Home Articles Forums Gallery Marketplace Videos

WoodCentral Forums

Knowledge You Can Build On — Est. 1998

Support WoodCentral when buying things you need

Work bench use photos & comments *LINK*

Posts

Work bench use photos & comments *LINK*

#1

Work bench use photos & comments *LINK*

Alan Bierbaum

>This posting was expedited by last night's hand tool chat room conversations.

After using my bench, and answering questions from internet viewers on the bench page, I am starting to compile some information for publication on this page. I will update / modify this page based on comments received.

My bench is sized to fit my work area and the expected use of the bench. Without vises, the top is 35" deep and 84" wide. Depth across the face vise (without handle) is 45 1/2" and length across the closed tail vise (without handle) is 89". The tool tray is 7" wide (part of the 35" depth) and 2 1/2" deep. The bench is 35 1/2" high (to match my table saw height). My barefoot palm height is 34 1/2". The longest piece that I can clamp in the tail vise is 84". The face vise front (movable) face is 11 1/4" wide. Dog holes are rectangular and are 2 3/4" from the bench edge.

My bench is used for hand tool and power tool applications. It is also my sanding and assembly table. The depth of 35" allows me to assemble three foot objects (like a desk) without having to use a secondary top for support. This depth also allows me to work parts and still have the final product remain on the bench top (pushed to the side/back). There is room all around the top the allow clamping objects to the top.

Do I like it? YES ! Would I do some things differently? YES. Based on my constraints; the only thing that I would change is to move the dog holes closer to the front edge. This would allow moulding plane use on narrow boards clamped by the tail vise. If I had the room; I would make the bench longer. It would be nice to be able to clamp 8' (or longer) boards with the tail vise. For sawing dovetails (in the face vise) and chopping dovetails (near the tail vise); I would like the bench to be several inches taller (easier on my back). Using hand planes would be easier if the bench was 2-3" lower. For my work; I would not change the basic design. The only change that I made from the original is to add three drawers above the lower support stretches. The original shelf collected junk and the drawers hide the junk. The drawers also act as supports for long stock clamped in the face vise for edge jointing. This saves me from making a sliding board jack or building a separate support for long boards. The finish is several coats of WaterLox followed by several coats of paste wax. I rewax about every six months. I cleans up nicely. The top is still within a few thousands of flat and has not been resurfaced (a heated and air conditioned shop probably helped).

In the following link:

The following pictures are taken from some recent project pictures (they are not staged) and show actual bench usage for me. There are some holes in the usage pictures as I do not have pictures of all of the uses for my bench. There is no real sequence to the pictures.


Web page with pictures - Large pictures

Re: Work bench use photos & comments *LINK*

#2

Thanks, Alan....

Frank Mutchler in Colorado Springs

>I appreciate all the time you've taken to share your experience. Do you ever get down to the Springs?

Re: Work bench use photos & comments *LINK*

#3

Re: Thanks, Alan....

Alan Bierbaum

>Glad that it was interesting to you (and I hope to others).

I don't get to the Springs very often now; However I still am working one to two days a week for the same company and occasionally get to the Springs for a quick job.

Re: Work bench use photos & comments *LINK*

#4

Re: Work bench use photos & comments

Brad in Ottawa

>Thanks for sharing!

I was wondering about two things:

a) Do you joint long boards if so how is this done? Could your dog leg vise act as a hook???

b) Your flip up stops for sawing are great! Do you find it easy to work over/around the tail vise?

c) I noticed the combo plane... which one do you use?

Great looking bench, tools, storage and bowsaw!

Brad

Re: Work bench use photos & comments *LINK*

#5

Re: Work bench use photos & comments

GolfSteve in Calgary

>Thanks Alan. You've helped to push me a bit more towards a completely traditional bench.

Re: Work bench use photos & comments *LINK*

#6

Re: Work bench use photos & comments

Alan Bierbaum

>"Thanks for sharing!

I was wondering about two things:

a) Do you joint long boards if so how is this done? Could your dog leg vise act as a hook???"

Not very often. When I do, I clamp in the face vise and support the board by pulling out (partly) a drawer to support the "free" end of the board. I normally joint with a tailed jointer.

"b) Your flip up stops for sawing are great! Do you find it easy to work over/around the tail vise?"

It is easy for me, I have long arms. I would not want to cut a hundred pieces this way; I would use a tailed saw. They work well for cutting parts for joint fitting such as panel frames.

"c) I noticed the combo plane... which one do you use?

Great looking bench, tools, storage and bowsaw!"

It is a 45; normally used as a plow for 1/4" dado/groove work.

I "collect" user tools; not "show" tools. The bow saw is a "Bugbear" type and the bench is a modified Klausz design. I am glad that you like the information and hope that it helps you in some way.

Thanks,

Alan

Re: Work bench use photos & comments *LINK*

#7

Re: Work bench use photos & comments

Alan Bierbaum

>If that works for you, fine. My intent was to show some actual use of the bench. Others will find that a different style will work better for them. For the way that I work; this was a good choice.

