Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Identify and use hundreds of woods

I saw the light! (Looooooong)

Posts

I saw the light! (Looooooong)

#1

I saw the light! (Looooooong)

Dave Caudill

>On the tips of the saw teeth I had just joined that is. I just finished up the big kitchen remodel at home and have been meaning to get caught up on tool cleaning, sharpening etc. Well one of the things bugging me was all those dull saws hanging on the wall each time I walked into the garage. I had all of the tools to file them, the vices, files, joining tool, lights, radio. You know the essentials. What I didn't have was the experience or the confidence to do them. Having either of these might have led to the other.

Well I made up my mind I was going to try a couple. Did I mention I had filed a couple saws a couple years back? Well I had and I wasn't impressed. They were a 5 1/2 rip and something else with large teeth. I ended up with teeth of all shapes and sizes. They were sharp but I sure was dissappointed. After that experince I sent several of my saws to Tom Law with the obvious results.

Well I was speaking with Tom a couple weeks ago and I told him since he was no longer in the business I was going to try my hand at it again. He was encouraging. I told him I had an 8 PPI x-cut, a Disston D-12 I was going to practice on. He said, a what? I told him again a D-12 Lighweight and he said you'd better put that one away as they are quite scarce and I should practice on something else. He said there was talk a while back whether or not this saw even existed, it does. So I took his advice and found another victim.

After a few days I had several sharp saws and was much happier with the results of my work. The first one was a bit rough. It was a 6 PPI x-cut and again it was a little ragged when done but sharp. Next I tried a 9 PPI x-cut and it looked better then anotheer and another and a 10 PPI and an 11 PPI and finally a 13 PPI backsaw all crosscut. Turned out great.

What I found out and as I talked with Tom about later was that the recommendation you often hear to start with a very large tooth saw might not be the best recommendation. The shaping which in my mind is the most difficult part can be quite difficult with large toothed saws. You are taking off a lot more material and it makes it more difficult in my estimation when your filing skills aren't that refined. I don't think you should start with a 16 PPI backsaw but a 9, 10 or 11 is not that bad you can still see the teeth fairly well yet you don't have to take as much material off minimizing the risk to some degree.

The key as Pete Taran mentions in his article on filing is watching both teeth as you file to make sure you are taking the proper amount of material off each too so that you end up with evenly sized teeth. I use sight black to darken the teeth so that you can see the joined tips clearly and the filed edges.

The angles are pretty easy and don't have to be exact and you can use several methods to help in getting those correct. I know a lot of you out there already do your saw sharpening and are saying, "Big Deal". This is not for you this is for the others like me who have been reluctant to "ruin" a perfectly good saw. Well you won't ruin them you'll just deform them a bit. That can be fixed. So have at it I think you will be surprised with the results after a couple saws.

Dave

Re: I saw the light! (Looooooong)

#2

Re: I saw the light! (Looooooong)

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native in FL. Exile :~(

>Need more info Dave. What did you use for a sawset, and what did you learn with it? What files did you use for specific teeth? I've got conflicting sizes from 3 different sources, (T.Law, H.Payson, and H. Disston)and am leaning heavily towards what tom recommends. Did you have any problems with the saw not cutting straight afterwards? Congrats on your success.

I finally won a saw jointer from $bay, now I just need to gather a few files and I'm all set.

Now that the kitchen is done are you going to start on the bathrooms? ;~)

Todd O.

Re: I saw the light! (Looooooong)

#3

D-12 Lighweight

Ernie Miller Topeka

>can you post a picture? what is the differance between it and a D12? is it the etch? size? I'm hoping I find a dozen D12 this rust season. I'm off to an estate sale in a few minutes.

Re: I saw the light! (Looooooong)

#4

Re: I saw the light! (Looooooong)

Dave Caudill

>Hi Todd. Well I'm sure I learned somethin in all of this. I think as I said yesterday you really have to watch both teeth as you are filing so you get even sized symetric teeth. Use good files and don't try and sharpen too many on the same file. And of course patience, which is often my downfall.

I used a Stanley 42 sawset and it worked nicely. There are lots of others that I'm sure work as well. Once in a while it pops off the teeth and its a pain but it happens. I asked Tom Law about that and he said it happens to him too. I think its because they made the sawset to set teeth from 4 PPI to 16 PPI and the one size fits all thing might not be the best way to go. But it works for the most part. Again patience.

The files I used were Simonds files that I had purchased from Pete Taran a few years ago and they worked pretty well. Tom Law told me he no longer uses Simonds files because so many of them are defective. He now uses the Sandvik files Pete sells. I've yet to try them but I have some on order. As far as size goes I use the sizing that Pete recommends on his website www.vintagesaws.com. I think you can get away with different files though as long as they fit inside the teeth.

I did take some photos of my D-12 although they aren't very spectacular. I'll try and attach one to this and see what happens. The saw itself is nothing special either. Maybe thats why they are so scarce. I think that is pretty common with a lot of old tools. The ones that are so valuable are often those that never were that popular or worked that well so they disappeared quickly.

My saw vise is an old Disston that I picked up somewhere. I like the old vises you just have to make sure the jaws close tight and straight so that they hold your saw well. A lot of the old vises have been broke and you see a lot of them that have been welded. So be careful on what you are buying. You can make one as well although I haven't done this.

Other than that start filing and start slow don't get in too big a hurry. After a couple saws you will be suprprised. Even the ugly ones usually work better than they did before the filing.

After I got the hang of it I found it really satisfying to go out to the garage and file a saw. Its nice to see those teeth reshaped and shiny and sharp.

Dave

Dave


img

Re: I saw the light! (Looooooong)

#5

Re: D-12 Lighweight

Todd O. Cronkhite Maine Native in FL. Exile :~(

>Thanks for the add'l info Dave, it was very enlightning. Little extra bits of info like that coming from a beginner can be of particular interest to other beginners as the Pro's may have so much experiance that they may tend to forget some of the "little problems" that a beginner may encounter. Bet Pete's file sales increase 10 fold now eh? I bought a few Simonds because that is what Tom said he used, so I fiqured if it's good enough for Tom, than that's what I'll use. Now he's onto Sandvik's. Glad I asked.

I had a D-12 and didn't like it, so I busted it up for scrapers.

OK, that wasn't true, I just said it to bust Ernie's chops. ;~)

Todd O.

Re: I saw the light! (Looooooong)

#6

Re: D-12 Lighweight

Ernie Miller Topeka

>Todd I have one that you can bust up if you want. as there are some serious problems. there is about 1/2" out of the blade down by the custom open handle.

Budget, Ned said budget, HAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA! HA! HA! Silly boy. ;~)

Re: I saw the light! (Looooooong)

#7

Nicholson files

Luke Herzberg

>I was figuring to order a few more saw files in the near future and thought Nicholson was the only option until reading this thread. On the vintagesaws site where he mentions decline in domestic files, I assume that means Nicholson?

Incidentally, does anybody but Nicholson make an auger bit file?