Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Have a question? Ask Woody!

Two Cherries - quality question - is 10.6mm = 10mm

Posts

Two Cherries - quality question - is 10.6mm = 10mm

#1

Two Cherries - quality question - is 10.6mm = 10mm

CONGER - the Irish diaspora in Munich

>I recently bought a 2C mortice chisel (10mm) and 2C swan-neck mortice chisel (10mm).

I now find that the swan-neck is NOT 10mm... it is 10.6mm and does NOT fit into the mortice I make with the 'normal' 2C mortice chisel!

Is this acceptable?

Is this to be put down to 'hand tools need to be tuned'?

Personally I think it is nonsense... surely a manufacturer can get a standard size like 10mm RIGHT.

Your opinions please.

-g-

Re: Two Cherries - quality question - is 10.6mm = 10mm

#2

Re: Two Cherries - quality question - is 10.6mm =

Pam Niedermayer - Austin, TX

>Forging metal is no more an exact science than woodworking, lots of places for imprecision to raise its ugly head. I'd suggest grinding to fit.

Pam

Re: Two Cherries - quality question - is 10.6mm = 10mm

#3

Re: Two Cherries - quality question - is 10.6mm =

Dar

>It certainly looks like the Two Cherries swan neck chisel you have is way out of tolerance. I recommend that you exchange it with the retailer where you bought it.

Darlene

European Hand Tools

Canadian Importers for Two Cherries

Re: Two Cherries - quality question - is 10.6mm = 10mm

#4

Re: Two Cherries - quality question - is 10.6mm =

Stephen Dalfollo-Daley

>Ultimately you are the final QA inspector...if it is not up to par I would return them and ask they be at least matched...

surely they can do better than 6% error...

Re: Two Cherries - quality question - is 10.6mm = 10mm

#5

Re: Two Cherries - quality question - is 10.6mm =

Christof Hartge

>Hello Conger,

I Just controlled my Two-Cherry Chisels and Mortise Chisels. According to my micrometer they have tolerances at about 0,03 mm, which means that the average of my chisels are twenty times more precise than the swan neck chisel.

I'd send the swan neck chisel back to the retailer if he is a good one, or, if not, send it directly back to Two cherries. I've heard good things about their customer service.

Wilh. Schmitt & Comp.

K�nigstra�e 59

42853 Remscheid

or

Postfach 13 04 28

42819 Remscheid

and the web link: http://www.kirschen.de/

Christof.

Re: Two Cherries - quality question - is 10.6mm = 10mm

#6

Re: Two Cherries - quality question - is 10.6mm =

CONGER - The Irish diaspora in Munich

>Thanks for the response Christof.

The supplier was 'unser Hausherrn'. He kindly offered a replacement. I refused because I have in-betweentimes ground the chisel down to 10.05mm. This is close enough for my slightly oversized 10mm mortices ;-))

It is however peculiar that a well-respected german manufacturer would have such sloppy quality control... or do they even have quality control if things like this get shipped!

I do hope that they will learn... It is insufficient to learn like ULMIA did... namely TOO LATE!

Now those chisels from Lie Nielsen.....

-g-

Re: Two Cherries - quality question - is 10.6mm = 10mm

#7

Well...

Scott in Douglassville, PA

>...while I'd agree that forging isn't an exact science, I'd say that milling and finishing is a precise one, and that the chisel in question sounds way out of spec. If it's not a QC issue, I'd look for another manufacturer. But that's me.

Scott, who expects precision, but not always accuracy