Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Price drop on over 1300 Rockler items

Washita Lily White Stone; First Impression

Posts

Washita Lily White Stone; First Impression

#1

Washita Lily White Stone; First Impression

Patrick Gibbons, Houston, TX

>When Joel first announced he had Lily White Washitas for sale in February I purchased one and have used it in a number of situations. When I bought it I felt it was a frivolous purchase and figured it was one of those guilty pleasures I wouldn't admit to in public. After about a month of light use, I am no longer ashamed of my impulse buy. This stone fills a niche and does it quite well. For most of my edge tools, I use the old standby combination of fine India and Hard Arkansas followed by a leather strap. As most here know, Joel has a tutorial on his website, Tools for Working Wood. The time I usually spend on the Arkansas is longer than I like but is necessary to chase the wire burr. Experimenting with the Lily White has led me to conclude that using the Washita as an intermediary step between the India and the Arkansas is actually faster than using just the two original stones. I use the Washita the same as the Arkansas, on both the back and the bevel of the blade. I have used the Washita in place of the Arkansas and it produces a fine edge that will suffice for chopping and a quick resharpen of a dulled edge when I'm in a hurry to finish. I have used the Washita alone and found it to be acceptable when the keenest of edges is not necessary and the edge itself is not abused. The same is true when the Washita is substituted for the India and the blade is finished off with the Arkansas. However when the blade is worn, the India is the best place to start. The Washita is really a finishing stone, not one to expose new steel and form a burr. When a marking knife or awl needs to be sharpened, the Washita is a one-stop solution that produces an edge that is more than good enough.

A2 steel is a horse of a different color. I have sharpened plane blades made by Veritas and Lie-Nielsen with oilstones and have been pleased with the results. However it takes a bit longer to get the job done on A2 than other steels that I have in the shop. The Washita works in the same way on A2 as it does on tool steel, just slower. An exception is the one Lie-Nielsen mortise chisel I have. I have not been able to turn a wire burr on this chisel with oilstones though it did sharpen up easily. I hope to post a review of some mortise chisels I've used later.

I have not owned the Lily White long enough to judge its longevity. I have no dishing of the stone but it's only been about 45 days. It is more porous than an Arkansas and soaks up a bit more oil. It has a pleasant tooth to the surface in use and does polish the edge somewhat. These are my impressions, yours may vary.

Re: Washita Lily White Stone; First Impression

#2

Re: Washita Lily White Stone; First Impression

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Patrick, great info. Have you tried the Washita without oil?

Pam

Re: Washita Lily White Stone; First Impression

#3

Re: Washita Lily White Stone; First Impression

Greg Betit, Crown Point NY

>My washita lilly white hasn't made it into the shop yet. I use it for touching up the kitchen knives. I use water for this, before I use the knife I run water over the stone, and run the knife over it, and wipe them both off before I use/put away. I'm not so used to such sharp tools in the kitchen; I'm going to have to be more careful.

Re: Washita Lily White Stone; First Impression

#4

Cool.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>

Re: Washita Lily White Stone; First Impression

#5

Re: Washita Lily White Stone; First Impression

Patrick Gibbons, Houston, TX

>Pam, no I haven't. Please elaborate.

Re: Washita Lily White Stone; First Impression

#6

Re: Washita Lily White Stone; First Impression

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>I think I recall Joel saying he used his without water or oil, sometimes uses water.

Pam

Re: Washita Lily White Stone; First Impression

#7

Re: Washita Lily White Stone; First Impression

Patrick Gibbons, Houston, TX

>Thanks Pam. I see what you're after. I have a fear of glazing this stone. It is somewhat porous. I don't really want to experiment with my stone to find out.

Re: Washita Lily White Stone; First Impression

#8

Re: Washita Lily White Stone; First Impression

Joel

>I use mine with water - (I tried oil also which works fine, maybe better, but now the stone is mostly in the kitchen and water makes more sense. )

Dry the stone would load

Re: Washita Lily White Stone; First Impression

#9

Washita Lily White Stone; spec question

Jim Brown

>Hey Joel, how similar are these new stones to the very old originals we see on the 'bay? Same quarry, etc? Thanks.

Re: Washita Lily White Stone; First Impression

#10

Re: Washita Lily White Stone; spec question

joel

>Same company, same quarry, same stone. The one customer who had old stones to compare to says that the quality is exactly the same.

Re: Washita Lily White Stone; First Impression

#11

Thanks, Joel.

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>