Alan

Re: Work bench use photos & comments *LINK*

#8

Thanks for the great bench page!

Matt Williams

>

Re: Work bench use photos & comments *LINK*

#9

Shoulder Vise construction

Darin in Victoria

>Hi Allan, I'm designing and getting ready for construction of my second generation bench that is similar to yours. I'm still a little concerned about methods for attaching the large shoulder to the bench top. I was hoping that you could provide some additional details on how you attached the shoulder to the main bench top. Frank Klauz uses a threaded rod straight through the shoulder and bench top and glues all splines to the bench top. Did you do something similar or use other methods?

Re: Work bench use photos & comments *LINK*

#10

Re: Shoulder Vise construction

Alan Bierbaum

>"Frank Klauz uses a threaded rod straight through the shoulder and bench top and glues all splines to the bench top. Did you do something similar or use other methods? "

You can see the end of the rod in the fourth picture up from the bottom of the linked page. I followed Frank's method of using 1/2" threaded rod and it works well for me. Due to my bench size; I used the full 36" length of rod (both ends recessed). I used 1/2" plywood splines for all top glue ups. In order to align everything during assembly; I used a 9/16" hole (drilled with a hand drill and guide block).

Re: Work bench use photos & comments *LINK*

#11

Re: Shoulder Vise construction

Todd Stock

>Same thing here - although I did not glue on the end cap like Klausz. I tighten the threaded rod (and the other bolted connections) a couple of times a year. The shop is air conditioned, so no real expansion/crushing problems in the summer.

On my first bench ( a Tage Frid), the shoulder vise bolt was bedded in the top just past the dog strip, which is exactly where the large crack showed up the second winter after construction.

Go with the full width threaded rod.

Re: Work bench use photos & comments *LINK*

#12

Re: Shoulder Vise construction

Darin in Victoria

>Thanks guys, I was a little worried about the expansion, but maybe I'll just go for it. Klauz says that the nut will just embed when the slab expands, but I wanted to confirm with others that it wasn't a problem.

Re: Work bench use photos & comments *LINK*

#13

Re: Shoulder Vise construction

GolfSteve in Calgary

>I've often wondered about using Belleville washers for this purpose. We use these at work to keep bolts tight in metal structures that experience serious thermal expansion.

You would want several washers back to back to apply sufficient preload to keep the vice from spreading during use, but not so many washers that the wood would deform before the washers compressed when the benchtop expanded.

If I were a maniacal (mechanical) engineer I'm sure I could figure this out. This might not be a workable solution at all. In fact, according to Klausz and others, this isn't even a problem waiting to be solved.

Re: Work bench use photos & comments *LINK*

#14

Re: Shoulder Vise construction

Todd Stock

>I've used Bellevilles on free castoring aircraft landing gear to provide a preload - as you indicated, they are a potential solution. Not certain what it would take in terms of the stack and washer spec: however, with a deeper tool tray countersink, it might work, despite the high load on the rod.

Re: Work bench use photos & comments *LINK*

#15

Re: Work bench use photos & comments

Todd Stock

>Almost forgot - nice job on the bench - hope it gives as much pleasure in use as in the building.

Re: Work bench use photos & comments *LINK*

#16

Re: Shoulder Vise construction

William Duffield, on the Cohansey

>George Langford recommends Belleville springs on the bolts holding Bailey type plane totes and knobs in place for the same reason. An explanation, with some example calculations, can be found here:

Keepin' Totes from Breakin'

Of course, larger springs would be needed for a bench, and you'll have to ask a mechanical engineer to calculate how many to install on each bolt.

Re: Work bench use photos & comments *LINK*

#17

Re: Work bench use photos & comments

Alan Bierbaum

>Thanks,

30 years ago, I had the time and money to build a bench. I did not think that I "really" needed a "nice" one. 25 years ago, I needed a "nice" bench but did not have the time or money. For the last 12 years, I have been involved with kitchen remodel work and did not really need a woodworking bench.

I am glad that I finally built it and really enjoy using it. I strongly urge anyone that intends to be a furniture woodworker for the foreseeable future, to build a bench designed around their work habits and requirements.

Re: Work bench use photos & comments *LINK*

#18

Re: Shoulder Vise construction

GolfSteve in Calgary

>Wow the washers he uses are tiny. Thanks for the link.

I'm used to seeing washers that are 3-4" in diameter and about 3/16" thick :-) The last job we did we installed over 70,000 of these big washers and some poor summer student had to arrange them onto about 6000 custom machined 30mm dia. bolts in a special order - something like this: |()()(())()()|. The bolt heads were custom machined to avoid stress risers at the connection between the shank and the head.

That same summer student (along with all his buddies) had the enviable job of carrying 200 tonnes of refractory cement into a kiln using 20 litre (5 gal) pails.