Crafts auction is a week from Saturday in Flemington NJ.

Adam

Re: spoon contest rules?

#8

I don't think so.

mike recchione

>I Googled dogwood toxicity and the usual suspects said either "undetermined" or "non-toxic". Apple is definitely non-toxic - it's used for smoking meats, etc.

Thanks again for the apple - I'm not sure how hard it is to work, but it's got to be easier to work than dogwood with hand tools. And it sure looks pretty when it ages. Is the pear you have the fruitwood, or Bradford Pear? Bradford Pear isn't really a pear at all. Like dogwood, it's excellent mallet and chisel handle wood - takes a good pounding. Come to think of it, apple makes nice saw handles, molding planes and chisel handles. And spoons :-)

- Mike

Re: spoon contest rules?

#9

Re: I don't think so.

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>I love to turn dogwood. It is very well behaved, and finishes very smoothly. I make all sorts of tool handles, bottle stoppers, carving mallets, etc. out of it, but have not tried carving it or working it in other ways.

I find apple to be easy to work. It has a lot of the characteristics of cherry, but seems to be a bit softer, and the colors are somewhat more muted.

Re: spoon contest rules?

#10

Dogwood

mike recchione

>I had heard (maybe from Saint Roy?) that dogwood was used for weaving shuttles, bearings, etc - i.e. moving parts. I think the explanation was that it gets more slippery as it wears, providing what amounts to natural lubrication. I've been planning to try it for a spinning wheel flyer assembly. I also love to turn it. It isn't the prettiest wood in the world, but it's got other good qualities. And it sure can take a beating.

Re: spoon contest rules?

#11

Lilac

Greg B�tit, Vergennes, VT

>I made a couple spoons out of lilac. I had to work with small branchy pieces, which was difficult and made the finished pieces susceptible to reaction cracks. But the wood is hard and you can come across an occasional streak of purple in the smooth white wood. The purple stays, unlike the spectacular colors of other woods like box elder. If the spoon is given to someone who is mourning the loss of a cherished ice destroyed lilac bush, it's a real point-getter. Just don't blow it by giving the second spoon to her sister. DAMHINT.

Greg

Re: spoon contest rules?

#12

Re: Dogwood

Jim Reed @Tallahassee

>Dogwood was used for loom shuttles because the surface finishes nice and tight--no little fibers to snag the thread. It turns easily and polishes up well.

Re: spoon contest rules?

#13

Lilac is a pleasure to work too.

Bob Hackett

>It a shame that it`s so unstable and prone to cracking.

I`ve made chisel handles and small bowls from some very old and colorful local wood.75% warped and cracked in drying even after being riven and the end grain sealed.

It does make nice treen though,some of my wife`s favorites.

MB

👍 This page answered my questions

Your vote helps other woodworkers quickly find the answers and techniques that actually work in the shop.