Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Good Hope Hardwoods - Walnut Slabs & Specialty Hardwood Lumber

Adria vs LN Dovetail Saw

Posts

Adria vs LN Dovetail Saw

#1

Adria vs LN Dovetail Saw

Gerald A. Poppke

>Can anyone compare the Adria dovetail saw with the Lie-Nielsen. I'm not only interested in the blade comparison but the handles as well. I have fairly long fingers. Thanks. Gerald

Re: Adria vs LN Dovetail Saw

#2

Jim in Burlington Ont.

Re: Adria vs LN Dovetail Saw

Jim in Burlington Ontario

>I have one of each and my longest finger is 3 1/4" long both are very comfortable for me. The adria cuts a little faster and seems to be a few ounces heavier but I have never weighed them. Seems to me that the Adria handle is ever so slightly larger.

Re: Adria vs LN Dovetail Saw

#3

Re: LN Handle

Dave Mount

>I have the LN DT, but have never handled an Adria, so I can't complete the comparison. But. . .

I have hands that I think one would call large, but not chubby. I just measured my right hand, and it is right about 4" from side to side across the middle. This is relevant because the stock LN handle is a little snug for me between the horns, not fatal, but a little irritating (not enough to keep me from loving the saw, however).

I e-mailed LN one time and asked if it was possible to get a bigger handle. They said if I sent specific instructions on how I wanted it altered, they'd make a custom handle for an additional $25. I haven't followed up as yet.

I have heard before the comment above, that the Adria handles are slightly larger, but can't confirm that from my own experience. Might be a factor for those with large hands if it's true.

My $0.02,

Dave

Re: Adria vs LN Dovetail Saw

#4

Re: LN Handle

Erik in NC

>Gerald,

Like Dave, I found LN more than happy to accomodate strange handle requests! In my case, my hands are also burdened with long fingers. As a consequence, I found most handles ever so slightly cramping. I asked LN to sned me a saw with an unfinished handle (cut, fitted, but without varnish). They were more than happy to comply. I spent about three hours with a rasp and a spokeshave, three more with sandpaper, and then used a couple of coats of walnut oil. It resulted in a saw handle that fits like a glove.

Just a thought, since LN will accomodate almost any request...

Erik

Re: Adria vs LN Dovetail Saw

#5

Re: Adria vs LN Dovetail Saw *LINK*

Mike-in-Havertown

>Hello Gerald,

I have the Adria dovetail saw and it is a beaut. I have just started the long slippery slope down to the neander level and I got a good deal on the saw (used once and 50% off), so I jumped on it.

It is a great saw and you will not be disappointed. However I think you are overlooking another option. The Spehar mentions that they will fit the saw to your hand provided you give them the measurements. They are right on price with Adria and LN.

I have nothing vested in this company just sharing info.

Work safely,

Mike-in-Havertown


Another Choice

Re: Adria vs LN Dovetail Saw

#6

Re: Adria vs LN Dovetail Saw

Ron

>I have the Independence pair and they are beautiful and tremendous tools. I have big hands too and the Adria does fit better.

Back a few years ago when I was hosting Kokomo Galoot fests, we had a saw off and the Adria is a very fine tool and if fits a big hand better

Ron

Re: Adria vs LN Dovetail Saw

#7

Re: Adria vs LN Dovetail Saw

Gerald A. Poppke

>Mike, I tried to e-mail you directly on something off-subject but it would not go through. Anyway, are you in Havertown PA? One of my clients is the Daniel J. Keating Co. in Narberth PA.

Re: Adria vs LN Dovetail Saw

#8

Re: Adria vs LN Dovetail Saw

Gerald A. Poppke

>I would like to thank everyone for your input. I'm leaning toward the Adria, but, I have to say that I like the curly maple handle on the LN.

Re: Adria vs LN Dovetail Saw

#9

Re: Adria vs LN Dovetail Saw

Todd Stock

>I have reasonably big hands/long fingers and the IT/LN fits fine with the standard 3 finger grip.

Either saw should work.

Re: Adria vs LN Dovetail Saw

#10

Re: Adria vs LN Dovetail Saw

Gerald A. Poppke

>Not so quick, another saw is in the mix. I followed Mike-in-Havertown's recommendation and went to Spehar's website - very interesting. Anyone have any experience with thier dovetail saw? I did a search here any no reviews in the last year. Thanks, GP